Mafiascum.net

VC 4.FINAL

votes

[4] OkaPoka

:

Moongrass 3045, Varsoon 3046, mbaki 3067, Creature 3210

[1] mbaki

:

DrDolittle 2273

[1] DrDolittle

:

OkaPoka 3195

[1] Not Voting

:

Kmd4390 3083

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch

The Day 4 deadline is in

: (expired on 2019-01-20 04:15:59)

Mod Notes

:

I am a lot less sure its DDL over Kmd, after that EoD + Moongrass posting + Kmd has bad Oka associations (randomly townreading him in his iso, never showing an effort to sort).

Creature, Varsoon, are you still considering me as likely scum? Each other (please say no, you're both town)? This affects how I will play today.

Tbh same fam

Action was not successful.
Since there's only one scum left, this makes Creature town.

I need to ISO Oka.

In post 3016, DrDolittle wrote:oka mbaki doesnt make sense.

I don't like that Kmd and DDL both defended Oka, early game and here. I agree with this part though lmao.

I am leaning towards voting Kmd.

From each of your perspectives, the 'solve' should be the two other guys.
We need ya'll three to come on a consensus.

Obviously, one of you won't agree.

If I was scum with oka why wouldn't I have hammered you when creature voted and I was ready to vote you anyway

Weren't around? I dunno.
I don't think it's you, though.
I think the solve is probably Mbaki/DDL.

In post 3238, Kmd4390 wrote:If I was scum with oka why wouldn't I have hammered you when creature voted and I was ready to vote you anyway

to make it believable? after Moon had just shaded you and Oka as a possible team, you lol hammering would not have flied.

In post 3239, Varsoon wrote:Weren't around? I dunno.
I don't think it's you, though.
I think the solve is probably Mbaki/DDL.

I had every opportunity to help you lynch Creature or to help Oka lynch you, both were pushing me too. Just saying.

If that's the solve, we can do DDL, but Kmd has much worse play here than I'm used to from him.

I think that Oka went hard on me and DDL went strong passive.
I wonder if I called the scumteam of Oka DDL on D1
But then why wasn't I shot?
Wonk.

Because Moongrass was global town, by far, and people were still suspecting you. This includes a hypothetical town Kmd and a Creature, both of whom would still be alive. You had also voted me yesterday more than you voted DDL.

Not saying DDL is scum over Kmd, but for the second time this game, you not being killed is not a reason to doubt your reads.

No, no, I mean over rb and over Dunnflor

I am not sure about the latter, exactly. rb was a given kill, especially pushing both scum if DDL is scum in this hypothetical. Dann did have both Kmd and DDL in his scum pool too, maybe they just thought he was more threatening because you hadn't done anything up to that point.

That brings up this: if I'm scum with Dann, why do I kill him when he doesn't scum read Oka, and has me as his strongest town read, and is an available mislynch? The "perfect storm," so to speak. There isn't even a hypothetical reason I can think of.

In post 2083, DrDolittle wrote:oka's scum because how much he's scared of bef being killed yesterday since he didn't want a neop shot

I should have stronger conviction in this hard evidence.

So which one of kmd/mbaki was more anti letting fish live?

That is completely irrelevant, it is not hard evidence. It was very clear his claim was fake.

In post 2022, Dannflor wrote:DDL you are a very mixed read to me with some of your slot reading very scummy and some of your slot reading very town, so I don't really know where to sort you. I would lean more town than scum just based on gut though. At a surface level, yours and Varsoon's posts do look similar.

In post 2038, Dannflor wrote:I didn't imply I thought it was DDL, just that his logic is off.

BTW to correct you mbaki dann thought i was town: see his last couple of posts

In post 3247, mbaki wrote:That is completely irrelevant, it is not hard evidence. It was very clear his claim was fake.

only sith deals in absolutes.