Mafiascum.net

In post 2973, MathBlade wrote:

In post 2971, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 2969, MathBlade wrote:

In post 2968, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 2966, MathBlade wrote:https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p13327143

This is where I am getting at.

I am quite confused

In that game Koba was a false clear for bussing their buddy.

I examined it and figured out what they did only made sense for scum Koba.

By figuring out what the scum goals and intents are we can find who the players are that are doing it.

We don't have a protective. They will sort themselves as long as we are vigilant about it and don't let time slip away the logic.

Why do you say that?

If I was a protective I protect NK or JV not Koopa.

Koba has been known to run false gambits and lie to get what they want as town. Lord knows I wouldn’t protect them over JV or NK15. To be clear this is not a claim just an if. I might or might not be.

You shouldn't have said this :p
I was aware, I was doing a gambit of my own.

In post 2974, MathBlade wrote:

In post 2972, JacksonVirgo wrote:Or we can elim them as soon as they give a green-check which is a route that's much more fun.

I think sorting them soon as a green check. But yeah I can vibe with this.

It's the best course of action rather than trying to solve them now when the correct elimination is obvious. Scum!NK doesn't do this if Andres is not scum so it's an almost certain red flip today.

In post 2975, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 2973, MathBlade wrote:

In post 2971, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 2969, MathBlade wrote:

In post 2968, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 2966, MathBlade wrote:https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... #p13327143

This is where I am getting at.

I am quite confused

In that game Koba was a false clear for bussing their buddy.

I examined it and figured out what they did only made sense for scum Koba.

By figuring out what the scum goals and intents are we can find who the players are that are doing it.

We don't have a protective. They will sort themselves as long as we are vigilant about it and don't let time slip away the logic.

Why do you say that?

If I was a protective I protect NK or JV not Koopa.

Koba has been known to run false gambits and lie to get what they want as town. Lord knows I wouldn’t protect them over JV or NK15. To be clear this is not a claim just an if. I might or might not be.

You shouldn't have said this :p
I was aware, I was doing a gambit of my own.

Hey! I claim mayor of facepalm.

What’s new?

Apparently it’s raining cats and dogs here.

In post 2976, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 2974, MathBlade wrote:

In post 2972, JacksonVirgo wrote:Or we can elim them as soon as they give a green-check which is a route that's much more fun.

I think sorting them soon as a green check. But yeah I can vibe with this.

It's the best course of action rather than trying to solve them now when the correct elimination is obvious. Scum!NK doesn't do this if Andres is not scum so it's an almost certain red flip today.

Alright let’s go.



Unless someone has something else?

I was not saying I was aware you were the protective, I was referring to knowing that koopa dying does not equate to no TProt

In post 2949, MathBlade wrote:

In post 2944, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 2910, MathBlade wrote:I guess the big question I have is why did scum send Andres to do the kill?

Depends if multitasking exists and where the PRs lie

I mean yes but no.

Assume scum have two PRs they had to use and Andres is a vanilla goon.

Then what were they doing?

We have Koopa, JV, and NK15 who all claimed something. If they’re all town what would the invests be doing?
Then if they have manipulators like a roleblock why did NK15 get a check off?

If Andres is a strongman so had to do the kill then that means we have a protective along with a gunsmith and a tracker who could act on D1?

I can’t get the pieces to fit which means something smells.

What makes you think scum would have 2 PRs?

I just want to state that if I do die tonight do not take my role lightly, it is important.

Okay I have a ghost vote on Andres.

It could be that the mafia are all in the lowest point in the Town and Andres was the top. That'd be quite funny

I'll hammer if I see an E-1 vote.

In post 2953, ItalianoVD wrote:

In post 2950, ItalianoVD wrote:It doesn’t make sense which is why they would do it.

Responding to 2947 & 2948

Pls respond to 2951/2970

In post 2980, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 2949, MathBlade wrote:

In post 2944, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 2910, MathBlade wrote:I guess the big question I have is why did scum send Andres to do the kill?

Depends if multitasking exists and where the PRs lie

I mean yes but no.

Assume scum have two PRs they had to use and Andres is a vanilla goon.

Then what were they doing?

We have Koopa, JV, and NK15 who all claimed something. If they’re all town what would the invests be doing?
Then if they have manipulators like a roleblock why did NK15 get a check off?

If Andres is a strongman so had to do the kill then that means we have a protective along with a gunsmith and a tracker who could act on D1?

I can’t get the pieces to fit which means something smells.

What makes you think scum would have 2 PRs?

Process of elimination:
Scum have either 0 PRs (which I mean wtf balance can discard)
Scum have 1 PR >> In this case why send Andres to do the kill? Unless that one PR is strongman or ninja or inno? Ninja is out so strongman? But then the setup needs a protective for town which doesn’t exist. Surely they’d send someone less likely to be checked.
Scum have 2 PR and Andres is a PR >> Why send Andres to do the kill and not use the PR?
Scum have 2 PR and Andres is not a PR >> Then what are the PRs doing?
Scum have 3 PRs >> See prior point

I am at a point where scum mechanically suck but then how do we get 100s of pages in a mini without an elim with shit scum? The 2 PRs and Andres isn’t one is the least shitty but ew.

I keep running into contradictions.

You’re drunk on WIFOM
Stop trying to guess at what PRs scum do or do not have.

In post 2987, Gamma Emerald wrote:You’re drunk on WIFOM
Stop trying to guess at what PRs scum do or do not have.

That’s like how I hunt though :/

This is gonna sound rude but: when have you ever had ideas of normal balance that resembled what the game reviewers actually had in mind?

Get to E-1 and I’ll hammer.

In post 2990, ItalianoVD wrote:Get to E-1 and I’ll hammer.

No me

In post 2989, Gamma Emerald wrote:This is gonna sound rude but: when have you ever had ideas of normal balance that resembled what the game reviewers actually had in mind?

In the game I just linked a bit ago where I caught Koba scum?

I will just have to think about it overnight.

Guess I am good to end the day.

I don’t think anything constructive comes out of this.

Just want to say that Malcom is overwhelmingly Town.
Who is NK scum-reading prior to this red-check.

Scum might be there.

I lied I wanna make sure scum can’t lurk sac this.

I am good from a conversation point though.

I would like for kitty to post before the hammer is dropped

I think HEM and Andres are paired

Agreed. I want her reads and reads of anyone likely to be nightkilled.

In post 2997, MathBlade wrote:Agreed. I want her reads and reads of anyone likely to be nightkilled.

Can you list the NKed people

In post 2998, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 2997, MathBlade wrote:Agreed. I want her reads and reads of anyone likely to be nightkilled.

Can you list the NKed people

?? Koopa died last night?