Mafiascum.net

wait does table mean yes or no elim

In post 2468, samantha97 wrote:uhh I hope you aren't referring to last night, cause I targeted you thinking BEF was safe until the next night

pedit: ok nm then lol

Yeah, I'd like you to explain targeting me over BEF more, samantha. Why me? And why'd you think scum wouldn't kill BEF who was a UTR due to claim and could've been lying about parts of his role?

I reread Vax's iso and all I got from it was that HBB was probably town and that I should have caught bell/vax as ss theater like way earlier

In post 2875, Ydrasse wrote:wait does table mean yes or no elim

I'm more of a bean bag kind of Birthday

My strongest conclusion this game is that I have successfully commemorated Boonskiies's birthday to an acceptable degree.

solid work boyo, job well done

Ircher seemed to think there was scum inside shelly and GX and seemed to dislike a lot of shelly/taylor's posting

his hide target was unfortunate

he also didn't like sam much

ircher and shoshin didn't like sam much hmmm

to reread gamma or to not reread gamma

I think Ari was town, I still think sam might? be town

TGP may have extended his scumrange but I don't think quite so much... ?

HBB is confirmed not a strongman and sam cross-confirms a strongman on n1 in addition to the shoshinkill, I don't think there's 2 scum in shelly/gx/sam

I need to reread GX, I didn't like his klick vote

I might be running out of steam for tonight.

I can't believe I keep forgetting about the other reason HBB is town lol

I mean I wasn't considering him today but I every now and then was like 'what about...' and then I just remembered the fucking fruit lmao

wait shit that means you're dying tonight huh

HBB I need you in my life don't leave me

In post 314, samantha97 wrote:

In post 312, Happy Birthday Boonskiies wrote: I don't doubt that they're true either, but why can't 1 be a true mafia ascetic claim?

they could all be mafia claims, I just don't think any are

this post is so weird

In post 242, shellyc wrote:

In post 240, The Pelican Brief wrote:I think Tsunami is scum. Too much fluff, not enough solving. Not 100% because it is Noraa.

taylor and I kinda concur here.

72s entrance was quite townslippy with the ratio question (took it too far with the unawareness), noraa feels quite self-aware so far, and because 72's ellitelling

UNVOTE:

nope

or at least idk

ircher thought tgp was lurking when he came in with the bus on vax
but I toneread some of tgp's stuff as town pretty hard

gamma vouched for ari and ari's readslist is kinda diff than the way he usually plays scum, although maybe he was trying to save his slot
ari felt super vacant in content for a lot of the game idk, not super loving that slot for scum

shelly's push on tsunami maybe a little too hard for s/s early on even though they backed off and then went on BEF, so maybe... I read taylor's posts and it seems super different from town taylor to me, and then there's the roleclaim thing with GX which felt super weird

gx's klick read today bothers me a little but idk, the mech reaction was good, liked some of his tone stuff, think his first actual take in the game was bell/vax not being s/s which is... weird to think as the *first* take in the game?

hbb is like town in three different ways and the more I think about it like certainly tonight's kill

sam was scumread by two decent dead townies, made terrible mech decisions with ari, but I kinda like some of her tone. still vax's push there when he repped in could easily be s/s

I just saw something from sam I liked though I think -- ah, that's right, I kinda thought the way she was approaching klick's wagon felt like it reflected a town mindset

hhhhhhhmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

sleeptime fuck this

fuck I enjoyed posting with ydra while she was high and actually she does have some tonal differences but uhhhh I guess I need to reconsider whether tonight's interactions were townie enough to put her over these other slots

HUB how obvtown would you judge yourself to have been?
Like I read a lot of your posts and I feel like the reaction I SHOULD be having is 'oh that's some genuine solving the game, scum wouldn't play it like this'
But instead I'm like 'there's a lot of content here but I don't feel like any of these takes couldn't come from scum'

What makes you town? I feel like I can play this game with you

idk I'm pretty sure I would have hammered you and not driven myself crazy like, literal days ago, but that's just the first thing that comes to mind

I feel like my read of Bell vs. BEF was pretty good and I actually think I kinda nuked Bell's counterplay with the bus driver tinfoil. If you actually read bell's reaction to that tinfoil I think you would recognize we were not S/S if only because he literally had no idea how to process wtf I was talking about, and he struggled to articulate a counter-play strategy when I explained why he was scum for entirely wrong reasons

I'm probably not the best evaluator of what makes me readable as town though, I find that the better people know me the harder time they have finding me town even though I'm like... actually a super easy read in my mind

In post 1418, Ydrasse wrote:and idk if it’s that we are actually are town or something

still one of my favorite sentences in any game ever

In post 2876, Happy Birthday Boonskiies wrote:Yeah, I'd like you to explain targeting me over BEF more, samantha. Why me? And why'd you think scum wouldn't kill BEF who was a UTR due to claim and could've been lying about parts of his role?

I tried googling utr and only got under the radar... which I don't think is right. I'll lay out what I considered that night:

BEF: claimed non-consecutive, pseudo-confirmed town by pushing bell
you: pseudo-confirmed town by very likely getting fruit from bell, pseudo-confirmed power role by bell, are a restricted messenger (didn't even think of friendly neighbor) because by process of elimination you had to have messaged shoshin night 1 and would have targeted me night 2 if you could do it whenever (that post you quoted only had a pedit cause I spent longer rewriting it; it first was me accusing you of lying because of shoshin then I realized how dumb it would be to step on that strategy)
mafia: low-skill, can't fakeclaim, likely believed BEF and never gave it a second thought, doesn't know that you have a basically useless power role

speaking of which I don't think anyone has addressed what I have been saying, so what is everyone's thoughts on the lack of mafia fakeclaims? do you disagree with my conclusion? why?

Back to catching up. I keep reading posts and thinking 'oh that's obvtown yay' and then seeing who wrote them and it's Gamma and BEF. I'm disappointed that Gamma will get faded at the end of D2 because he reads as super town.

The amount of effort Bell is putting in towards the 60s pages kinda suggests that he has at least one buddy who is in a good position. Unless he just doesn't like playing scum or something, idk.

In post 1634, Bell wrote:

In post 1632, Happy Unbirthday Boon wrote:Can I think Ari made some good points but still think his catchup was a little scummy lol

You can, I was prolly about to move my vote to the puffer fish.

In post 1635, Ydrasse wrote:VOTE: brighteyedfish

This doesn't feel like a partner follow-up.