Mafiascum.net

aside from everything else, glad to hear you're doing okay, ducky

does anyone have a reason why lilith shouldn't die today?

as far as I'm concerned right now the pool is (Best Bird, peta, Dave, hoopla, NM, lilith, infinity) and you earn your way out

I'm trusting skitt on S_S along with my initial read there

I also think skitt is fairly solidly accurate as town, she thought lilith was scum, she's dead now

I also think that lilith, who knows me and skitt, might have been keeping her alive so long as we were in conflict/sceptical, and she's now dead because we'd got to the point where we were actually coming together and townreading each other

regardless, lilith should die today unless there's like, a really good reason not to do that

If scum are most of the way done figuring out the setup and we have no clue, wouldn't a massclaim help us more?

The cop should claim today for sure.

fyi, "she claimed JK" is no longer a good reason, for anyone wanting that

although, lilith, you do still need to claim your JK

In post 2930, Something_Smart wrote:If scum are most of the way done figuring out the setup and we have no clue, wouldn't a massclaim help us more?

The cop should claim today for sure.

I will defer to you on this, but I'm not persuaded for all the reasons I gave

it's cop, watcher, doctor, neighbouriser who are unclaimed

do you think any aside from the cop should claim, S_S?

and before anyone claims "TMI!?!??!?!?!!!!!!" about me saying watcher -- I'm just using it as shorthand for the slot and I'm assuming that most people would choose watcher

VOTE: lilith I’ll let other people figure out the massclaim stuff. Lilith definitely needs to die.

In post 2930, Something_Smart wrote:If scum are most of the way done figuring out the setup and we have no clue, wouldn't a massclaim help us more?

The cop should claim today for sure.

i feel like the cop role is very likely in scum's hands which is why i want people to have to out and not just kill lilith

good vote but you're still back in the scumpool for now

In post 2936, petapan wrote:i feel like the cop role is very likely in scum's hands

why?

ugh, skitt, why didn't u activate ur PGO last night?

was it because of dunn pushing for a cop check on you?

In post 2887, skitter30 wrote:my strong towns are mena and ss

i'm still weakly townreding infinity

everyone else is in my pool on some level, esp. if dunn is town

In post 2898, skitter30 wrote:my key takeaway, of course being, that lilith is still scum unless dunn is exactly mafia goon

because everyone who could be a cop has posted and none of them are playing like they're a cop

Wonder if skitter dying today means bird is scum here, as she was starting to come around on him being scum. May be a bit obvious, but definitely a possibility.

I'm actually really starting to scumread you again infinity and it's literally only skitter calling you town that is stopping me

which is then added wine, because would you kill her as one of the main people supporting you!town?

I think if lilith is scum maybe not, but if lilith flips town then it's not an awful play for scum!you at all

I'm not saying this IS what happened btw, and anyone trying to use this argument tomorrow if I'm dead should be super sceptical of the person making it -- but I do see a world where you note my desire to deadsheep players, kill skitter to frame lilith + lock in her TR on you, then kill me before I can tunnel you the next day

but I'm definitely considering it

My solve is {bird, n_m, lilith}.

Hoopla has talked enough about her play that I actually have something resembling a soulread on her, and I don't think she's ever scum here.

I also have gut townreads on peta and s_s. I want to trust skitter's TR on s_s.

Mena I'll only consider if there's no doc. There are a couple things that give me paranoia here (I have a feeling scum are pretty confident in this gamestate is one) but I think he deserves a scummy if scum for how he played after the guilty.

Not really feeling dave!scum but maybe? I have a feeling he's being set up to be the next mislim.

PEdit: mena I'm going into solve mode now if it helps your read on me. I got a lot less busy over the past couple days.

I don't think bird and NM are ever scum together because I don't think JV is a meme-y enough player to take 4 with his scumbuddy

I strongly suspect davesaz would be in place of one of NM/JV if lilith is correct