Mafiascum.net

In post 2824, Datisi wrote:i'm not scumreading mena even though something is telling me i should and i don't know what to do

Is it going to help to talk about it with me or nah?

In post 2819, skitter30 wrote:ss this might be a weird thing to say but i'm gettng me/titus vibes from you/lilith rn

like this is what's throwing me off here ???

Maybe talk to skitt or Blake or one of the other people townreading me if you’re not sure you should be

In post 2819, skitter30 wrote:ss this might be a weird thing to say but i'm gettng me/titus vibes from you/lilith rn

What does this mean, sorry?

In post 2825, Menalque wrote:

In post 2824, Datisi wrote:i'm not scumreading mena even though something is telling me i should and i don't know what to do

Is it going to help to talk about it with me or nah?

maybe
i don't know
you feel weird
but idk if i can slap a scum sticker on you

In post 2822, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 2820, Menalque wrote:I think this is possible but not my experience. I actually remember you really struggling to make a decision on whether to bus your partner (Pine) in Added to the Group Chat when I forced you to choose between bussing him or saving him.

The difference is I wasn't under pressure there, I was fairly townread and I was debating whether or not I could use that trust to shield him.

True, but I think that in this scenario there’s also the mitigating factor of your prior read on lilith making it hard for you to suddenly shift to bussing if you were on a “mutual townreads” course earlier on. Also if I remember right there was a mitigating factor in that game of pine having claimed tracker to save himself

In post 2829, Datisi wrote:

In post 2825, Menalque wrote:

In post 2824, Datisi wrote:i'm not scumreading mena even though something is telling me i should and i don't know what to do

Is it going to help to talk about it with me or nah?

maybe
i don't know
you feel weird
but idk if i can slap a scum sticker on you

Okay, how do I feel weird

Like in what sense do I feel weird

If I feel weird in a “trying to force the gamestate” one way that’s because that is exactly what I’m doing, yes. If you think I’m trying to do it in a scummy way or for scummy motivations then you should scumread me for it and try to remember in future that me trying to control the game is not a good way to read me unless you think it’s for clearly scummy reasons

In post 2695, skitter30 wrote:the titus thing was kinda impulsive and i just kinda ran with it and strengthened it when i realized it was screwing with the gamestate that much

my partner in this scumgame was a lilith/ss hydra (hence i know they'd get the reference)
titus was hard townreading my slot and so i started hard-townreading her for like 2 whole game days and it thoroughly messed with the gamestate because everyone was convinced there was at least one (maybe two) scum in the pair but it somehow created enough force to prevent people from actually lynching either of us

In post 2830, Menalque wrote:True, but I think that in this scenario there’s also the mitigating factor of your prior read on lilith making it hard for you to suddenly shift to bussing if you were on a “mutual townreads” course earlier on.

I don't think it would be hard for me to shift to bussing, I never had lilith as more than a light townread and they were based on very early things.

In post 2832, Menalque wrote:If I feel weird in a “trying to force the gamestate” one way that’s because that is exactly what I’m doing, yes. If you think I’m trying to do it in a scummy way or for scummy motivations then you should scumread me for it and try to remember in future that me trying to control the game is not a good way to read me unless you think it’s for clearly scummy reasons

i mean yeah i guess you feel weird because trying to shift the gamestate

that's why i said i don't think i can genuinely call you scum here
but i can't keep quiet about it becuase you know i gotta get out all my paranoia out at some goddamn point
so i'm aware i'm kinda just screaming in the wind here but

also why does that feel low-key condescending bc like i'm genuinely trying here

In post 2835, Datisi wrote:

In post 2832, Menalque wrote:If I feel weird in a “trying to force the gamestate” one way that’s because that is exactly what I’m doing, yes. If you think I’m trying to do it in a scummy way or for scummy motivations then you should scumread me for it and try to remember in future that me trying to control the game is not a good way to read me unless you think it’s for clearly scummy reasons

i mean yeah i guess you feel weird because trying to shift the gamestate

that's why i said i don't think i can genuinely call you scum here
but i can't keep quiet about it becuase you know i gotta get out all my paranoia out at some goddamn point
so i'm aware i'm kinda just screaming in the wind here but

also why does that feel low-key condescending bc like i'm genuinely trying here

I don’t find it condescending

Like datisi, I’m gonna say the same thing pure boi said to me: if you feel like you need to scumread me, scumread me, as hopefully that’s the best way for you to finally be able to get to reliable reads on me. Like I think initially you tended to townread me because you (I think?) wanted me to be town. Now I think you’re in a phase of tending to scumread me because you’ve played a couple of times against me as scum where you had it right and points but ultimately came off me again or whatever

I don’t think you should be scumreading me because I think I’m verging on being out of my scumrange but if you need to then go for it I guess

I’d like us to get to a point where even if one of us is scum we don’t have to start off every game fighting or mutually scumreading each other as a pattern, or one scumreading the other because it’s really tiresome tbh

In post 2834, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 2830, Menalque wrote:True, but I think that in this scenario there’s also the mitigating factor of your prior read on lilith making it hard for you to suddenly shift to bussing if you were on a “mutual townreads” course earlier on.

I don't think it would be hard for me to shift to bussing, I never had lilith as more than a light townread and they were based on very early things.

I will reread your posts and think about it a bit later, not right now

In post 2833, skitter30 wrote:

In post 2695, skitter30 wrote:the titus thing was kinda impulsive and i just kinda ran with it and strengthened it when i realized it was screwing with the gamestate that much

my partner in this scumgame was a lilith/ss hydra (hence i know they'd get the reference)
titus was hard townreading my slot and so i started hard-townreading her for like 2 whole game days and it thoroughly messed with the gamestate because everyone was convinced there was at least one (maybe two) scum in the pair but it somehow created enough force to prevent people from actually lynching either of us

Oh right, the city planners game from NSG right

Okay, what do you make of S_S saying he hasn’t been hard townreading lil and that’s it’s more from her end towards him? And the implication of that on the feeling you have

i think it's darn paranoia becuase this game doesn't feel [solved] and i think i'm wrong [somewhere] and while i don't think i'm wrong on you i think i'm legally obliged to have this conversation with myself at least like once per dayphase

right

I'm seeing nothing that I care to respond to over the last few pages.

yeah, that too ^^

like this feels as if the day's already over and we've decided we're lynching in {lili, s_s}

In post 2840, Datisi wrote:i think it's darn paranoia becuase this game doesn't feel [solved] and i think i'm wrong [somewhere] and while i don't think i'm wrong on you i think i'm legally obliged to have this conversation with myself at least like once per dayphase

right

Okay, so why do you think you’re feeling that you’re wrong somewhere?

Also datisi if I’m about to work through your reads with you to try and help you get to a greater confidence and you end up flipping scum I’m gonna be so pissed in postgame lmao

i'm not scum

In post 2839, Menalque wrote:Okay, what do you make of S_S saying he hasn’t been hard townreading lil and that’s it’s more from her end towards him? And the implication of that on the feeling you have

i guess i don't have an answer to this, i'm just getting similar vibes
and i'm kinda wary that if i give up on ss today it's just not going to happen

In post 2845, skitter30 wrote:

In post 2839, Menalque wrote:Okay, what do you make of S_S saying he hasn’t been hard townreading lil and that’s it’s more from her end towards him? And the implication of that on the feeling you have

i guess i don't have an answer to this, i'm just getting similar vibes
and i'm kinda wary that if i give up on ss today it's just not going to happen

How likely do you think a bus driver is? I don’t think bingle does lie about mechanics and he’s said that 3-4 T’s is the most likely outcome in which case there is no scum bus driver. In which case you just shooting him tonight always means he dies?

i think there's a decent chance there's a bus driver and i therefore don't want to talk about where i'm intending to shoot / if i'm intending to shoot

like i want to keep open the possibility of holstering or shooting ss or shooting a {secret scumread that will henceforth not be named} because then hopefully if i'm still around n3 any potential bus driver will have been spent

In post 2843, Menalque wrote:

In post 2840, Datisi wrote:i think it's darn paranoia becuase this game doesn't feel [solved] and i think i'm wrong [somewhere] and while i don't think i'm wrong on you i think i'm legally obliged to have this conversation with myself at least like once per dayphase

right

Okay, so why do you think you’re feeling that you’re wrong somewhere?

Also datisi if I’m about to work through your reads with you to try and help you get to a greater confidence and you end up flipping scum I’m gonna be so pissed in postgame lmao

that's the problem, i don't *know*

like sure lili could be red, okay fine i'm accepting that
i still kinda don't think s_s is? and there's the jumbled mess of {fb, maria, pp} and i'm kinda townreading everyone else

like the thing is i am not seeign anythign pointing at "this is wrong" other than my expericence that my reads are generally garbage