Mafiascum.net

In post 275, JacksonVirgo wrote:I wasn't really meaning super long ones. Just the paragraph ones, where it's more than a sentence.

that is such a weird comment to make about skitter when almost all her posts are one-liners. there's literally only one of her posts that is 4+ sentences long.

why pick out her?

especially when there --




1/2

2/2



especially when there are half a dozen other players who have posted with an amount of verbosity. not to mention me, who has actually posted a couple of walls.

i agree with peta. i simply don't buy this is genuine town thought.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: jacksonvirgo

Hoopla, I'm pretty sure you're too good of a player to buy this reasoning.

Why is that weird thought more likely to come from scum than town?

Like, what's the scum motivation here? I think it's just laziness.

Actually, probably more noteworthy is skitter's response to that read. She just took it in stride and told JV it was NAI instead of pointing out that she didn't have any long posts.

Good point, I do think it had more to do with effort than length? We'll see what jackson says

In post 304, Something_Smart wrote:Why is that weird thought more likely to come from scum than town?

looks to me like he threw out a surface-level offhand 'read' on skitter, then when someone pressed him on it, he just made up some BS and doubled down on it when pressed again.

i think if this was a genuine town observation, it's more likely for him to have had this thought about me (someone who has actually posted walls).

In post 303, Infinity 324 wrote:Hoopla, I'm pretty sure you're too good of a player to buy this reasoning.

that's where you're wrong!

Yeah that looks weird enough to vote and see what happens.
VOTE: JacksonVirgo

I got a chuckle out of 301 and 302.

In post 309, Hoopla wrote:looks to me like he threw out a surface-level offhand 'read' on skitter, then when someone pressed him on it, he just made up some BS and doubled down on it when pressed again.

This is in theory possible, but not what I was asking. It's possible that they made it up out of thin air; it's also possible that they misremembered skitter's posts as being longer than they were. If they did misremember, that's obviously not alignment indicative, so what makes you think it was a fabrication rather than an error?

In post 312, Something_Smart wrote:If they did misremember, that's obviously not alignment indicative, so what makes you think it was a fabrication rather than an error?

at first, i assumed it was probably an error and that jackson must have swapped me & skitter in his head. but he was explicitly asked that:

In post 269, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 263, Infinity 324 wrote: Do you mean hoopla? I get the feeling she's known as the setup speccer so it's kind of expected of her.

Nah I mean skitter

if it was an error, it would have been revealed then.

In post 312, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 309, Hoopla wrote:looks to me like he threw out a surface-level offhand 'read' on skitter, then when someone pressed him on it, he just made up some BS and doubled down on it when pressed again.

This is in theory possible, but not what I was asking. It's possible that they made it up out of thin air; it's also possible that they misremembered skitter's posts as being longer than they were. If they did misremember, that's obviously not alignment indicative, so what makes you think it was a fabrication rather than an error?

This could hold some weight behind it as JV did also forget about the time of Peta's unvote.

In post 307, Something_Smart wrote:Actually, probably more noteworthy is skitter's response to that read.

She just took it in stride and told JV it was NAI instead of pointing out that she didn't have any long posts.

What do you take from her not pointing it out?

I don't know. It seems more unskitterly than anything else.

My instinct is to say that it's more likely scum looking to grab towncred by pointing out why she shouldn't be townread, but I don't know if skitter thinks like that.

I'm only slightly aware of Skitter's rep and have only had one game with her hence why I asked

I feel like most good players would make a similar move as either alignment

In post 316, Something_Smart wrote:I don't know. It seems more unskitterly than anything else.

My instinct is to say that it's more likely scum looking to grab towncred by pointing out why she shouldn't be townread, but I don't know if skitter thinks like that.

this is an aside, but you're one of those type characters, no?

I think s_s is town

In post 297, Uncrowned wrote:So far JV's two reads have been myself and Skitter as town.

Would you mind elaborating on these a bit more JV?

My original reasoning of skitter was called out by skiiter themself which makes me think they're Town a lot more. I just realised that their posts look a lot smaller to those who don't have split windows (like a video to the right and the MS to the left).

But their post regarding choosing Multitasking over choosing informed is townie to me as scum doing so would probably put heavy heat on them, as it did this game.

My read on you is probably bias as well due to everything but I think that your tone is super genuine and that's why you're a TR of mine.

In post 309, Hoopla wrote:

In post 304, Something_Smart wrote:Why is that weird thought more likely to come from scum than town?

looks to me like he threw out a surface-level offhand 'read' on skitter, then when someone pressed him on it, he just made up some BS and doubled down on it when pressed again.

i think if this was a genuine town observation, it's more likely for him to have had this thought about me (someone who has actually posted walls).

In post 303, Infinity 324 wrote:Hoopla, I'm pretty sure you're too good of a player to buy this reasoning.

that's where you're wrong!

You didn't give me cake, so you're insta scum I don't have to read you owo

In post 276, Uncrowned wrote:If we're comparing Skitter to Peta (who you're voting) in terms of non-setup related discussion, they're pretty similar, no?

In what way?

In post 307, Something_Smart wrote:Actually, probably more noteworthy is skitter's response to that read. She just took it in stride and told JV it was NAI instead of pointing out that she didn't have any long posts.

I dont have a sense for how long my posts are this gane in particular, and i get someone (wrongly) townreading me for something along those lines nearly every game i play. But post length/how many posts/efforting is nai for me, and i'm reasonably confident you (or someone else who knows me) would have complained if i *didnt* point that out

In post 316, Something_Smart wrote:I don't know. It seems more unskitterly than anything else.

My instinct is to say that it's more likely scum looking to grab towncred by pointing out why she shouldn't be townread, but I don't know if skitter thinks like that.

I point out it's nai as both alignments