Mafiascum.net

In post 3068, Menalque wrote:also Dave, also peta

Getting a new refrigerator delivered.

In post 3079, Menalque wrote: Dave could be a scum reaction

My non reaction from not being here could be what?

In post 3110, Menalque wrote:so does anyone have a problem with just sequentially eliminating (Best Bird, Dave, lilith, peta)?

Not but I also need to do ISOs and meta people

In post 3117, Best Bird wrote:Dunno - {s_s; infinity; maybe hoopla)

Of course - I have a back of the mind of mena because of the crappy entrance, hasn't found scum, not dead, and a difficult counterwagon to town but skitteR said he was a strongest townread so...

What is your gun-to-head solve? According to you there’s very likely 2 scum in {me, mena, s_s, hoopla}, and you really don’t seem convinced on mena, s_s, or hoopla. It looks worse knowing I’m town. Do you just have generic paranoia towards a bunch of slots or what’s up?

In post 3128, Infinity 324 wrote:

In post 3117, Best Bird wrote:Dunno - {s_s; infinity; maybe hoopla)

Of course - I have a back of the mind of mena because of the crappy entrance, hasn't found scum, not dead, and a difficult counterwagon to town but skitteR said he was a strongest townread so...

What is your gun-to-head solve? According to you there’s very likely 2 scum in {me, mena, s_s, hoopla}, and you really don’t seem convinced on mena, s_s, or hoopla. It looks worse knowing I’m town. Do you just have generic paranoia towards a bunch of slots or what’s up?

I mean that’s not what I said but sure say what you want it to mean. Also, not sure why you said I don’t seemed convince on ss given no qualifier same as you. I don’t think you’ve been towny at all so idrc what looks worse to you.

Like - it’s pretty transparent and easily discernible that I don’t have strong reads anywhere.

You said there’s 1 scum 2 in {you, dave, peta, lilith}. If there’s 1 scum in there, and the rest are in {me, hoopla, mena, s_s} then there’s 2 in the latter group. I said you didn’t seem convinced on s_s because you said he wasn’t at the top of your elim list when asked about it by mena.

I get that you don’t have reads but I want you to get them. It’s frustrating to try to put in effort when everyone else has given up, and if town doesn’t try it makes it too easy for scum to hide.

Right. Maybe means there a possibility of each occurrence not that one occurrence is as you stated.

So...maybe two and if so, it’s probs Dave and Lilith. Not at the top of my elim list is deference to skitteR not my view.

I misread the tone of your post. I still want you to be more solvy.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯

idrc

now that we know there's no cop, i'm of the opinion we should full massclaim now, doc included.

there is no value in keeping the doc hidden because:

1) there is no cop (thus no innocents), with only N_M as a potential prob-town candidate worth protecting
2) we're in odd numbers, so a correct doc save doesn't even yield us an extra mis-elim
3) there is too much lingering haze, particularly around the N1 no-kill, that getting all the cards on the table would help the town's ability to collectively PoE. an extra exposed prob-town slot (doc) makes solving much easier as it rules out/minimises certain combinations of players
4) if there's no doc, this is info we need now, as it changes a lot of things

scum already knows the answer to the N1 riddle. we have a better chance of cracking the game by figuring that out, and that requires a massclaim. scum have also elected to hide the cop, so we know there will be a fakeclaiming scum amongst (dave, SS, infinity, peta, mena). a massclaim may be able to narrow down that field of the lying scum.

too much hinges on the lilith slot to properly solve, so we need to focus on that first, but in order to do that we need to massclaim. there's more to gain by massclaim at the moment than what we're giving up.

meh i'll claim vt as i've made myself pretty obvious anyway

In post 3136, petapan wrote:meh i'll claim vt as i've made myself pretty obvious anyway

what role did you go for?

night 3 vig

in the spirit of altruism, i'll claim now:

VT, went for cop

i want dave to claim next.

wondering if there's too much casual confidence to infinity's posts from the start of the day

Town will lose now. I wanted to know if there was a doc or not first.
1-shot watcher.
Meet your next NK.

Lilith if you're town . Our only hope is scum kill someone else AND I guess who it is and watch them.

If Lilith is town, I'm absolutely floored that both of the top 2 picks went for a scum (IMO) role. Take a role with unambiguous results over one that leaves more questions than answers. Always!

Lilith won’t be able to jk you because we’re flipping her today

Also not at all sold that Dave is town, fwiw but he wasn’t my top pick today anyway

I think if he claims a guilty in lylo it’s super sus, so we need to try to hit scum today to force him into not having that option

Also, Dave, why did you out exactly?

I’m still really okay with just going through all of (Dave, lilith, Best Bird, peta)

In post 3145, Menalque wrote:Also, Dave, why did you out exactly?

Because it looks like a massclaim is in progress and people who claim stall tend to get elim'd.
Any other stupid questions?

VOTE: Menalque
Keep mentioning me?

Let's just turbo elim the guilty and get it over with.