Mafiascum.net

In post 299, Menalque wrote:I think GL and ali are both scum, or if not I think there is likely one scum in there

dam, if you just wanted in on the townbloc all you gotta do is say

i read 299
i know mena is wrong because i know im town
but even if i was not one of those 2 slots and i was a slot like say titus or someone outside mena, gl, me
i would still be able to look at that post and say that you're wrong and likely town
and i'm able to do this because i see and understand that you want to be right

In post 289, Titus wrote:All I get from you are feelings of sympathy not feelings of alignment. I want those.

It's page twelve and I've never been a fan of day one anyway. And besides after over a decade playing a certain way I'm still kinda adjusting to a new playstyle for reading people.

Tell ya what, tonight after I get off work I'll have a nice long reads list just full of my opinions of these twelve pages. Or however many we're at by midnight.

Why the tiger, Menalque?

In post 303, Hel wrote:Why the tiger, Menalque?

I felt like his opening post was very out of character for him and made me feel like he really wants to be perceived as town in a way I wouldn’t normally say he does

And I think his datisi take was bad and lazy and I dislike him doubling down on it instead of easing up once he spoke to me about it

In post 304, Menalque wrote:

In post 303, Hel wrote:Why the tiger, Menalque?

I felt like his opening post was very out of character for him and made me feel like he really wants to be perceived as town in a way I wouldn’t normally say he does

And I think his datisi take was bad and lazy and I dislike him doubling down on it instead of easing up once he spoke to me about it

I don't think you said anything that really addressed his concerns.

In post 299, Menalque wrote:I think GL and ali are both scum, or if not I think there is likely one scum in there

This made me go back and read GuiltyLion, and I have to agree, I'm not sure what in his first post is worthy of a townread and his push on Datisi doesn't seem legitimate, it's all references to "feels" but no direct quotes or anything of the like, so vague it can't really be counter-argued.

In post 304, Menalque wrote:

In post 303, Hel wrote:Why the tiger, Menalque?

I felt like his opening post was very out of character for him and made me feel like he really wants to be perceived as town in a way I wouldn’t normally say he does

And I think his datisi take was bad and lazy and I dislike him doubling down on it instead of easing up once he spoke to me about it

I'm not trying to be perceived as town, I'm trying to give thoughts on how we should try to play the game. It's a unique setup with weird mechanics, it feels disingenuous to try to compare that to how I may have opened with you in traditional mafia formats. I can point to plenty of times I've played weird mechanics games where I've opened or spent time on mechanics talk. I also find it misreppy of you in general to assume that's me trying to make some kind of LAMIST play instead of just setup talk.

As for Datisi, why would doubling down on it indicate scum!GL to you? Especially after I explicitly asked you to consider my view? I think Datisi's scum, if that was a made up belief I'd be likely to ease up on it, not less.

In post 306, maxwell wrote:

In post 299, Menalque wrote:I think GL and ali are both scum, or if not I think there is likely one scum in there

This made me go back and read GuiltyLion, and I have to agree, I'm not sure what in his first post is worthy of a townread and his push on Datisi doesn't seem legitimate, it's all references to "feels" but no direct quotes or anything of the like, so vague it can't really be counter-argued.

Alisae sees it. I'm not trying to make an argument that "can't be counter-argued", I'm just calling a vibe that feels off from someone I've played with as town a handful of times.

In post 306, maxwell wrote:

In post 299, Menalque wrote:I think GL and ali are both scum, or if not I think there is likely one scum in there

This made me go back and read GuiltyLion, and I have to agree, I'm not sure what in his first post is worthy of a townread and his push on Datisi doesn't seem legitimate, it's all references to "feels" but no direct quotes or anything of the like, so vague it can't really be counter-argued.

A feeling of this sense is a gut level read. It shouldn't be given much credence but it's better than nothing. This level of read is fine early day 1. There's not much to go off of.

Alright so.
I want to execute Menalque because I have no idea how to read him and that in turn interferes with all my other reads. I'm probably scumreading him I think? But also he said in the dead thread last game we were in together that he does scummy things on purpose to make them not scummy. So yeah, I haven't figured out how to read him, and him interacting with people then makes it hard for me to read them, so I have to have him dead to read the rest of the game.

I hope that makes some kind of sense.
VOTE: Execute Menalque
VOTE: Ship Copper
VOTE: Inspect Linen

I just deleted my wall catchup from my copy paste and i hate my life

In post 309, Radical Rat wrote:Alright so.
I want to execute Menalque because I have no idea how to read him and that in turn interferes with all my other reads. I'm probably scumreading him I think? But also he said in the dead thread last game we were in together that he does scummy things on purpose to make them not scummy. So yeah, I haven't figured out how to read him, and him interacting with people then makes it hard for me to read them, so I have to have him dead to read the rest of the game.

I hope that makes some kind of sense.
VOTE: Execute Menalque
VOTE: Ship Copper
VOTE: Inspect Linen

Have you considered just pretending Mena is not in the game?
Do you have anything else to contribute?

I did have other things to contribute, but shit happened IRL and I forgot. I'll probably have to read the game again later tbh.

Also to anyone else
Is it weird that I find RR’s post scummy, because I feel like its weird to immediately post something like that as your first post in the game
I have literally not see anyone enter the thread like that as their first post so its weird.

In post 312, Radical Rat wrote:I did have other things to contribute, but shit happened IRL and I forgot. I'll probably have to read the game again later tbh.

WOW ok

In post 311, Alisae wrote:Have you considered just pretending Mena is not in the game?
Do you have anything else to contribute?

scum wouldnt make dumb posts like that one hes prob town

OTHER PEOPLE IM LIKING

Titus (but Im not sure if its just because she admitted she always gets wagoned D1 or not that made me laugh)
Maxwell (the no lynch thing town is most likely to be antitown)

Im not remaking my catchup post its too much work ot do after a 13 hour day so im just flying by the seat of my pants



His "anger" reads forced as fuck it looks like fake scum AtE

I think youre picking at low hanging fruit because i get 100% where RR is coming from lol this game is confusing to anyone not in the "in" group

In post 316, notscience wrote:scum wouldnt make dumb posts like that one hes prob town

I do have a tendency to HATE something that may not exactly be scum indicative.
Though I’d feel like the expectations I have for him are low.

In post 314, Alisae wrote:

In post 312, Radical Rat wrote:I did have other things to contribute, but shit happened IRL and I forgot. I'll probably have to read the game again later tbh.

WOW ok

I honestly don't understand what problem you have with this?

Ya maybe I’ll pulling the trigger too early
UNVOTE:
I’ll at least let him answer my questions ig

Unvoting doesn't actually answer the question of what problem you have with it

In post 319, Umlaut wrote:

In post 314, Alisae wrote:

In post 312, Radical Rat wrote:I did have other things to contribute, but shit happened IRL and I forgot. I'll probably have to read the game again later tbh.

WOW ok

I honestly don't understand what problem you have with this?

because the only thing he talked about was mena and I’m not sure how thats the only thing you can remember and pay attention to but also not remember anything else

In post 321, Umlaut wrote:Unvoting doesn't actually answer the question of what problem you have with it

chill i didn’t see ur post

Ill forgive you if you clown username with me