Open 635 - JK9++ (Game Over)

[Frozen Angel]

Titus, Postie:

As a birthday gift to RC, mind switching to Thor?

lol

[RadiantCowbells]

*pokes FA*

[mhsmith0]

mhs I felt like your pushing a delimma there. what about two wagons with 2 votes on proof there must be scum between them? Scum need 2 town votes to make a wagon going.

and I guess RC had only one vote on himself the whole time.

Each wagon would have to have at least one wolf between its voters and votee. If Ranger/RC/Thor are all town, then the mafia could all pile on and quick lynch. Ditto Titus/Postie/SC.

Probably wasn't clear in making that point.

this means RC-Ranger and Titus-Postie aren't scum together?

RC-Ranger could be mafia together. Technically Titus-Postie could as well (though again, the night actions from that group would be so bizarre that I simply don't consider it reasonable). Also could be RC-Titus, in which case who knows about Thor and SC.

[Frozen Angel]

Happy Birthday you ... RC!

[RadiantCowbells]

I want a birthday present FA

[Ranger]

lol

Yes, I know, I switched off.
Scum lynch is a scum lynch. Doesn't matter on who.

[Frozen Angel]

I'm thinking about one ...

[mhsmith0]

I find it likelier that SC is mafia than Thor (though still reading), I find it much likelier that SC is mafia PR than Thor, and I find it likelier that Titus/Postie is town/town than RC/Ranger is town/town.

I suppose this

is

valid, though.

If Thor is scum, he is probably vanilla anyway.

So,
VOTE: SirCakez.

I'm not ready to sheep, but I don't think I object. lol if this is part one of the quick-hammer though (if that happens, anti doesn't get to be mad at me post-game like he was in our last game together).

[Ranger]

I'm thinking about one ...

Well, lynching scum would be one.
Certainly would boost his ego.

[mhsmith0]

btw, happy birthday RC

[RadiantCowbells]

I find it likelier that SC is mafia than Thor (though still reading), I find it much likelier that SC is mafia PR than Thor, and I find it likelier that Titus/Postie is town/town than RC/Ranger is town/town.

I suppose this

is

valid, though.

If Thor is scum, he is probably vanilla anyway.

So,
VOTE: SirCakez.

I'm not ready to sheep, but I don't think I object. lol if this is part one of the quick-hammer though (if that happens, anti doesn't get to be mad at me post-game like he was in our last game together).

For it to be a quickhammer FA would need to vote.

[Frozen Angel]

mhs I felt like your pushing a delimma there. what about two wagons with 2 votes on proof there must be scum between them? Scum need 2 town votes to make a wagon going.

and I guess RC had only one vote on himself the whole time.

Each wagon would have to have at least one wolf between its voters and votee. If Ranger/RC/Thor are all town, then the mafia could all pile on and quick lynch. Ditto Titus/Postie/SC.

Probably wasn't clear in making that point.

this means RC-Ranger and Titus-Postie aren't scum together?

RC-Ranger could be mafia together. Technically Titus-Postie could as well (though again, the night actions from that group would be so bizarre that I simply don't consider it reasonable). Also could be RC-Titus, in which case who knows about Thor and SC.

There can't be 3 tpr liers (or it can be? I will check that) so 2 tpr on one wagon , the other 2 on the other one. one scum must be in each ? means the town on same wagon aren't a team.

[Ranger]

btw, happy birthday RC

I don't think I've actually said these words officially, either, so...yeah.

Happy birthday, RC.

[mhsmith0]

Yes, that is accurate. And you are both here. And Titus and Postie aren't. So if that's it, that's it. I'm feeling cautiously optimistic that it isn't at this point.

[mhsmith0]

mhs I felt like your pushing a delimma there. what about two wagons with 2 votes on proof there must be scum between them? Scum need 2 town votes to make a wagon going.

and I guess RC had only one vote on himself the whole time.

Each wagon would have to have at least one wolf between its voters and votee. If Ranger/RC/Thor are all town, then the mafia could all pile on and quick lynch. Ditto Titus/Postie/SC.

Probably wasn't clear in making that point.

this means RC-Ranger and Titus-Postie aren't scum together?

RC-Ranger could be mafia together. Technically Titus-Postie could as well (though again, the night actions from that group would be so bizarre that I simply don't consider it reasonable). Also could be RC-Titus, in which case who knows about Thor and SC.

There can't be 3 tpr liers (or it can be? I will check that) so 2 tpr on one wagon , the other 2 on the other one. one scum must be in each ? means the town on same wagon aren't a team.

Possibilities:
1) 3 VT claims are mafia: SC and Thor (wagonees) are both mafia
2) RC/Ranger team: SC is the third (barring a quick hammer which hasn't happened yet at least)
3) Titus/Postie team: Thor is the third (and with only one doc, they'd just shoot Ranger tonight given a ML)
4) RC/Titus team: any VT claim could be the third

[mhsmith0]

PS FA and I are both on, it is now impossible for there to be an FA/MHS/Thor team (since we'd quick hammer SC). More progress of sorts.

[RadiantCowbells]

FA, assuming that it is in fact Titus/Postie, who would your 1 pick for scum be in the VTs?

[Frozen Angel]

w8 is thor online?

[Ranger]

At this stage, I'm not actually sure which of {mhsmith, Frozen Angel} is town, but I'm like 95% certain we're in the 3-VT scenario.

I do think that it'd be appropriate for, if we're gonna lynch on any day, it to be during RC's birthday. If it's on scum, it's a birthday present; if it's on town, well, I suppose it's an ironic birthday present but it still counts as a present. :P

[RadiantCowbells]

FA pls

[Frozen Angel]

FA, assuming that it is in fact Titus/Postie, who would your 1 pick for scum be in the VTs?

I would have said mhs last night but I lost my confident.

[Ranger]

FA pls :(

Honestly, I'm having a crisis of confidence and am worried she may be scum with SC.

[Frozen Angel]

PS FA and I are both on, it is now impossible for there to be an FA/MHS/Thor team (since we'd quick hammer SC). More progress of sorts.

this is like a semi slip

Thor is not online. how you scratched him ?

[Ranger]

I believe the plan here is protecting Postie, dunno who RC/Postie target, but...we should be good no matter what if we get a scum lynch now.

[RadiantCowbells]

Ugh FA just vote please.