You could be Anyone IV - GAME OVER

[TheWayItEnds]

thats only the correct scenario if alch is a death godfather TSO

[Elyse]

Sorry just being paranoid Shiro it seemed like a longer time

[T S O]

thats only the correct scenario if alch is a death godfather TSO

If you assume that Spider Gwen hid behind Alch, then yes. On the other hand, if you assume she didn't, then things seem to become a lot more straightforward.

[Shiro]

Sorry just being paranoid Shiro it seemed like a longer time

I understand. Paranoia can kill oyu as teh game progresses

[T S O]

I mean, we now know that the only scenarios that explains Gwen's death if you're taking Alchemist as the target are a) no action taken and b) a Mafia role that nullifies Hiders, and that scum also decided to shoot her the same night.

Alternatively, Gwen hides behind someone else. That person is scum. Scum shoot Gwen because she claimed a PR in the thread. Gwen dies.

[T S O]

And should read or in that first sentence, but you get the gist quite clearly.

[T S O]

So, we now know, almost for certain, that one of EE and random is scum. Does that seem familiar to me?

[T S O]

EE scumflip likely clears Aneninen, for one person.

[Aneninen]

I just want to say, I don't support a Eagle waggon.
I truly think he is town.

Having thought about it and he's a Miss Marple townread. I think. He's so similar to someone that I can see some possibility that he's an alt. ^_^

I also oppose the eagle lynch.

Whut? You? Why?

Can people explain townreads on Eagle? I've been going back and forth with him.
At this point, I've put PS, TSO, Aneninen, Garmr, Varsoon, and TWIE in my townpile.

See above.
Varsoon and TWIE are question marks.
TSO is an auto-paranoia, but because most of you thinks he's town I must clearly have missed something important. The last bit is an "Aneninen is being Aneninen" tell.

Jason, you left out the player who's voting for me in your 3177

Well, we both agree Aneninen is scum. Why do you think he's town?

Where did that read come from?

Let's just say it - he seems like the vig. That's it. There's no point hiding it because literally -everyone- is thinking the same.

...because?
Were he a Vig, he would have Nightkilled Elyse at Night1.

Shiro's absence is making me question him as well

I haven't parrotted anything for a while.

Shiro's absence is making me question him as well

Excuse me absence ? I didn't post for one page and you call that absence ? Seesh

Beetlejuice.

Alternatively, Gwen hides behind someone else. That person is scum. Scum shoot Gwen because she claimed a PR in the thread. Gwen dies.

Okay, I have a little something for you.
As I have time, I'll check her posts. I'm not only a proven liar but also a proven weirdo. I might find something there to reveal where she hid.

EE scumflip likely clears Aneninen, for one person.

?

________

Also, I'm aware of the fact that I haven't lied anything Today. Please, give me ideas! You know, if I told the truth after all this time, noone would ever believe me.

[T S O]

Come on now, Anen, I'd expect you to see why your Vig objection doesn't make sense.

[jasonT1981]

Jason, you left out the player who's voting for me in your 3177

.

I'll go back and look for it when I get on properly again. Do you know what post it was?

[TheWayItEnds]

thats only the correct scenario if alch is a death godfather TSO

If you assume that Spider Gwen hid behind Alch, then yes. On the other hand, if you assume she didn't, then things seem to become a lot more straightforward.

Did this post stop existing?

@Stormy: A reread of Alch wouldn't hurt. I know I haven't gotten much from his play. You might be able to see things I can't.

It doesnt seem like it...

[TheWayItEnds]

So, we now know, almost for certain, that one of EE and random is scum. Does that seem familiar to me?

there is literally nothing in SG's iso that remotely indicates either of these hides.

[Errantparabola]

Whut? You? Why?

Why does that surprise you?
I find it interesting that it surprises you.

[Errantparabola]

Since a MOHIS lynch unfortunately seems to not be happening, I would be fine with VOTE: random

[Randomnamechange]

Since a MOHIS lynch unfortunately seems to not be happening, I would be fine with VOTE: random

Explain?

[Shiro]

Guys what are the chances that Gwen hid behind scum Titus who was protected by scum doctor thus keeping Gwen alive?

I recently had this thought in my head and I cant get it off so please tell me how stupid and unlikely it is.

[I Am Innocent]

My other game just ended, so expect my full attention now I'll get moving on that day 1 vote analysis now.

[I Am Innocent]

Guys what are the chances that Gwen hid behind scum Titus who was protected by scum doctor thus keeping Gwen alive?

I recently had this thought in my head and I cant get it off so please tell me how stupid and unlikely it is.

Hiding behind scum would have killed SG regardless whether that scum lived or not.

[Shiro]

Oh cool cool then. I thought if a doc was present both would live.

[ZZZX]

Here. will read in a while today. gona game a bit first

[My Other Head Is Scum]

Since a MOHIS lynch unfortunately seems to not be happening, I would be fine with VOTE: random

Sorry Errant, I want to get lynched to ;(

[My Other Head Is Scum]

there is literally nothing in SG's iso that remotely indicates either of these hides.

Not all players crumb their actions though.
Like I don't. Ever.

[My Other Head Is Scum]

So, we now know, almost for certain, that one of EE and random is scum. Does that seem familiar to me?

EE scumflip likely clears Aneninen, for one person.

So which one is a better lynch?

[TheWayItEnds]

there is literally nothing in SG's iso that remotely indicates either of these hides.

Not all players crumb their actions though.
Like I don't. Ever.

hider is literally completely useless if you dont crumb your hide.