It's a role I thought I would get, it's a good counter to informed and good at detecting fakeclaims in general, it can clear me from having done the nightkill, it's a reasonably useful role to deny from scum, UB is fairly likely to miss or at least not do anything for several nights, and the popularity of UB means that if the first role to die is something like jailkeeper or doctor then having that slot can serve as a deterrent because scum will expect a UB.
Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2020 10:48 am
by petapan
well, anyway: i fibbed a little bit with my claim. i went for 1-shot watcher. didn't want to out that right away just in case of potential shenanigans although it probably wouldn't matter much. so now dave can't be the redirector unless either 1. i'm scum fakeclaming to back him up or 2. he's roleswapping with a teammate in the group of unknowns. both of these would be dumb and suboptimal, but regardless, we don't flip dave today because there's still scum in the group of 4.
so lilith is virtual locktown and the people trying to get us to vote her today don't look good
do you think mafia fucking nokilled on night 2, knowing there wasn't a doctor, just for the sake of bolstering a fakeclaim when that gives town an extra elimination? no way in hell.
(i mean, unless someone got cute and didn't claim doc)
Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2020 10:55 am
by Infinity 324
Right. So is mena just scum here? Fmpov a n1 kill on mena seems really weird.
Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2020 11:01 am
by petapan
unless it was...you??????????????????
but for real, possibly. maybe even probably.
Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2020 11:04 am
by petapan
i wanted to give credit for retracting his gambit but that goes away when he didn't remember there's confirmed to be someone who took the cop role slot
Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2020 11:10 am
by Infinity 324
I was 90% sure a doc save was what happened and now I'm just confused. Mena being scum here makes almost no sense on play, but so did lilith being town.
We definitely leave dave alive, he's likely to get NKed here. n_m is very likely town cause neighborizer.
Then the pool is {peta, bird, mena, s_s, hoopla} and hoopla I have a soulread on. Hmm.
I kinda wanna elim bird on PoE but that feels lazy.
@Mena: what role did you go for?
Posted: Fri Nov 20, 2020 11:13 am
by Best Bird
In post 3167, petapan wrote:do you think mafia fucking nokilled on night 2, knowing there wasn't a doctor, just for the sake of bolstering a fakeclaim when that gives town an extra elimination? no way in hell.
(i mean, unless someone got cute and didn't claim doc)
*night 1
**one save doesn't give town an extra elim