Played over 209 games of mafia, more town than scum, but I can’t give you a number. I absolutely hate, detest, loathe drawing scum, but I usually do okay. Went on a two-year streak of winning every scum game I played across 6 sites sometime back though. Don’t know how I’d do today. Haven’t played mafia in over a year and haven’t drawn scum in two years. I still hate it. Drawing mafia is one of the worst forms of torture in mafia, and that’s misery usually shines through.
Probably more than you wanted to know, but.
Okay gotta go for realz.
That's actually... really interesting. How long have you been playing and across what sites?
I asked because I somewhat disagreed with you on your previous comment, but you obviously have the experience to be taken pretty seriously here so I'll weigh it appropriately.
Still back at work but I thought I had a meeting. It’s next Monday oops.
Anyway I started playing in late 2011 army homesite rip then came here sometime later. Not gonna mention sites though cuz I might as well mainslip depending on who might be in the game.
Why do you disagree though? I have experience and some strengths but strategy is not one of them. I’ve never played or followed a dance game before, and my brain does not conceptualize how things will work or look just from the setup. I have to see how things are playing out/read peoples theories/express my own to see it.
So if you disagree let me know!
Alright, let's discuss it after the game, then!
I think as scum I'd rather let my partner stand on her own - if she can't really convince someone to partner with her, she's likely to be a liability, and the jump on Lady 5 seemed like an attempt to avoid association with Lady 2. That's just a narrative that seems to fit pretty well as far as I'm concerned, but you bring up some good points counter to that, so I'll definitely consider that at the very least.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:40 am
by Gentleman 5
Everyone really needs to shut up about G8 and L5.
Unless FG is coming in to confirm them both as town, THEY ARE GETTING LYNCHED AFTER ME/L4 or G6/L8 DIE.
Like we should not be having a discussion on either of them, they are a detriment as town, regardless of alignment.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:41 am
by Lady 3
and if u dont look for em then maybe ur also scum who wants to set me up to leave G4 hmmm
hmmm
hmhmh
mhmh
hmh
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:42 am
by Gentleman 5
In post 2950, Lady 3 wrote:u should look for them otherwise im going to think u two are in the same pt
....
.....
........
Holy shit, have you ever made a read on your partner? Im not going back to find out but all I remember is G4 telling everyone how much he likes you, but not the other way around.
...
I dont know what to make of this information. Im not finding quotes because you know im right.
In post 2950, Lady 3 wrote:u should look for them otherwise im going to think u two are in the same pt
....
.....
........
Holy shit, have you ever made a read on your partner? Im not going back to find out but all I remember is G4 telling everyone how much he likes you, but not the other way around.
...
I dont know what to make of this information. Im not finding quotes because you know im right.
Relax, I'm talking to her. Do you wish to discuss your read on Lady 3 more in depth now, and I can talk more about why I think she's likely town?
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:44 am
by Gentleman 5
In post 2953, Lady 3 wrote:and if u dont look for em then maybe ur also scum who wants to set me up to leave G4 hmmm
hmmm
hmhmh
mhmh
hmh
I dont give a fuck anymore since L4 wants to die, probably thinks Im scum, and isnt helping me fight my lynch.
Assume whatever you want, just get on with it.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:45 am
by Lady 5
In post 2908, Gentleman 4 wrote:Lady 5, the following two posts contradict each other, which is pretty par the course for you. Actually I'm almost certain that if you picked any single stance of yours this game I could find another post of yours that contradicts it without much difficulty.
Please stop posting for a while, watch the game, get a hold of yourself and know where you're coming from before you keep posting.
In post 2888, Lady 4 wrote:If G8 is scum and all of his options were town, his selection of L5 is still correct. All him picking L5 proves if he's scum is that his buddies wanted them to pick her so she could continue to do L5 things.
WRONG!
If he was scum his correct choice is Lady 2. They are a strong town and should take down a strong town with them.
In post 2875, Gentleman 4 wrote:No one is made nervous by the fact that Gentleman 8 went out of order to choose Lady 5?
What do you make of the fact that he jumped to pick someone he could have waited to pick? Was l5 in danger of being picked by g1 or 3, i forget who was supposed to go first?
I think it more has to do with the fact that if he's scum, he doesn't necessarily want a S-S pair.
Which I’ve pointed out BUT NO ONE SEEMS TO LISTEN TO ME!
If he was Town*
I didn’t actually see that mistake. Thanks for pointing it out.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:46 am
by Gentleman 5
In post 2956, Lady 3 wrote:I'm never going to make a public read on my partner that's bad form.
Pretty sure G8 has.
And L5.
Im with you though, its bad form. Ive said that earlier
In post 2956, Lady 3 wrote:I'm never going to make a public read on my partner that's bad form.
Pretty sure G8 has.
And L5.
Im with you though, its bad form. Ive said that earlier
L8*
I have, G8 hasn’t made a read on me I don’t think.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:49 am
by Gentleman 4
I think Lady 5 and Gentleman 8 are a solid first lynch, because this flip has a reasonable possibility of flipping red, and it helps me sort Lady 2 and Gentleman 3 at the very least.
In post 2950, Lady 3 wrote:u should look for them otherwise im going to think u two are in the same pt
....
.....
........
Holy shit, have you ever made a read on your partner? Im not going back to find out but all I remember is G4 telling everyone how much he likes you, but not the other way around.
...
I dont know what to make of this information. Im not finding quotes because you know im right.
Relax, I'm talking to her. Do you wish to discuss your read on Lady 3 more in depth now, and I can talk more about why I think she's likely town?
I dont care, I wasnt questioning your pair until after intermission
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:50 am
by Lady 2
In post 2963, Lady 5 wrote:Town G8 doesn’t choose L2.
Scum G8 chooses Town L2.
Scum G8 doesn’t choose Scum L2.
There!
It’s more clear now!
if you believe that
vote me
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:51 am
by Lady 5
Watch G8 replace out and the best mafia player in the world replaced into his slot.
If that happens he can prove to you that I’m Town.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 10:52 am
by Gentleman 5
In post 2968, Lady 5 wrote:Watch G8 replace out and the best mafia player in the world replaced into his slot.
If that happens he can prove to you that I’m Town.
Shut the fuck up. Fucking aye.
Lady 2 wrote:
In post 2963, Lady 5 wrote:Town G8 doesn’t choose L2.
Scum G8 chooses Town L2.
Scum G8 doesn’t choose Scum L2.
There!
It’s more clear now!
if you believe that
vote me
If I cared more, I would raise an eyebrow to such an empty threat.
