Firstly, could the Hydra's at least set up a sig saying who's in it, or even that it's a hydra. Don't care much about signing, just remembering who is in what.
Steevie's #44 was about the scummiest post I've seen in a while.
Have to agree with TMTOLBTWNTOF's #101. Tip can go in the scum pile though Steevie is still scummiest.
Dram busted active lurking?
Shadi #179 looks real bad to me.
Scum reads:
Steevie
Ank.
Stubbs
You know what, TiP can go in the lesser nullish/scum pile, with Doc.
One specific part, or rather the concept behind one specific part.
Why leave my vote in the quote?
I actually don't remember, probably a mistake.
Alright, which part then?
Posted: Fri Jun 14, 2013 7:04 pm
by Baby Spice
The last.
You answered a question directed at someone else. It could even be said that you defended someone whom you could not possible have a town read on from a question directed at someone else.
I can even see you leaving the vote in there as an attempt to direct the attention of others away from you question to me.
"Look I'm just asking a question, she's voting someone else"
You answered a question directed at someone else. It could even be said that you defended someone whom you could not possible have a town read on from a question directed at someone else.
I can even see you leaving the vote in there as an attempt to direct the attention of others away from you question to me.
"Look I'm just asking a question, she's voting someone else"
As for the part, fair point. I'm not going to argue against it. I just thought I could share my thoughts about it while /maybe/ answering his question. inb4 this post is also very scummy
As for the second part, welp wasn't the intention but whatever; I genuinely just... left it.
Posted: Fri Jun 14, 2013 10:26 pm
by Nero
i propose we completely and utterly ignore the divine intervention and just quicklynch stevie.
In post 244, Calcifer wrote:I have no idea why you went about that in such a roundabout way when you could've just asked "Why is that self-vote a scumtell?"
That would indicate I was sure it's the self-vote.
BROseidon is still my biggest scumread, though. Let's run him through.
Why?
In post 251, StubbsKVM wrote:Could you explain why Nero is town? I'm not seeing it.
The tunneling is a bit disconcerting and it's the reason why he's only a weak townread, but I like his #159 where he addressed Doc Holiday. Him not understanding what "weak scum" was and then jumping on that as hard as he could seemed like a town move; usually when people are calling you shitty scum when you're just plain scum, you steamroll them WITHOUT trumpeting about how good your scumgame is.
In post 262, Ankamius wrote:His overall point is good, but his explanation sucks.
Why does that make him scum?
(It doesn't.)
In post 262, Ankamius wrote:I can easily see scum doing this. I've done something similar in a recent scum game. I was the first wagon of the game and I self-voted because it was safer than responding normally; it has a higher chance of appearing scum in a reaction test.
Basically, scum paranoia.
Why is it more likely to be coming from scum as opposed to be coming from town?
Did you expect me not to ask you why you didn't like those posts?
In post 297, BROseidon wrote:I didn't realize that Stevie was coming from another site. Will reevaluate him with this in mind.
Erm, not another site. Another time.
Posted: Fri Jun 14, 2013 11:15 pm
by DOMO
Hi guys, sorry for disappearing, family emergency. All is well and I'm back now. Sorry to djd too, I didn't even let him know.
Catching up now, reads and stuff to follow.
Posted: Fri Jun 14, 2013 11:15 pm
by DOMO
- rev
Posted: Sat Jun 15, 2013 12:10 am
by DOMO
Notes -
Spoiler:
#10 - prohawk's list gets a reaction
#11 - BRO's response is interesting, if BRO flips scum I'm going to be interested in those on the list.
#12 - same again with TIP
#13 - calcifer's suspicion seems town motivated
#19 - scummy, speculation on scum numbers seems fake - BRO is scum read
#23 - I'm happy zdenek is probably town if BRO is scum
#29 - liking calcifer more
#32 - too blatant to be chainsaw vote, I don't think nero is scum if BRO is
#35 - not liking TIP though if BRO is scum
#38 - yeah zdenek is town
#42 - BRO is scum
#44 - interesting post from stevie... why is forming a town read on page 2 a scumtell? This stinks to me of distancing from BRO and TIP.
#46 - yeah calcifer is on exactly the same page as me here, this guy is town
#53 - huh? calcifer is now saying BRO, TIP and stevie all town? I'm confused, these three were all named as scum in post #46, a position I agree with at this stage
#57 oh of course, hydra differences... I suppose I won't complain about that, seeing as we'll probably have our disagreements
#70 - ripping Bender jokes... made me laugh though... TIP posting a little more townlike though
#73 - BRO seems like he's deliberately trying to link himself with TIP here... not sure how this reflects on TIP, but I'm pretty sure BRO is scum whatever TIP's role
Up to beginning of page 4...
I'm really tired and need sleep, will resume my catch up later.
So far... BRO is probably scum, weaker scumreads on stevie and TIP... calcifer and zdenek both town.
Posted: Sat Jun 15, 2013 12:11 am
by DOMO
Sorry... ^ rev
I will get into the habit of signing my posts.
Posted: Sat Jun 15, 2013 1:56 am
by dramonic
This game is silly
Posted: Sat Jun 15, 2013 1:58 am
by Nero
are you gonna quit being a condescending prat and actually fucking do something?
Posted: Sat Jun 15, 2013 3:25 am
by truly14
What happened?
Posted: Sat Jun 15, 2013 4:30 am
by ProHawk
Soo... I thought Shadi's 202 agreeing with me, then unvoting was strange... never happened to me before with someone who was scum-reading me. At first I thought scum trying to not ruffle feathers, but on reading Shadi's other games as town he seems to be a generally agreeable chap. Unfortunately he doesn't have any scum-games I could refer to... so I don't have that to compare it to, but I think I am good with
UNVOTE:
VOTE: KingCrabd
Came in, offered a bit of words, left. His vote for a null-read over a scum-read was awkward and a vote for a lurker is quite ironic...
I don't necessarily agree with the Stevie is scum mantra. I agree that his vote on me was poor, his reasoning (me being either scum or a bad player) likewise tact-less, but I can't see a whole lot of scum-benefit is being so controversial.
