Mafiascum.net

In post 477, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 458, Almost50 wrote:

In post 445, Gamma Emerald wrote:@Almost50 who here have you played with?

All but Nako and Dolittle.

Hem. Who has seen you as town and in what games?

This also feels like a weird question at the moment. Why are you asking only "town" games and not scum ones? TMI slip?

In post 506, DVa wrote:I have some mixed feelings about BearAvi being lynched today, but I can't decide if there's a better wagon out of Cloud'sDaddy, PenguinGifs, Tyrion, and Neegan.

DVa said this when I was voting scum. Hmm...

In post 3075, Nako wrote:

In post 477, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 458, Almost50 wrote:

In post 445, Gamma Emerald wrote:@Almost50 who here have you played with?

All but Nako and Dolittle.

Hem. Who has seen you as town and in what games?

This also feels like a weird question at the moment. Why are you asking only "town" games and not scum ones? TMI slip?

Okay I know the logic to this is somewhere in my brain, and it has something to do with the softing A50 did super early

In post 520, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 519, OkaPoka wrote:Gamma why are you voting DDL and why aren't you voting kokichi?

DDL is a scumlean
Kokichi I don’t really have an opinion on

Gamma did not jump off from the wagon on scum when he could.

In post 3077, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 3075, Nako wrote:

In post 477, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 458, Almost50 wrote:

In post 445, Gamma Emerald wrote:@Almost50 who here have you played with?

All but Nako and Dolittle.

Hem. Who has seen you as town and in what games?

This also feels like a weird question at the moment. Why are you asking only "town" games and not scum ones? TMI slip?

Okay I know the logic to this is somewhere in my brain, and it has something to do with the softing A50 did super early

A50 was attacked at N1.
Hmm...

In post 542, DVa wrote:Kokichi vote Neegan?

DVa was trying to get people to vote a counter wagon to scum.

In post 572, DrDolittle wrote:

In post 563, DVa wrote:maybe if you and gamma both join he will gain some motivation to do more than one post per day?

Fine I can do this
VOTE: Radja

DVa gets more people to counter wagon to DDl. DDl was scum so why he needed convincing to get into the CW? Was creating a CW discussed in The Daytalk?

In post 637, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 606, DrDolittle wrote:

In post 585, OkaPoka wrote:Have you found scum yet kokichi?

I'm helping

Nice #metoo moment. I’ve done this before as scum. I now feel less apprehensive about my vote.

Would Gamma point this out if he was scum with DDl?

In post 639, Gamma Emerald wrote:That was me calling DDL scum

In post 640, Nako wrote:Whoops


VOTE: DrDolittle

In post 641, DVa wrote:Hmm, we never really got a reaction from Radja tho

DVa did not like my revote on the scum.

In post 659, OkaPoka wrote:Dva why aren't you sheeping nako?

In post 661, DVa wrote:lol that's a funny question

thinking about it, but so far we have usually waited for a reaction from the player we push before switching off

In post 675, DVa wrote:Townier
Nako / Gamma-chan / OkaPokey
Joey_From_Friends
Kokichi AFK
BrightEyedFish / DrBearAvi
PenguinGifs / 50Monkeys / Sephiroth
Tyrion
Neegan
Scummier

Feel like I'm somewhere around here atm

These posts have don't many time between each other. DVa said they would consider a DDl vote, but DDl is not that low on her list?
She was either trying to pocket me or made a slip by putting their partner higher. (She would do that if she believed DDl was a town, but then she would not say "I thinked about voting DDl with Nako")

In post 444, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 440, Nako wrote:Almost50, what do you think about BEF at the moment?

Would like to chime in that I find the attacks against A50 rather unsettling and maybe telling of who might be on the scumteam

Ok this is ACTUALLY why I asked who had played with town!A50
I figured anyone who had would know his playstyle and how dangerous it can be and want him gone

In post 728, DVa wrote:

In post 721, Tchill13 wrote:I can't believe this day 1 still isn't over lol. Kinda ridiculous.

Why? We're not even halfway through day 1 and you're not hard pushing a wagon and don't seem certain on having caught scum?

In post 723, Tchill13 wrote:Dva kokichi and DDL. I'd shoot them all today, with vig shots if I could.

What is this, OMGUS? What don't you like about my posts? This feels like a really fake reaction to the thread tbh

VOTE: Tyrion

Is anyone actually townreading Tyrion atm?

DVa realized Radja wagon won't get any vote then picked Tchill.
I want to point out one thing:
DVa was waiting for her biggest scumread's reaction while voting for him, and the scumread replaced out.
Why she did not comment on this?

In post 3085, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 444, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 440, Nako wrote:Almost50, what do you think about BEF at the moment?

Would like to chime in that I find the attacks against A50 rather unsettling and maybe telling of who might be on the scumteam

Ok this is ACTUALLY why I asked who had played with town!A50
I figured anyone who had would know his playstyle and how dangerous it can be and want him gone

Hmm, makes sense.

In post 756, DVa wrote:Gamma what do you think of Tyrion rn?

In post 758, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 756, DVa wrote:Gamma what do you think of Tyrion rn?

I think I already said I doubt my ability to read him
Why do you ask?

Like, if Gamma is scum here he is literally ignoring every possibility to jump on another wagon. I don't know why would he do that as a scum on a scum wagon.

In post 830, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 828, Almost50 wrote:

In post 827, OkaPoka wrote:Like literally this BES vs Kokichi thing (very similar conversation) just happened in DDU in NASO vs Saudade and we ended up lynching NASO instead of Saudade.

You know what? I don't even know what you're talking about, but I'll trust and sheep you.

VOTE: BEF

Now I expect some to question my vote on BEF when I say I'm sheeping Oka. I had my own suspicion on BEF from earlier, and I only backed off bc DVa reminded me of something.

But I also very much understand Oka's approach (although not the incident he's referring to), and I know I have been there myself once too many where I pint out something being a scumtell based on my own experience and even provide links to previous incidents and still nobody listens. It has been 66.667% successful in nailing scum on a precise tell, and 75% on another.

So, while I can't say for sure if it's the exact same thing here I know it has to have a higher probability of nailing Scum still. In otherv words, I'm not "blindly" sheeping a read, but I'm rather sheeping a "scum hunting technique" that I'm very well familiar with.

Check Oka’s vote
And I’ll vote Kokichi because the DDL wagon is dead I guess
VOTE: Kokichi

Would he jump off with saying this if he was scum with DDl?

In post 867, Gamma Emerald wrote:VOTE: DDL
Maybe this can get some more votes now

Why would he try to get a CW on a scum partner while the main wagon was dissolving because of Kokichi's claim? Would he bus like this?

In post 964, Gamma Emerald wrote:VOTE: PenguinPower
Okay this is approaching lolcat territory

Jumps from scum to another scum...

*Insert Nako Surprised GIF here* (I don't have time to actually do that.)

I am willing to vote DVA at the moment.

In post 942, DVa wrote:VOTE: PP

DVa did that before though...

Anyways, voting while there were less vote is safer than voting it while it had more votes, so it also looks good from Gamma's side. He also dislikes a Tchill wagon while on PP so yeah...
I need to go now but be back from where I left.

Kokichi, if you think DVa is good here, consider reading the newbie game where DVa tried to pocket Thor at LyLo.

In post 516, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 513, Almost50 wrote:

In post 477, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 458, Almost50 wrote:

In post 445, Gamma Emerald wrote:@Almost50 who here have you played with?

All but Nako and Dolittle.

Hem. Who has seen you as town and in what games?

Come on, Gamma. You don't really want me to go through all my games to see who was in which!

Well, you were there when I was Town and PP got lynched as Town on D1 in Diffusion of Powers. Oka was with me in 2 games, but I only remember the one with the Cannibals flavour. Tchill in several games, including one as JJD. Hmm.. As A50 I think he was in the game where everyone was a Dayvig. Radja also in a couple of games.. I think he was in the Team Mafia one with me?? Seph has been with me in the last game I played as AP (and yes he knows it's me now). BEF also (same game as Seph). Joey has been with me in numerous games, including Civilization (which you were also in). Kokichi in 3-4 games, but I can recall the one with Wisdon & N_M where Alisae was scum with Jeanne, and one that immediately followed that where we were Neighbours, and Mastina, Chara, LLD and Toranaga were all in the game. Finally, DVa is an alt and doesn't wish to out.

Well shit. Was thinking someone on the scumteam had knowledge of your Town game and was concerned about it, but that says nothing I guess

Hm with the numbers whittled down I think this should be revisited
DVa what’s you experience with A50 on all your accounts? Some games would be nice

In post 964, Gamma Emerald wrote:VOTE: PenguinPower
Okay this is approaching lolcat territory

Honestly feel like this could still hold water.
FYI I am working on towncasing myself rn
Btw @Nako who do you want to vote rn?

Fuck I lost my progress in the towncase
I’ll get it back and post what I had, probably best to avoid putting too much in one post anyway

In post 3056, Nako wrote:I'm trying really hard to read DVa, she has been townie in this game but I don't understand why did she Gamma so fast, she did not even consider me being a scum chance (I protected PP whole game, we could be scum partners from obsever PoV).
A50 metaread Gamma at some point in this game and I also liked his posts at the first time, however those were not really strong since those can be faked. But IDK if Gamma plays like this as scum.

I voted Gamma precisely because I am not completely certain you aren't scum. However, there are things pointing in your favor. For one, you were not on the Mew wagon. Second, your reactions to me throughout day 1 seemed relatively townie. Third, your desire for a mass claim after the failed nightkill on A50 seems much more likely to come from town than from scum. Nonetheless, when we consider the Mew wagon, it seems much more likely to be a desperation push given how bad those actions would be for scum--but only if Gamma is scum.

The plan, given Sephiroth's claimed intentions before the counter-push onto Mew and A50's dumb acceptance that Seph should shoot him, was to lynch PP, vig you, and have A50 investigate Gamma. Given Sephiroth's vig shot was uncertain (it's always hard to tell with vigs), what is baffling here is why Gamma (who is certainly going to be alive and likely cleared by A50) would opt to lynch Mew, and you (who in this scenario would be scum getting shot) would stay off wagon.

Also, A50's metareads are generally not good, if my experience with him in 2040 are any indication.

In post 3058, Nako wrote:If PP is scum and if DVa is town, PP bussed both of his partners? IDK how likely is that. Can anyone tell me what do they know about PP?

PP is competent enough scum that he would certainly play for endgame. Strong scum players tend to bus both of their partners strongly, since they want as much towncred in endgame as possible.