And yes, that includes the one I casted for Baezu.
Urs is particularly bad, though.
For funsies, anyone else want to tell me why?
ooh ooh pick me
is it because jackal is my mason partner?
Posted: Sat Aug 17, 2019 10:27 am
by rosterfoster
In post 290, cyrus62 wrote:you mean to tell me after 12 pages you don't see any one as scum or town yet? what have you been doing for 12 pages
You asked me for 4 reads.
Posted: Sat Aug 17, 2019 10:28 am
by rosterfoster
And yeah tbh, I usually don't actually have reads until about page 50.
Posted: Sat Aug 17, 2019 10:29 am
by rosterfoster
In post 299, GreyICE wrote:going through momo's vote counts the following players have been voted:
The Fonz
cyrus62
Lil Uzi Vert
GreyICE
Baezu
Doctor Drew
Menalque
Jackal711
that leaves your scum list potential at
Karnage
mastina
elements
and i suppose if you must be complete gammaemerald
so i guess this raises the question, why aren't you voting karnage since he's guaranteed scum to you
unless this response of yours was total horseshit, of course
Nice to feel remembered.
Posted: Sat Aug 17, 2019 10:29 am
by GreyICE
why is some hobo with a chicken avatar posting in this game
And yes, that includes the one I casted for Baezu.
Urs is particularly bad, though.
For funsies, anyone else want to tell me why?
wait no ive got it
jackal is posting a whole bunch in mish-mash games but not here
and that means hes lurking
and fonz thinks lurkers are usually town and shouldnt be voted
did i get it
In post 290, cyrus62 wrote:you mean to tell me after 12 pages you don't see any one as scum or town yet? what have you been doing for 12 pages
You asked me for 4 reads.
yes roster what are you doing this game . you wait till page 50 to give reads? the game may not make it to page 50 so your basically siting voteing random
people . so tell me how are you helping town?
And yes, that includes the one I casted for Baezu.
Urs is particularly bad, though.
For funsies, anyone else want to tell me why?
wait no ive got it
jackal is posting a whole bunch in mish-mash games but not here
and that means hes lurking
and fonz thinks lurkers are usually town and shouldnt be voted
did i get it
Actually unsure if sarcastic (I'm not exactly noted as pro-lurker). The opposite was what I thought was true. I didn't see any other posts anywhere on site since his last post here. Since you have said this I have noted that Jackal did drop a couple of mishmash posts yesterday later than his last post here.
Nonetheless, he has made three posts
across the site
in the whole of the last ten days. Jackal looks like effectively an empty slot to me. Voting a player who appears to be 'lurking' but is actually just not online is a pretty common way scum try to fake scumhunt - it's of very low utility to town, but safe because you can avoid getting caught in the middle of whatever the main argument of the day is. Then he responds to me criticising his vote by saying that all the existing wagons are bad, which reinforces the feeling of scum hiding by parking his vote on an inactive.
If LUV had tried to rally other people to a Jackal vote - even so much as being like "Hey guys, let's get this lurker" I'd be less suspicious.
And yes, that includes the one I casted for Baezu.
Urs is particularly bad, though.
For funsies, anyone else want to tell me why?
wait no ive got it
jackal is posting a whole bunch in mish-mash games but not here
and that means hes lurking
and fonz thinks lurkers are usually town and shouldnt be voted
did i get it
Actually unsure if sarcastic (I'm not exactly noted as pro-lurker). The opposite was what I thought was true. I didn't see any other posts anywhere on site since his last post here. Since you have said this I have noted that Jackal did drop a couple of mishmash posts yesterday later than his last post here.
Nonetheless, he has made three posts
across the site
in the whole of the last ten days. Jackal looks like effectively an empty slot to me. Voting a player who appears to be 'lurking' but is actually just not online is a pretty common way scum try to fake scumhunt - it's of very low utility to town, but safe because you can avoid getting caught in the middle of whatever the main argument of the day is. Then he responds to me criticising his vote by saying that all the existing wagons are bad, which reinforces the feeling of scum hiding by parking his vote on an inactive.
If LUV had tried to rally other people to a Jackal vote - even so much as being like "Hey guys, let's get this lurker" I'd be less suspicious.
I didn’t vote Jackal for his inactivity and assuming I did is pretty scummy.
Seeing the Baezu wagon go nowhere coupled with not understanding any of the reasoning people have been giving for their votes motivated me to reread the game. I saw Jackal had voted for Cyrus and I didn’t like that he voted him for reasons he couldn’t discuss. I was hoping it would draw him out but I think these reactions are better.
I find it pretty laughable you think I have trouble faking scum hunting. There’s a lot of mislynch bait here as Mastina pointed out. There are also players like yourself and Grey that are easy to frustrate and distract the town. This is me disengaged and trying to see if throwing what little I have against the wall will work for me like it has been doing for practically everyone else.
Posted: Sat Aug 17, 2019 1:59 pm
by cyrus62
no one sees rosters attempts at dogging questions, from me? on giving reads saids he has to wait till page 50?
Posted: Sat Aug 17, 2019 2:42 pm
by Menalque
In post 296, The Fonz wrote:Third party gambit would be dumb if she's out and out scum and I don't see the point wasting discussion on this.
Why? Esp considering mastina?
Posted: Sat Aug 17, 2019 2:56 pm
by Karnage
In post 292, mastina wrote:And of the mislynch bait, I townread Baezu in spite of the scummy content. I scumread Menalque, you, and Karnage and have a backup scumread in the form of cyrus.
Thus my readslist.
The difference between you and I is that there is at least
a chance
that I'm town despite your scum read on me while you are 100% not town.
In post 296, The Fonz wrote:Third party gambit would be dumb if she's out and out scum and I don't see the point wasting discussion on this.
easy peasy day 2 policy lynch
Posted: Sat Aug 17, 2019 3:04 pm
by Karnage
In post 313, cyrus62 wrote:no one sees rosters attempts at dogging questions, from me? on giving reads saids he has to wait till page 50?
i dont know that its a big deal right now. Outside of the obvious (gamma/elements/mastina) I don't have any strong reads yet
Posted: Sat Aug 17, 2019 3:18 pm
by Gamma Emerald
In post 312, Lil Uzi Vert wrote:I didn’t vote Jackal for his inactivity and assuming I did is pretty scummy.
Pahahahaha! This so bull.
Alright then, what's so scummy about Jackal's one post?
And yes, that includes the one I casted for Baezu.
Urs is particularly bad, though.
For funsies, anyone else want to tell me why?
wait no ive got it
jackal is posting a whole bunch in mish-mash games but not here
and that means hes lurking
and fonz thinks lurkers are usually town and shouldnt be voted
did i get it
Actually unsure if sarcastic (I'm not exactly noted as pro-lurker). The opposite was what I thought was true. I didn't see any other posts anywhere on site since his last post here. Since you have said this I have noted that Jackal did drop a couple of mishmash posts yesterday later than his last post here.
Nonetheless, he has made three posts
across the site
in the whole of the last ten days. Jackal looks like effectively an empty slot to me. Voting a player who appears to be 'lurking' but is actually just not online is a pretty common way scum try to fake scumhunt - it's of very low utility to town, but safe because you can avoid getting caught in the middle of whatever the main argument of the day is. Then he responds to me criticising his vote by saying that all the existing wagons are bad, which reinforces the feeling of scum hiding by parking his vote on an inactive.
If LUV had tried to rally other people to a Jackal vote - even so much as being like "Hey guys, let's get this lurker" I'd be less suspicious.
I didn’t vote Jackal for his inactivity and assuming I did is pretty scummy.
Seeing the Baezu wagon go nowhere coupled with not understanding any of the reasoning people have been giving for their votes motivated me to reread the game. I saw
Jackal had voted for Cyrus and I didn’t like that he voted him for reasons he couldn’t discuss.
I was hoping it would draw him out but I think these reactions are better.
I find it pretty laughable you think I have trouble faking scum hunting. There’s a lot of mislynch bait here as Mastina pointed out. There are also players like yourself and Grey that are easy to frustrate and distract the town. This is me disengaged and trying to see if throwing what little I have against the wall will work for me like it has been doing for practically everyone else.
In post 312, Lil Uzi Vert wrote:I didn’t vote Jackal for his inactivity and assuming I did is pretty scummy.
Pahahahaha! This so bull.
Alright then, what's so scummy about Jackal's one post?
No your vote is bull.
There’s no reason for me as scum to draw attention to myself there by voting Jackal. I wasn’t on a single persons radar so I could’ve happily just continued to lurk and sit on the Baezu wagon. I could have also just joined one of the more of the popular growing wagons in Mena.
doctor drew told me to look in to roster so i did and i see roster doing nothing for town . hes doing nothing for town hes just acting like he is doing something for town.
doctor drew told me to look in to roster so i did and i see roster doing nothing for town . hes doing nothing for town hes just acting like he is doing something for town.
i see i said the same thing 3 times in a row.
Posted: Sat Aug 17, 2019 3:50 pm
by Doctor Drew
Besides my scum read on Cyrus, I am not a big fan of the major scum reads.
Menalque is playing way different than the one game i played with him where he was scum(granted he was in a hydra, but he basically played the game by himself). And tbh, he seemed pretty easy to scum read.
LUV, he makes a good point. Why do that and just leave when eventually someone would point it out. Either he is terrible at being scum, or he is a convenient wagon. Though I would appreciate him actually answering my question is asked in rvs haha.
Why don't we all take a deep breath, and just vote Cyrus?