Explosiva Mafia - GAME OVER

[forbiddanlight]

Your meta is based on your first couple of games of mafia, where a mislynch is always easy to push pretty much regardless of person.

And Bad idea mafia like 50 people could pull the trigger. Only one can here, and I know DGB knows it is in the town's best interest to follow the voting system unless we don't let the voting system do anything for us.

Fine. As I said though, my vote stands.

And those weren't my first games of mafia. I've been playing for close to 2 years now. I have more experience than my join date. My main problem is trouble I have defending as town. It's really quite odd. It was also troublesome getting used to the incredibly friggen long days you all advocate around here. Where I play, days are over in 72 hours, nights between 24 and 48. Here you just take years to get a lynch finally. And I'm still not sure your accuracy rate is much better.

[M4yhem]

I'm the same, Forbidden. I get horribly frustrated by the pace of these games.

[Battousai]

Can you guys do this one favor for me (M4yhem, BM, etc...)? Will you guys and gals stop double or triple plosting when there are plenty of other active players? You guys are going to make rereading accurately almost impossible. Hell, it takes me a while just to catchup after not posting for 24 hrs.

Also another favor for BM- Will you please stop cluttering the thread. We all know you don't understand hypotheticals, but come on. It's quite clear Coron was being hypothetical a few pages back and didn't claim scum. Your making Coron defend something that really doesn't need to be defended.

If I was the King (bomb carrier), I would take out someone to avoid all this clutter, and was the most suspicious of the clutterers, BM. So,

Vote:BM

for cluttering the thread, accusing players (Coron) of something they did first (insults) and trying to lynch a player based on a hypothetical and twisting it into a scum claim.

[Crazy]

Unvote, Vote Forbiddan

Don't like that post where she said her vote was pure OMGUS because votes don't really matter. Yeah.

I really don't see how Coron claimed scum.

As for BM, I hope Stoofer's 5th Law applies here.

[forbiddanlight]

Don't like that post where she said her vote was pure OMGUS because votes don't really matter. Yeah.

k, have fun being wrong. Also, thoughts on Tar's BS case?

[Crazy]

Don't like that post where she said her vote was pure OMGUS because votes don't really matter. Yeah.

k, have fun being wrong. Also, thoughts on Tar's BS case?

Meh, it's all about whether you agree with IIoA or not. Since he does, I don't find it scummy, because the case does fit with that scum-tell at least.

[forbiddanlight]

Fair nuff. But do you agree with IIoA, especially in a setting with different mechanics from a normal game?

[Crazy]

Fair nuff. But do you agree with IIoA, especially in a setting with different mechanics from a normal game?

In this case, I do agree with it.

a. This game is incredibly simple, and the setup really doesn't need that much discussion.
b. It surprises me that anyone joins a game without knowing some basic things about the game, such as it being useless for scum to give another scum a bomb. That's the thing you'd think of before the game even started.

[forbiddanlight]

a. This game is incredibly simple, and the setup really doesn't need that much discussion.
b. It surprises me that anyone joins a game without knowing some basic things about the game, such as it being useless for scum to give another scum a bomb. That's the thing you'd think of before the game even started.

Nyeh, I honestly didn't care. I just wanted to blow someone up. I don't think about things before a game. I mean geez, it's a game, I'm not gonna waste life trying to figure things out before it's even started. I don't go into ANY game with a specific strategy, I just play.

[forbiddanlight]

EBWOP: Also, what of Tar's completely ignoring other IIoAs? Of which there are many in the game.

[M4yhem]

Sure, Battousai, I'll try to let at least two other people post between my posts, just for you.

Crazy- Do you think then that the people asking setup questions are scum faking stupidity?

I'm not sure I agree with IIoA. There was a lot of setup (and endgame) speculation in Bad idea mafia and most of the participants were town.

[Crazy]

Crazy- Do you think then that the people asking setup questions are scum faking stupidity?

I believe it's a good possibility. Iron Man is the worst case in this game, asking if there were any lynches in this game. I'd vote him, but since he's not on DGB's list, I'll

FoS

him.

[forbiddanlight]

I believe it's a good possibility. Iron Man is the worst case in this game, asking if there were any lynches in this game. I'd vote him, but since he's not on DGB's list, I'll FoS him.

Ok, well, you are sold on me. Any particular reason why NOT the others?

[Crazy]

I believe it's a good possibility. Iron Man is the worst case in this game, asking if there were any lynches in this game. I'd vote him, but since he's not on DGB's list, I'll FoS him.

Ok, well, you are sold on me. Any particular reason why NOT the others?

I don't like the others either.

[DragonsofSummer]

I have no intentions of staying on MS past 6ishPM (which I often do, but usually at that time I don't actually respond properly as I'm either A, getting ready to go out, B eating or C surfing something else on the internet.), because I do have some sort of a social life you know, last night, for example, I was going to a BBQ, and next week I'm going back to school, so you see I do do things other than MS.

Right which is why I added the aside. I just don't like how you came into the game asking a question which had already been answered multiple times by multiple people, and then when called on it said that you wanted a serious answer (as much as it may not seem like it all of the previous answers were fairly serious in regards to it).

As for why the scum would pick a specific person I completely disagree that day 1 is the right day to talk about it. Maybe a few days down the road (like day 3 or 4) when there is at least some sort of pattern to look at it might be helpful, but at this point in the game it is pure speculation and does absolutely nothing.

@FL: Do you not agree with IIoA? and for that matter who do you feel is committing IIoA that Tar is ignoring?

@BM: I feel like you are being completely irrational at this point in the case of Coron. Though the fact that his playstyle and your playstyle are so radically different amuses me. (Besides it has been far to long since I've actually had a chance to play in a game with you.)

@Tar: I'm interested in hearing more from you about other people than FL.

[forbiddanlight]

I don't like the others either.

Why? You know, you can't just be like "kk, forbiddan is doing this, I don't care about anyone else. I'll just say they look bad and hope no one notices"

@FL: Do you not agree with IIoA? and for that matter who do you feel is committing IIoA that Tar is ignoring?

*sigh*, let's see. Most of the people in the "Why did they give the bomb to DGB debate", actually. Twomz is one, but he's only posted 3 times.
alvinz as well, but I think Tar mentioned him.
Batt to an extent doesn't seem to be scumhunting that hard.
Haschel is definitely in this group, but only has three posts and V/LA.
As mentioned before, that's ALL Iron Man is doing.
Jex' only post was in the random phase and not incredibly enlightening.
Oh, and Jordan hasn't posted ANY content at all. It's not IIoA, but it's all noise.
K7 just noticed the thread, so I won't say anything on that yet.
Max isn't doing much of anything either and was in the DGB debate. His only semi contented post was the one where he agrees with Tar.

That seems to be most everyone. They can't all be scum. To be fair I went past just IIoA as a scumtell, but most of the cases are close. In the end, we haven't been playing long enough to get good reads, and I personally think that's one reason why such an early IIoA call is crap. You can remove Haschel and K7 from being suspected by me in that list for now. If I were to vote ANYONE, and not just DGB's targets, I'd go for Jordan.

[Crazy]

Why? You know, you can't just be like "kk, forbiddan is doing this, I don't care about anyone else. I'll just say they look bad and hope no one notices"

I thought the question was "Out of this list, who would you execute." If I was the King, I'd pick Iron Man over you, but he's not on that list.

[forbiddanlight]

I thought the question was "Out of this list, who would you execute." If I was the King, I'd pick Iron Man over you, but he's not on that list.

No, my question is, what are your thoughts on the others in that list. You've never listed them far as I can tell, you've just focused on me and my IIoA supposedly.

[Crazy]

I thought the question was "Out of this list, who would you execute." If I was the King, I'd pick Iron Man over you, but he's not on that list.

No, my question is, what are your thoughts on the others in that list. You've never listed them far as I can tell, you've just focused on me and my IIoA supposedly.

It's not zero content that I'm worried about. This is right at the beginning of the game, and some people are bound to have zero content. It's the people that are asking really obvious questions.

[DrippingGoofball]

I'm also willing to explode DragonsofSummer on account of his last post. Possibly sooner than later.

[M4yhem]

What in particular caught your eye, DGB?

[forbiddanlight]

I thought the question was "Out of this list, who would you execute." If I was the King, I'd pick Iron Man over you, but he's not on that list.

No, my question is, what are your thoughts on the others in that list. You've never listed them far as I can tell, you've just focused on me and my IIoA supposedly.

It's not zero content that I'm worried about. This is right at the beginning of the game, and some people are bound to have zero content. It's the people that are asking really obvious questions.

You are evading my question. I think you should answer it or you look suspect.

[Crazy]

You are evading my question. I think you should answer it or you look suspect.

Most of the people on your list have just done little content so far. I expect them to post content eventually, but now that's not the problem. If any of those people seem to have asked dumb questions to avoid looking like scum, then I'll be suspicious of them. Right now I don't feel like looking through those people to see if any of them have done that, though. However, I am suspicious of Iron Man and you.

[forbiddanlight]

Most of the people on your list have just done little content so far. I expect them to post content eventually, but now that's not the problem. If any of those people seem to have asked dumb questions to avoid looking like scum, then I'll be suspicious of them. Right now I don't feel like looking through those people to see if any of them have done that, though. However, I am suspicious of Iron Man and you.

Cept my question wasn't precisely dumb, because I was trying to figure out if there was any way for scum to lock the game and how to stop it should that possiblity exist. Thankfully, it doesn't, at least not by the method I was thinking. Course, K-scope never answered anyway, but oh well.

[Battousai]

M4yhem, that's all I ask . Three successive posts that can easily be made into one is a little much.

DGB- I can't really find anything in DoS's last post that looks scummy.

FL-

You are evading my question. I think you should answer it or you look suspect.

That's more or less a loaded question. As it implies that not answering the question is scummy, and answering the question would make you look like your trying not to look scummy.