Mafiascum.net

alch only makes sense as a kill target if someone read those crumbs as a hider though.

Which, I guess is not that far fetched given that thats what I assumed she was crumbing.

But then alch would also have to have been the doc target and that seems loose.

i did until we lynched alch and that stopped being a possibility.

Dropping in for Monday post. Read this page, and kind of looked at Gwen's ISO for cluse to who she may have hid behind on night2, but her biggest suspect (Dapper) was lynched day2.

↑ Spider Gwen wrote:@Stormy: A reread of Alch wouldn't hurt. I know I haven't gotten much from his play. You might be able to see things I can't.

this post says, and i quote

"I will be hiding behind alchemist tonight"

The simple answer is she didn't target alchemist maybe we should look for another possible crumb

↑ TheWayItEnds wrote:

↑ Spider Gwen wrote:@Stormy: A reread of Alch wouldn't hurt. I know I haven't gotten much from his play. You might be able to see things I can't.

this post says, and i quote

"I will be hiding behind alchemist tonight"

It could have been more clear IMO, but it's a start.

we already lynched alchemist is the problem and he flipped town.

and the mod has now confirmed that SG did not die from hiding behind scum.

she died as the result of a targeted kill.

That's getting nominated for Kodak Moment, Peregrine. That is so fucking rich.

Well, I was hoping to catch TWIE in a lie, but that doesn't seem to have worked. At the least, his story is consistent.

TWIE: I am seriously beginning to question if you understand how Hiders function when you say that Gwen was "the result of a targeted kill".

Like the other option is that she forgot to send an action in over Christmas but that feels unlikely too.

With all due respect - we know that Gwen performed an action, because she was both active and not a capering idiot. We know that Hiders can't be roleblocked, we know Hiders are immune to nightkills when using their action, and we know that Gwen didn't hide behind grapes.

↑ T S O wrote:That's getting nominated for Kodak Moment, Peregrine. That is so fucking rich.

So you do or do not think she hid behind scum on night2?

I don't want to hear about Bus Drivers, I really could care less about them. Anyone who suggests the involvement of Bus Drivers will be taken out the back and shot.

Well, consider the facts, Peregrine. Either she hid behind scum, or her death was the result of a tinfoil hat-style conspiracy where the person she believed was scum was actually targeted by a Doctor and was also the target of the nightkill.

↑ PeregrineV wrote:My activity is my vote today.

Vote: Alchemist

↑ PeregrineV wrote:

↑ TheWayItEnds wrote:

↑ Spider Gwen wrote:@Stormy: A reread of Alch wouldn't hurt. I know I haven't gotten much from his play. You might be able to see things I can't.

this post says, and i quote

"I will be hiding behind alchemist tonight"

It could have been more clear IMO, but it's a start.

Vote: Alchemist

Fakey fakey. You helped lynch Alch, I doubt you forgot.

You otherwise only voted Spifflop town counter to Klingon.

VOTE: PV

Off to work.

↑ jasonT1981 wrote:

Spider Gwen was Angel, Town Hider killed Night 2

↑ jasonT1981 wrote:

↑ T S O wrote:

2. Hypothetically, if a Hider hid behind a player who was scum, what would the Hider's kill flavour be?

3. Hypothetically, if a Hider hid behind a town player who was killed, would the Hider's kill flavour be identical to the killed town?

2. Kill flavor would simply be 'died' as per YCBA 3

3. Yes. I believe so, that is how I would have flipped it.

So there are two kills. SGs death flavor isn't died and it doesn't match grapes. You go ahead and explain what happened.

↑ T S O wrote:Well, consider the facts, Peregrine. Either she hid behind scum, or her death was the result of a tinfoil hat-style conspiracy where the person she believed was scum was actually targeted by a Doctor and was also the target of the nightkill.

Then considering she is not a blithering idiot, she crumbed, in some manner, her target for the night. If it's not alchemist, then who is it?

↑ Spider Gwen wrote:

↑ Passionate Storm wrote:@SG, maybe we can reread alchemist tonight? Neither of my heads feels good about him, but at the same time too many obvious scum to work with Shiro.

Alch is not a priority for tonight.
.

Well I think I found the post saying she didn't target alchemist maybe she really did just want to reread him.

↑ PeregrineV wrote:

↑ T S O wrote:Well, consider the facts, Peregrine. Either she hid behind scum, or her death was the result of a tinfoil hat-style conspiracy where the person she believed was scum was actually targeted by a Doctor and was also the target of the nightkill.

Then considering she is not a blithering idiot, she crumbed, in some manner, her target for the night. If it's not alchemist, then who is it?

Nevermind. I should do more reading....

She either did not hide. Was somehow prevented from hiding. Or hid behind the person targeted by the mafia kill and they were prevented from dying and she was not.

↑ Passionate Storm wrote: I doubt you forgot.

Awww, thanks for the vote of confidense.

But you would be wrong.

And I do not believe she made that post regarding alchemist and then did not hide behind him.

↑ TheWayItEnds wrote:She either did not hide. Was somehow prevented from hiding. Or hid behind the person targeted by the mafia kill and they were prevented from dying and she was not.

Are you deaf hiders can't even be targeted by any night actions