i think i can :EFFORT: a readslist alongside a vote
this'll suck because i cant do nice colors D:<
: They were the first to vibe with me in our
Admin PT
and followed through with my townbloc exercise without contention or condition. Their whiteknight on me feels organic because their aggression in this game has doubled since D1 and with good reason he outlined a townread on
Akarin
in the PT and she flipped so. It's also because he pushed for a
Titus
lim for multiple reasons, a lim didn't happen, and now he's acquired scrutiny for wanting to force a lim on a, at-the-time, widely scumread slot
(Titus)
. No. I'm not limming this slot, and I dislike every push on
Gamma
right now.
: I'm rapidly warming up to
Cakez
. I take heed to
Gamma's
hesitation with this slot and I don't recall many points where I agree with this slot. I will say, their trajectory is very towny, in respect to me and
Akarin
post-flip. I feel like they've actually taken my pokes on their posts with sincerity.
1678 1868 2678 They took
Gamma's
counterpoints in good faith.
2679 They have a strong push to work with slots despite any disagreements or hangups they have with them. I trust
Cakez's
POV here.
: I don't have a lot of well-worded explanations for this slot, because I agree when people like
BM
say that this slot pokes for information more than they give it out. However, trying to rationalize a scum-angle on this slot is weird as fuck. For the LATEST example, the push to keep
Titus
on trial in
2832 is an argument that I think would miss scum whether
Titus
was town or a buddy because this is AFTER the thread doubting this consensus.
Blitzo
was the most silent in the
Admin PT
but they hung out with
Alisae/Gamma/Me
because they found our cell to be one of the towniest.
: Almost entirely fluffy since their entrance, which I can't tell if that's AI of this player. I've already stated my points in D1 that I townread
Alisae
pretty strongly and I still doubt that
Alisae
is scum especially post-
Akarin
flip and NAI replacement that made sense for
Alisae's
constant disengagement in the game.
: Eveyrbody is giving me a hard time with
Murder
, it feels. It gives me flashbacks to
Merchant's Daughter
over 1 year ago where
Krazy
was hard scumread by all the slots I townread, but I townread
Krazy
and ALL OF TOWN doubtcasted my read there, and we lost in elo because I was right about
Krazy
all along.
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=56&t=78670
No, I don't understand why people think
Murder
is scum. If anyone does, I want them to talk to me like I'm a 5 year old and explain it.
I townread
Murder
because he went from sus'ing my lukewarm POV on his slot to taking that as an opportunity to work with me when most of the plist wanted him eliminated.
1705 2004 2024 2033 2322 2371 He was transparent about the fact that he couldn't give a confident solve D1.
1710 2249 I believe him because his actions reflect someone trying to solve the game whether it is to townside with a player or give full context and ideas to their thoughts on mechanic in regards to gamestate.
1691 and 1692 He even asserted his own ideas above my own when he felt it necessary.
2347 2404 I feel like
Murder
-scum would've changed tune the second
Akarin
jumped onto him and I don't think he's actively tried to absolve or downplay the suspicion on him.
His disposition towards me reminds me of how he handled
Infinity
in
Student Council
. Slight paranoia, very, very strongly wanting to work with a slot despite this. I think this is
Murder's
method to gamesolving that I personally vibe with.
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=83&t=84987
Unless I'm literally loony-toons level stupid this game and
Murder
-scum is tailing a strong, red-herring associative to my neck (which I don't think is true because he's not a braindead sheep), I'm still feeling good about
Murder
being town. If any of you think I'm misled, I damn-well expect something RESEMBLING of a good retort because I've not seen one.
: I don't think
Reck
is malicious. Yes, the vote on
Gamma
is lackluster but I can't hold it against
Reck
to do little to gamesolve D2 because of his restriction. Still, I can't tie a specific agenda to him and out of the nay-sayers to players working to accomplish some form of mech
Pooky/Alisae/Akarin
, they were one of the less hard-lined players because they saw the value of grouping. They also don't have any reads where I just outright dislike or think is never impossible. If I were asked to give a specific post or stance where I strongly believed came from town in this slot, I'd draw a blank, tbh. But this does not
~feel~
like scum. Shitty reasoning, I know, but I'm content with that provided our stage in this game.
: My ISO, I felt was very thorough on
OWER
and my townread feels well reasoned.
1673 If scum, I don't think it's with any of
{BM/Alisae slot/Pooky}
outright unless he's EXTREMELY effective with theatre and they've spent D1 pocketing me. I will say, I do agree with
Alisae's
issue with
OWER
mentioned in the
Admin PT
and it boiled down to two overarching points:
1) Alisae
felt
OWER's
take on them was garbage because
Alisae
, in their mind, was not trying to control the game.
2) OWER
is more active and aggressive this game than when he was mislimmed as town in D1,
Student Council
.
And I agree with these reasonings, and I'd like
OWER
to contest these when he can. I like
OWER's
content but I don't have a strong grasp on how best to read them because they seem to have a large tonal range than I believed. I like their assertions about the gamestate
1563, their willingness to work with me
1625, and the insistence of evaluating
Akarin's
flip as a form of NKA to catch scum.
2603 I just really want to see them post more content now.
: This man gets my sympathies, I felt the volume that they 1v1'd MULTIPLE SLOTS D1 is something I see from town more often than scum. I made a lot of my points about them in my D1 ISO
1671 and other than
Akarin
townflip as a potential thing to look at for interactions, I don't see a reason to doubt my initial analysis. I'm solid on them as town.
My only vex with
BM
at the moment is that I feel that they're very cautious D2
and I don't have context on how he came to this behavior from when he was strong on that
Titus
lim EoD1.
I can see his change of heart happening being in a PT with
Titus
. But neither could've ended up in
Electrical
, since people going there had to relocate, from my understanding. Ultimately, I like that
BM/Titus
seem to be working in good faith but I'm iffy because
BM
is still putting her at arm's length BUT is going with her solve at the same time.
: She never really responded to my points on her near EoD1 but it's not that I opened D2 demanding that of her. I think she's a bit easier to read as her thoughts aren't hyperfocused on
BM
now, I don't know what has led her to change on
BM
.
I don't really want to pry either.
2850 implies she knows something nobody else does and she's playing it smartly to try and figure out the thread first. OK, that makes her prediction posts
2640 2661 a lot more sound.
...shit...
After posts like
2620 2850,
221 has given me several new potential interpretations to
Titus'
gameplay right now and I'm OK with her being in the townbin.
Overall, I'm a bit frustrated with
Titus
but I trust they're actually solving the game here. I'm frustrated because they think I forced my posting EoD1 as scum
2823 and I want them to work with me if they think I'm misled on
Murder
2821.
TL;DR The above rounds out my townreads.
Pooky/Haschel are in the Sorting pile.
{Flea, DGB, TGP, Bell} are where I am at. But this isn't a team-solve.
I'm also not quite satisfied with Flea/DGB remaining this low, so I'm really just looking at: {Bell/TGP}
