Mafiascum.net

Meaning do they form really solid reads or do they obvTown or what?

P-edit: Clearing up my question for Penguin.

In post 273, Elsa Jay wrote:I interract with fun people day 1 Bins. I ignore boring ones.

I also find this funny because they've interacted with mainly me.

I only called you scummy, never boring. Of course I'd interact with you.

YAY I'M INTERESTING

In post 298, Alchemist21 wrote:Penguin, how useful would you say Elsa is when they’re Town?

What a weird question.

Useful enough that I think they are a net positive.

Actually I'd speak for town!Elsa having some utility. They're quite good at reading me for example and have a knack for cutting through nonsense.

just need to sort out their 1v1s before lylo next time.

In post 304, PenguinPower wrote:

In post 298, Alchemist21 wrote:Penguin, how useful would you say Elsa is when they’re Town?

What a weird question.

Useful enough that I think they are a net positive.

It will make sense in time. I need to know if they really are worth keeping around.

In post 305, the worst wrote:Actually I'd speak for town!Elsa having some utility. They're quite good at reading me for example and have a knack for cutting through nonsense.

just need to sort out their 1v1s before lylo next time.

Cutting through nonsense? That’s not a skill I expected but I’ll take it!

UNVOTE:

Penguin seems less like scum now.

yeah it's always surprising to me as well but I noticed it after I tossed another mislynch his way the other day

In post 270, PenguinPower wrote:

In post 263, Bins wrote:IT ISN'T A POLICY LYNCH BUT IT ISN'T A BAD LYNCH CONSIDERING THEIR ISO

It's the definition of a policy lynch considering their ISO.

Move on.

oh bless your heart

In post 271, Bins wrote:

In post 270, PenguinPower wrote:

In post 263, Bins wrote:IT ISN'T A POLICY LYNCH BUT IT ISN'T A BAD LYNCH CONSIDERING THEIR ISO

It's the definition of a policy lynch considering their ISO.

Move on.

uh no

I think that the fact they've dodged the game so far, and the defensiveness when I pointed that out is scummy. I have said this like three times so I'm a lil offended rn PP. I think the response to me acting all "I don't care lol I am town this is all memes" is just a blatant attempt to look like they're keeping it cool. idk I just don't see it coming from town. Town would interact. RIGHT. I gotta believe.

In post 283, Elsa Jay wrote:See Bins? Pengu found it. If you want to prove you're worth to town you gotta call out my statements. I even softballed that one too you. I guess I should have bolded it to be extra transparent.

Minus points for not catching it.

LOL

"where did i call you scum"
*gets pointed out*
"aha you see i was TESTING you"

In post 292, Bins wrote:Tbh, after meta-ing Elsa, I don't really feel as strongly as I did about this read (which is probably while PP disagrees). … I guess it is slightly policy now. But I'm not going to feel any inclination to move my vote (even though, I COULD VOTE TBONE OR BEAZU, so like. eh. was fun.).

good thing meta is trash

I think holistically avoiding the thread and prodging is a playstyle indicator before an alignment indicator and I'm more concerned about the prodging from e.g. zor

In post 310, xRECKONERx wrote:

In post 283, Elsa Jay wrote:See Bins? Pengu found it. If you want to prove you're worth to town you gotta call out my statements. I even softballed that one too you. I guess I should have bolded it to be extra transparent.

Minus points for not catching it.

LOL

"where did i call you scum"
*gets pointed out*
"aha you see i was TESTING you"

Thanks for explaining my test to the uninformed. It's always good to know everybody understands.

In post 291, Elsa Jay wrote:It appears I've gained to much heat. A heads up I'm not claiming today so if it's info you want vote elsawhere, if it's a pure lynch and a way to waste the rest of the day then pounce on me. Hammerer would definitely be scum.

For now I'll just stick to making memes and jokes.

This is actually Elsa's worst post.

How long has Elsa been playing then, if this is an alt?

jaydragonking was his first account afaict
he took like a 6 month?ish break mid to late last year

In post 312, the worst wrote:I think holistically avoiding the thread and prodging is a playstyle indicator before an alignment indicator and I'm more concerned about the prodging from e.g. zor

yes like that

yes, i'm sure that your concern, 55 hours into this game, is "prod dodging" and not a totally-100%-natural response to having his scumpost pointed out.

Sorry guys, I just got back from my dog having stitches and I’m exhausted, I’ll catch up tomorrow

Actually I don't think you calling out that scumpost is organic or genuine and I've called that out to which you've not responded while regularly fluffposting so... yes, your activity is something on my radar.

Do you think you should be exempt from criticism because we're only 55 hours into the game?

In post 198, Alchemist21 wrote:I thought everypony voting on the Baezu wagon would be interested in a post like that and use it to decide if they want to keep their vote there or think she’s Town. With this many players I thought the first serious post by the wagoned player would have gotten more attention than it did. I haven’t seen anypony really trying to sort Baezu or if they are they’re not showing it.

i actually think that this could be a really scummy post asdfjas
regardless of baezeus's alignment

In post 252, the worst wrote:VOTE: T-Bone this is ok
team EP ride or die

Beazu can be town, Alch I feel like I want to townread as well but it's weaker

UNVOTE:
worst what do you think about bins saying that t-bone's tone in every game is kinda scummy + how serious is your vote?
also bins why do you say you "could vote t-bone" after telling me that my vote might not necessarily have been that good bc of your experience with him

In post 257, Bins wrote:everyone tell me why they won't vote elsa and who is scum on the wagon if they're town

might join on for funsies but i'm mainly focusing on getting more of a sense of people i know better and have more knowledge/experience to work with. like ive literally glossed over most of her posts

like for example im trying to sort worst (who im pretty unsure of atm but i feel like i have a very intimate sense of his scum-mindset, although maybe not as good of a sense of his town game) and implosion (who i feel might obvtown or obvscum himself eventually and i'm leaning towards ONE of the options at the minute (spicy))

In post 321, Errantparabola wrote:i actually think that this could be a really scummy post asdfjas
regardless of baezeus's alignment

also on a related note to this, i think that boise's big readlist post as her wagon response is like her one scummy post (and also her only scummy post). thats my hot take

@ bins
i really have no idea what to say about your paranoia posts re: me and it FEELS like i should be saying nothing. but it just feels really weird for me to let them go unaddressed
i've actually thought a lot about it, and its actually jarring whenever people sort of see me as a smart and deceptive player because i have usually seen myself as fairly unremarkable. Like i've been historically good as scum i GUESS but, i dont know, i just have no idea how to approach this kind of paranoia because i've never really gotten it before

but uh i guess keep doing what youre doing and i'll keep doing what im doing and i feel like it'll play out productively bc youre the person who i feel like i have the best sense of this game and connected with the most ugh SORRY

In post 321, Errantparabola wrote:worst what do you think about bins saying that t-bone's tone in every game is kinda scummy + how serious is your vote?
also bins why do you say you "could vote t-bone" after telling me that my vote might not necessarily have been that good bc of your experience with him

not a whole lot because I don't have a tone read on T-Bone and don't think T-Bone has really done anything AI and

mildly serious because T-Bone hasn't really done anything AI and we have enough time I'm chilled w/ having votes on null slots