Posted: Thu Jan 30, 2014 7:13 am
top~
that was exactly my readIn post 3199, Sakura Hana wrote:Gaiden flipped encryptor right? I need to read more into those 2 day 1 wagons and Cabd's interactions with them, because 1 thing i know is that Cabd considers day chat OP and he probably would have protected Gaiden if it came to it.
Idk, i haven't read anything past page 20 in general, and i've only read Lush's ISO, so since that was your read, care to bring anything idk or haven't checked then?
I don't get the question, is this at everyone? care to explain it?In post 3204, ActionDan wrote:It'd be nice to pseudo claim whether lush was motivated N1.
Why can't both be Town? Is this anything that i'll prob. find out when I finally get to read all the pages?In post 3209, Mac wrote:Dan scum = muffin town, in my opinion.
So I guess Kagami's gonna come after me then.In post 3181, Kagami wrote:He can only be town, in my mind, if you are scum.
Because I feel both are counters to the ninja - thus I think dan's possibly fakeclaiming. I still don't think a ninja kill would show up under his investigate.In post 3210, Sakura Hana wrote:Why can't both be Town? Is this anything that i'll prob. find out when I finally get to read all the pages?In post 3209, Mac wrote:Dan scum = muffin town, in my opinion.
There's a very solid chance that Lush didn't get a guilty, and I find your push like they did so absolutely retarded. If Lush, as a odd night cop, got a double guilty on Muffin and ActionDan, they would claim it. If Lush got a single guilty on Muffin, there's a zero percent chance she would keep it in her pants instead of crowing to the entire world how Muffin was scum and she called it years before; she would not allow a third person to be lynched that wasn't her guilty.In post 3067, GoodCop_BadCop wrote:And here I started to like you D2... guess it wasn't you after all?In post 3048, Jaqen Hghar wrote: A man thinks a man prior was correct after all. GoodCopBadCop is definitely a BAD Cop and must needs have his neck stretched.
Muffin, I was taking it easy since Cabd told me that we had a cop guilty entering D3... doesn't look to be that simple tho. What does concern me is you hunting the Varsoon wagon and notyour own quick wagon. If you really are town, it should be pretty freaking obvious from the speed and reasoning behind your wagon that scum would be salivating to hop on.
I also don't like how you are writing off Varsoon as very very likely town because his D1 play points to him being town when I absolutely disagree, and echo Jaqen's sentiments re: Varsoon from D2.
I will let Cabd respond to your questions, since you specifically addressed him, but would like your thoughts on my comments.
Nacho, I realize that there is a possibility that Lush may have not gotten a guilty, but why are you talking like its the end of the world with "Why the fuck do towns have a tendency to start throwing shit away because "oooh, we're in the lead"?" That is absolutely NOT what is happening here. Are you trying to say there is a zero percent chance that Lush got a guilty? Cause that's pretty dumb and you are NOT a mafia god.
If there is a chance that Lush had a guilty and was trying to convey that in the form of a lynch push then we should be pursuing that avenue for lynch candidate today. You are also clearing Muffin solely on claim alone? I expect you to actually contribute and not be freaking dead-weight as town.
~GC
You're completely correct; I have no idea what drugs Mac is ingesting.In post 3217, Sakura Hana wrote:Idk, i thought i read kill cop not kill tracker, so i thought it worked like a gunsmith, can anyone correct me on this?
I think the confidence of Muffin as an investigative target is :/In post 3081, Kagami wrote:I don't think Lush crumbed a target nor do I think it would make sense to decide and stick with a target given the Gaiden flip. Lush made it abundantly clear that the investigation target was muffin, the only argument for muffin's innocence is the possibility that muffin was framed in some way or another, or lush was redirected to a scum.
There's no way muffin was framed in favor of someone on Varsoon's wagon, to my mind, so we'd have to believe lush was redirected. I don't think this happened because I see no reason to think Lush was scum, and Varsoon has already claimed a redirection role.
Mollie doesn't crumb results.In post 3140, Kagami wrote:Ehhhh... I really don't think there's any reasonable argument that lush didn't investigate you, muffin. He clearly did not crumb an innocent, and came out guns blazing anti-muffin despite only having a weak rationalization for his suspicion.
It's not crazy that he jumped off the wagon to lynch the CoK either, though it does indicate that he didn't investigate Dan. He saw that he wasn't getting support for muffin and was fine with lynching an alternative guilty, knowing that his potential flip should result in a muffin lynch anyway, and maybe getting a second investigation with luck.
The pro-muffin argument relies on the investigation being tampered with, not Lush sucking at cop-crumbing.
That makes alot more sense than it does in my head.In post 3217, Sakura Hana wrote:Idk, i thought i read kill cop not kill tracker, so i thought it worked like a gunsmith, can anyone correct me on this?
You'd be wrong.In post 3198, Kagami wrote:I think we need the rest of the claims.
My current theory is that the motivator is even-night.