Open 488: Pick Your Poison [GAME OVER]

[Scott Brosius]

Okay, easy guys. This isn't a personal game, so let's leave personal matters out of it. Scott, that was a pretty terrible misrep.

Hardly, weak wishy-washy opinions that are contradictory as Pim pointed out, and that testing the water question reeks of scum.

There was nothing weak nor wishy washy there. It was a statement completely unrelated to the game.

Anyway, should we think about an AP lynch? Has he really done anything scummy?

There is only probing here to see if a wagon is viable. This offers I guess an opinion kinda defending AP, although earlier posts suggest that he thinks he is scummy. Why would someone be probing opinions about potential wagons, without offering a clear opinion themselves? Well if they are not town, it makes plenty of sense.

Ohey. Um. Yeah, the vote was kinda dumb. And I'm stuck now - I didn't have a good reason for it, and if I make up a reason you'll realize it was just made up after the fact, and if I unvote that can also get painted as scummy. Um, as to why I did it, it was some sort of weird gut thingy. Some of your stuff looked slightly odd and I just figured what the hell.

Yeah I have no idea what to do with this. Vigbait me thinks.

[FuDuzn]

Wouldn't that make you think Dirt Trip is town then Scott?

And Keyblade's flip flop with out even knowing it and then denying it even happened 'might' be the scummiest thing that as happened all game. Given GNR's entrance into the game I still feel good about his lynch, but I hink I could go for Keyblade as well.

[kcudz]

It's just beyond me that no one else is thinking about voting Fuzzy. The vast majority of his posts are void of substance, and half the drivel that escapes his mouth is wired with incomprehensible logic that's worthy to be considered a direct conversation derail. Although that's more vig-worthy than scum, I guess.

I like FuDuzn's slot more than I like GNR's right now, so:

Unvote, vote: GNR

[Bacde]

It's just beyond me that no one else is thinking about voting Fuzzy. The vast majority of his posts are void of substance, and half the drivel that escapes his mouth is wired with incomprehensible logic that's worthy to be considered a direct conversation derail. Although that's more vig-worthy than scum, I guess.

I like FuDuzn's slot more than I like GNR's right now, so:

Unvote, vote: GNR

I would be thinking about voting fuzzy if you had even tried to make an effort to get me to do so

but you didn't

all of your posts have been "blah blah blah im so cool i dont want to respond to other people's questions without sarcasm or snark or attitude or without forcing them to look at my previous posts"

seriously, why not just answer people's questions instead of referring them to posts you've made before? Its not that hard to just repeat yourself

If you wanna be upset that im not thinking about voting fuzzy, tell me why i should be thinking about voting fuzzy

[Bacde]

bc im open to voting fuzzy and I'll listen to whatever you have to say, and I'll push that wagon really hard if I believe you

[kcudz]

I don't believe there has been a single instance of sarcasm in my posts yet.
Repeating myself is tiresome. If your answers can be found in my previous posts, that's where you need to be looking for them. I'm not here to spoon-feed you guys because you're lazy.
Upon harder thought, I've decided that GNR has the higher chance of flipping scum between him and fuzzy. If there is a vig - more power to us. But I am 110% certain that Fuzzy will be dead before LyLo.
Rest assured though, if I feel like pushing Fuzzy as a lynch is more optimal today, I'll be doing exactly what you told me to do.

[fuzzybutternut]

I don't believe there has been a single instance of sarcasm in my posts yet.
Repeating myself is tiresome. If your answers can be found in my previous posts, that's where you need to be looking for them. I'm not here to spoon-feed you guys because you're lazy.
Upon harder thought, I've decided that GNR has the higher chance of flipping scum between him and fuzzy. If there is a vig - more power to us. But I am 110% certain that Fuzzy will be dead before LyLo.
Rest assured though, if I feel like pushing Fuzzy as a lynch is more optimal today, I'll be doing exactly what you told me to do.

Really? It's not possible to be that sure unless you are scum or a vig. I imagine if you were a vig you would have shot me already, so you must be scum.

[kcudz]

1) It is Day 1. What you said reads also as a painfully obviously feigned attempt to town tell.
2) Subliminal rolefishing attempts are adorable.
3) On the off chance you are town, scum will not kill you. Why? Because you present zero threat to scum. However, this is probably (thankfully) not the case. You are vig-shot worthy. I would not deem it horrible for a vig to shoot you. If you don't die from that, I will be pushing your lynch incredibly hard unless other matters desire my attention more.

[fuzzybutternut]

Spoiler:

1.) Feigning town attempts? No. There is NO WAY POSSIBLE for someone to know who is going to live through lylo unless you're either A.) Lining up lynches. B.)A vig or some other killing role, or C.)Scum. Coincidentally, A and C coincide quite well.
2.) That's not role fishing, straw man. That's listing possibilities and blatantly stating that i'm sure you aren't a vig.
3.) The fact that you don't think i'm a threat to scum is humorous.

EVERY

member of town is, in some way, a threat to scum.
4.) Strike the first line. You're lining up lynches.

[kcudz]

1) Yes, your statement that I haven't shot you yet implies that you didn't know there was no night yet. This is what I'm calling a feigned attempt to town tell.
2) That's why I called it subliminal. Because, if I am not scum, you are saying that I'm a vig.
3) The fact that you are resorting to the inherent set-up of the game and its mechanics as a testament as to how you're not useless is laughable.
4) Yes, your lynch is something that I see happening and is something that I will almost certainly make happen. What of it?

[fuzzybutternut]

Uh, no, actually. I very plainly said "you aren't the vig." Tell me how I'm useless, Kuddy. Please tell me how someone with much more experience at this, having played with multiple members of this game, is going to be useless. You're going to make my lynch happen? I find it funny that you think you, a single person, can see to it that I am lynched. Go ahead. Make a case against me. Please. Are you aware that there is a day vig? Obviously not. Misrep noted.

[kcudz]

unless you are scum or a vig

This implies that you think I'm either scum or a vig. Which means, if I am not scum, you think I am the vig.

Tell me how I'm useless, Kuddy.

You have provided close to zero content and have no scum reads other than one you formed on me with the aid of scrappy logic and maybe even confirmation bias.

Please tell me how someone with much more experience at this, having played with multiple members of this game, is going to be useless.

Experience is not an important determining factor at usefulness. Neither is your experience with the other multiple members; because if that was relevant, you would have shared the information already. You have not. Expressing self-importance in the later game is not a reason for you to be alive.

Make a case against me. Please.

I don't find it necessary as of now, or even later to make a case on you unless someone requests it. Your requests for me to make a case on you will be ignored.

Are you aware that there is a day vig? Obviously not. Misrep noted.

Another poorly thought out, contrived attempt to town tell. There is no day vig in Pick Your Poison. By the way, if you were wondering, I would have shot you to shit long ago if I were a day vig.

[fuzzybutternut]

kk. Kcudz is scum. Vote him and reap the benefits.

[kcudz]

You tried the same thing 248 posts ago, and look where we are now.

You're going to have to do better than that.

[fuzzybutternut]

Nope. I won't. I have everything i need now.

[kcudz]

...Which is what exactly?

[fuzzybutternut]

I don't find it necessary as of now, or even later to make a case on you unless someone requests it. Your requests for me to make a case on you will be ignored.

[kcudz]

So you're unwilling to explain your top scum read for everyone to see (and at the same time have me as a counterwagon)?

Tell me more.

[fuzzybutternut]

Do you find it scummy that I won't tell you?

[kcudz]

Yes. And it doesn't apply to me because you're not my top scum read at the moment.

[kcudz]

You're also not a competing wagon.

[fuzzybutternut]

That doesn't excuse from anything, just so you know.

[kcudz]

Come back and argue once you've formulated your thoughts.

[uctriton00]

I have AngryPidgeon and Antagon as scum reads

AngryPidgeon with ridiculous reasoning, and Antagon grasping at straws by saying my original post was complete scum. It's even sweeter when Antagon calls AP a town read. My gut says AP doesn't want me in the game due to pure meta and he sees me as a threat to him.

Kudzu is being a troll who probably remade his account because his precious account was bad, and baboon or whoever that star avatar is a town read from what I read. I think I have a town read on a soda can.

I need to read in detail when not on iPad, but my scum reads are right.

[uctriton00]

And whoever gave that vig list is bad too. It's as if they are someone who is a scum and needs some people taken care of on their behalf.