"btw if andante flips scum -> everyone she has pushed is pretty much conftown.
she is an avid antibusser till the very end unless she absolutely needs to.
like stubbornly so."
From Koba about Andante
and Koba has a shitload of experience with Andante
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 8:24 am
by Dwlee99
Yes and that is part of why I scumread Andante, she didn't push any of the flipped scum lol
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 8:25 am
by Dwlee99
Like I had that exact Koba quote in mind thinking of her being scum
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 8:25 am
by Stephen A Smith
In post 3120, Dwlee99 wrote:Like proposition: at least one of Hockey and I is town that vehemently believe the other is town as well. Now is it more likely one of us is completely snowing the other or that we are both town?
also if you're scum you kind of have to defend hockey from me because you know if i kill hockey!town i come for you tomm and its awkward for you tomm
as long as you keep hockey alive i can't really tunnel you directly
also hockey is kind of convinced of you being town so why wouldnt you keep him alive if you're scum?
if anything its mad weird you are this convinced hockey is town because i dont see anything very clearing in hockey's iso.
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 8:26 am
by Stephen A Smith
In post 3127, Dwlee99 wrote:Yes and that is part of why I scumread Andante, she didn't push any of the flipped scum lol
she voted for them didnt she
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 8:26 am
by Stephen A Smith
In post 3128, Dwlee99 wrote:Like I had that exact Koba quote in mind thinking of her being scum
In post 3120, Dwlee99 wrote:Like proposition: at least one of Hockey and I is town that vehemently believe the other is town as well. Now is it more likely one of us is completely snowing the other or that we are both town?
also if you're scum you kind of have to defend hockey from me because you know if i kill hockey!town i come for you tomm and its awkward for you tomm
as long as you keep hockey alive i can't really tunnel you directly
also hockey is kind of convinced of you being town so why wouldnt you keep him alive if you're scum?
if anything its mad weird you are this convinced hockey is town because i dont see anything very clearing in hockey's iso.
If I were scum you'd probably be dead last night. But regardless, the angle I'm taking re: hockey could make sense from a scum perspective of wanting someone who townreads me alive/preventing limming in the PRs but it also makes sense from my perspective right now where I don't think 1-shot backup gunsmith makes any sense as a scum role.
I didn't click on your link tbh. Koba has said it multiple times though yea and even DM'd me once on discord like "btw if you ever play against andante <thing about bussing>"
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 9:35 am
by Stephen A Smith
In post 3133, Dwlee99 wrote:I don't think 1-shot backup gunsmith makes any sense as a scum role
ok if he's an investigated inno why is he still alive today over a claimed VT?
But the no bussing meta is that Andante won't really push her buddies. Her being on Nero and then hopping off the moment it might go through doesn't break that for me, neither does her being nero/scorpious and then when I actually try to push scorpious to completion randomly going to Eyes.
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 9:39 am
by Stephen A Smith
make your best town case for yourself and ill evaluate it in good faith i promise
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 9:40 am
by Dwlee99
I'm scared that if we vote hockey and he flips town we're gonna lose either by you being alive and voting me or by you being night killed and then final scum being like "well look, stephen scumread Dwlee and is dead!" and I'll lose my bajillionth ELO 1v1 as town.
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 9:44 am
by Dwlee99
In post 3141, Stephen A Smith wrote:make your best town case for yourself and ill evaluate it in good faith i promise
okay tonight.
Some bulletpoints before I make like an actual big town case:
1.) Backup vig w/ assumption of vig very early in the game showcased throughout my ISO. Would have to be a planned fake very early.
2.) After Nero claimed even-night gunsmith I moved off eyes to push scorpious cause I thought his reaction to Nero's claim was shit
3.) Part of the reason even-night gunsmith made conceptual sense to me is I suspected even-night vig could exist which would kinda line up with my role and no n1 double kill
4.) Idk why I would kill the worst here besides to say "why would I kill the worst"
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 9:53 am
by Stephen A Smith
In post 3143, Dwlee99 wrote:1.) Backup vig w/ assumption of vig very early in the game showcased throughout my ISO. Would have to be a planned fake very early.
I respect your scum game enough for this to not really be a point in your favor lol
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 10:30 am
by HockeyFan
In post 3101, Umlaut wrote:Haven't had a lot to say, Andante case isn't terrible but I think Hockey's latching on to it is worse than whatever Andante is accused of here in the first place.
Why?
Also, stephen do u any reason to sus me thats not "There cant be 5 PRS in the game". you're just ignoring andante/umualt really cuz of "daitsi is an artist" like lol wtf.
Also theres a case for scum to leave the 3 prs alive
Leaving Dwlee Alive- B4 d5 and a bit of d4(thier reads were wrong(even said by them), and they werent saying anything really other than eyes!scum). Also TW was more TRD then them
Leaving Stephen alive- You were fixated on there NOT being 5prs in the game, so once again, mafia likely kept u alive for havign wrong assumption
Leaving Me Alive- Allows a path for town!you(stephen) to push on me, and give mafia basically a free lim
In post 3143, Dwlee99 wrote:1.) Backup vig w/ assumption of vig very early in the game showcased throughout my ISO. Would have to be a planned fake very early.
I respect your scum game enough for this to not really be a point in your favor lol
Okay but what about the other stuff
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 11:42 am
by Stephen A Smith
I'm still thinking about the other stuff
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 11:43 am
by Dwlee99
There's also like. If I was scum what was stopping me from just limming hockey, killing you, and then being like wow silly stephen xP cause literally only you think I'm scum here
Posted: Wed Mar 09, 2022 11:50 am
by Stephen A Smith
1) you want revenge for that time I dunked on you as scum
2) wifom you think not killing me will make me change my mind
3) you are worried that killing me could make people listen to me
4) you don't want to shrink the PR pool since you're scum and in the PR pool
5) you enjoy watching me suffer(see reason 1)