My approach has successfully been used by town in at least one past iteration of the setup.
Literally all that poking me on this issue requires me to do is make my identity more obvious than it already is and doesn't change the actual approach to the game.
If you need to go after me because you're scum and I'm not planning to take you to endgame, go after me on something besides the mechanics of it because you know that the correctness of the mechanics tbhat I've put forth can't actually be argued with.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 3:10 pm
by Gentleman 5
If the scumteam is G4/G5/G6 can we get a scummy nom plz
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 3:12 pm
by Gentleman 3
Is there a scummie for "most toxicity caused in order to win a game"?
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 3:12 pm
by Gentleman 6
In post 3233, Gentleman 3 wrote:Is there a scummie for "most toxicity caused in order to win a game"?
I don't think that I've been toxic this game.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 3:14 pm
by Gentleman 3
You haven't been too bad but if the G5/G6 interactions were theater that'd be pretty dirty.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 3:14 pm
by Gentleman 4
Gentleman 6, would you be willing to provide verbal input on who you think is and is not scum, based on process?
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 3:15 pm
by Gentleman 4
I'm really not interested in your lists of what does and does not contain scum, they contradict each other. If you want to discuss my process, that's fine, I've provided a sample of it, or if you'd share some of your own that would also be productive.
In post 3214, Gentleman 4 wrote:Alright here's the couples I'm considering for today in no particular order:
Lady 5 and Gentleman 8:
Spoiler: I've already covered this, and I think it's a dead horse now, but here's my argument in case you missed it:
In post 3107, Gentleman 4 wrote:I still support a Lady 5 and Gentleman 8 lynch, because it will help me sort Lady 2 and Gentleman 3, it will remove a lot of the spam from the thread, I doubt they will make it much later anyways, neither of them will surprise me with a scum flip, and I think we can get enough agreement on it to get two lynches before intermission.
One point I specifically want to bring up about this pairing is this: a lot of people are having difficulty with too many town reads - Lady 4's reads list included not enough scum and Gentleman 6 recently expressed doubt in several of his scum reads, and this is often indicative of scum being in the lurker pile -> Gentleman 8.
Gentleman 5 and Lady 4: The case against Gentleman 5 is debatable. I've liked what he brought to the table in the past, but Gentleman 1 made a solid point about his Lady 2 "joke." I'm really not certain about this pair, I'd really rather have more time to sort through this, because I've been very much on the fence about both these player's alignments. I think based on Gentleman 5's "joke," flipping this pair might be indicative of Lady 2 scum.
Gentleman 3 and Lady 6: Lady 6 has said very convenient things at convenient times before, and several of her more interesting posts have been noted several times by other players. I will go through these when I get the chance, but I think she's slid significantly under the radar due to her absence. There have been a couple things she's done that have barely any game relevancy but can be indicative of her being town on her main account, though, so this is something to keep in consideration. I have never been a fan of Gentleman 3's posting, it all looks particularly fake and his activity has dropped conveniently after finding a partner - right around the same time everyone else was looking at Gentleman 5 and Lady 4.
Gentleman 1 and Lady 2: Not really a pairing I was considering at the beginning of the day, I like Gentleman 1 for the most part, but Lady 2's flip could help determine the alignment of several other players here and I've been less and less convinced by her posting recently.
This specifically is what interests me. Feedback on this.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 3:16 pm
by Gentleman 4
From anyone, to be honest. I'm not really interested in considering any other lynches at the moment.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 3:17 pm
by Gentleman 6
G1/L2 is who I want to lynch right now because I think Star Wolf is scum.
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 3:18 pm
by Gentleman 5
Remind me of this joke?
Posted: Mon Nov 11, 2019 3:19 pm
by Gentleman 4
Can you talk quote specifically what posts Gentleman 1 made that made you uncomfortable? Or give me the page numbers at least? I want to be able to interpret for myself.