Non-Reviewed Game [game over]

[light_ganski]

/scratch that. I'll give the tracker shot to a conftown or townread. Won't say who

[RAS]

You can just hammer, I'm not going to be explaining my reads today. I've no reason to.

[Elsa Jay]

Hammer.

You're wish is my command.

VOTE: Ofhrz

[light_ganski]

Stop. Hammertime.

VOTE: ofrhz

PEdit: Beat me to it

[chennisden]

lol

[RAS]

... I really can't believe you're forgetting about the friendly neighbor that Dunn even confirmed.

This is a horrible post, by the way. Yes, dunn confirmed your night action, but it's far from alignment indicative. This doesn't confirm you as town, far from it. All it does is confirm that you had the ability to neighbor someone.

The fact that you're pushing this over-and-over is a big reason why I think you're scum here.

[Elsa Jay]

RAS, do me a solid and look up FRIENDLY Neighbor.

[RAS]

Also, Elsa's "confusion" today simply made no sense to me. There was nothing to be confused about, and I feel like she was either doing it as a way to not contribute anything or to attempt to confuse other people. It didn't feel very natural.

[light_ganski]

Um, RAS

Friendly neighbour is not the same thing as neighbouriser

He's literally conftown

[light_ganski]

From where I'm standing its got to be fuscosco/brassherald mechanically

And in the impossible situation ofrhz flips town then there really are bastard fake confirms and I'll accept the loss but I digress

[RAS]

Okay, so. chenn and I have both agreed to neighbor Elsa tonight since we both believe something isn't adding up. This is the last change we're making about this.

We're both aware of Friendly neighbors, however, we both believe that this is the best play for town. In the 0.01% chance that Elsa is scum here, this saves us from potential auto-loss. If she's town, then no harm was done.

[ofrhz]

Whoo now I can die in peace!

@Enigma, the dead pt better be full of salt and entertaining af

[light_ganski]

Who are your buddies ofr?

[ofrhz]

Enigma was my only buddy

[light_ganski]

Lol

[RAS]

... I really can't believe you're forgetting about the friendly neighbor that Dunn even confirmed.

This is a horrible post, by the way. Yes, dunn confirmed your night action, but it's far from alignment indicative. This doesn't confirm you as town, far from it. All it does is confirm that you had the ability to neighbor someone.

The fact that you're pushing this over-and-over is a big reason why I think you're scum here.

To be fair, I forgot about the Friendly part of their claim when I initially made this post. It's been a long day.

[RAS]

Elsa is still being neighbored regardless of that. chenn and I haven't changed our mind about that, and we both believe this to be the safest play for multiple reasons.

I want to add that a lot of these claims and actions just don't add up, and Elsa sort of just is the outlier in every one of our possible scenarios.

For example, Brassherald sees Fuscoco, myself, and chenn as confirmed towns which confirms Elsa from his point of view. This is only true if Brassherald/Light is the scum team, however, why would Brassherald confirm himself by outting Fuscoco as clear? This is exactly why I don't think Brassherald is scum here.

[RAS]

For example, Brassherald views Fuscoco, myself, and chenn as confirmed town which confirms Light, and more importantly Elsa as scum from his point of view. If Elsa is indeed a Friendly Neighbor, then why would Brassherald clear Fuscoco here? By doing so, he confirms himself as scum. He can't push on Fuscoco because he confirmed them as town FHPOV, he can't push on Elsa because "Friendly Neighbor", he can't push on chenn and I because we're confirmed town. This would leave only himself and Light for him to push on, and we all know there can't just be one scum left.

Clarified what I meant by adding a few words and a little bit more detail.

But also, since one might argue that it could be a fuck-up, I just simply don't think this is the case here. This would be such a dumb mistake to make, and it's something Brassherald would've had no reason to do here as scum. He could've lied in many ways (lied about the track, lied about being role-blocked, etc.), so why would he choose the only outcome that would confirm him as scum? He wouldn't.

[light_ganski]

I don't mind seeing Elsa neighboured tbh. Highly unlikely she comes back guilty but if she does we're half way there

and living on a prayer

, if she comes back innocent that brings our PoE in tighter

I don't fully agree with the point RE brassherald. His entry seemed like a rushed, poorly thought out attempt to fake-inno his partner fuscosco, overlooking that elsa was conftown, and get a quick lynch on elsa or myself. I think its a scum fuck up precisely because his early posts + elsa vote came from the position of someone who didn't know elsa was conftown, so in his eyes the maths worked out (elsa + me + bus on ofrhz) and he couldn't go back on the claim later without confscumming himself and outing his partner in the process.

[chennisden]

I assume I'll be the NK tonight

[chennisden]

We're getting Brass instead.

[chennisden]

Maybe.

[xyzzy]

gonna make some posts so that the end of day post is the top of the page instead of nearly the very bottom

[xyzzy]

wow! I love to post on "mafia scum dot org"

[xyzzy]

happy 4/13 everyone. today is the day Andrew Hussie invented webcomics