- I said "This is more like trying to look town". Which is me saying he's more likely trying to look like town as opposed to what you were suggesting. That's not certainty.
Why wouldn't you agree as town? Even if the person saying "let's not lynch you" is scum. Town not getting lynched is a good thing no?
---
@Desperado
- I asked Krab about him defending ferret, he either didn't see the question or he's ignoring it. Also, his weird reaction to Sven's question is suspicious.
However Ferret just seems more scummy. His vote on Raven seems incredibly forced and his reason weak. Voting/unvoting is mostly anti-town, not vote worthy.
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 9:22 am
by Krab Bucket
Just to clarify GCBC, it wasn't really so much a defence of furret, I just thought the reasoning against furret was poor.
~Krabs
With 21 alive, it takes 11 to lynch. Day 1 ends in 10 days, at 7am BST on the 8th May 2013.
Svenskt Stål, I draw your attention to this rule:
In post 1, Nexus wrote:Blue is my colour. Please don't use it.
Consider this your one and only warning. There are plenty of other colours you can choose from.
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 9:33 am
by GoodCopBadCop
Wait what!?
There IS an ISO button!? I'll have rethink on Ferret.
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 9:34 am
by GoodCopBadCop
When the hell was this implemented?
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 9:45 am
by Desperado
It's always been there? They just added a hyperlink to everyone's posts, you could always scroll to the bottom and ISO there
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 9:47 am
by Jebus
If you look the bottom right under the page numbers, there's a link that says "Activity Overview". Click on that, and then it'll give you a list of players and postcounts. Click on the number of posts and it'll give you all of their posts in iso.
, you could always scroll to the bottom and ISO there
Didn't know the bolded.
I thought he was saying he accidentally ISO'd the old fashioned way...
- All posts by Good Cop.
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 9:54 am
by GoodCopBadCop
yeah, wondering why monkey isn't lynched yet
I might move over to ravenpaw though because why not
-BadCop
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 11:02 am
by RATEDR
TheEsquire wrote:RATEDR is starting to give me a null/weak scum read. No information or real content in any of their posts, no conjecture, no... anything :\
TheEsquire wrote:RATEDR is starting to give me a null/weak scum read. No information or real content in any of their posts, no conjecture, no... anything :\
You've obviously never played with me before
Pretty obvious considering this is my first game on the site, yeah.
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 11:22 am
by RATEDR
TheEsquire wrote: A lot of hostility coming from RATEDR too which is never helpful.
What the fuck, I'm pretty chill man
Anyway Im liking Sven's recent posting and I'm thinking he's town
Most of the hydras in this game kind of look good for the most part except for maybe GoodCopBadCop but whatever
TheEsquire wrote:RATEDR is starting to give me a null/weak scum read. No information or real content in any of their posts, no conjecture, no... anything :\
You've obviously never played with me before
Pretty obvious considering this is my first game on the site, yeah.
O ok
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 11:27 am
by Nero Cain
I kinda like Des. Not only does he have a town read on me but he looks like he's actually hunting. Is there any specific posts that make you uneasy about that slot?
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 11:37 am
by RATEDR
In post 339, Nero Cain wrote:I kinda like Des. Not only does he have a town read on me but he looks like he's actually hunting. Is there any specific posts that make you uneasy about that slot?
I dont like #150. It's a HUGE overreaction to what I originally said and that kind of set off my radar
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 11:37 am
by Nero Cain
GCBC is iffy as his push on monkey was dumb but he makes a good point about Ferretlover. I'd also expect Nacho to be more active. AA is kinda a possibility 'cause (I think) scum tend to complain about heads posting out of hydras and I don't really know if their pointing out of Vifam posted out of hydra was helpful town or scum trying to look helpful. Still think ESQ posting IIOA then becoming super active and giving what looks like *slightly* conflicting reasoning for his IIOA makes him off limits for day 1.
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 11:37 am
by Nero Cain
GCBC is iffy as his push on monkey was dumb but he makes a good point about Ferretlover. I'd also expect Nacho to be more active. AA is kinda a possibility 'cause (I think) scum tend to complain about heads posting out of hydras and I don't really know if their pointing out of Vifam posted out of hydra was helpful town or scum trying to look helpful. Still think ESQ posting IIOA then becoming super active and giving what looks like *slightly* conflicting reasoning for his IIOA makes him off limits for day 1.
In post 339, Nero Cain wrote:I kinda like Des. Not only does he have a town read on me but he looks like he's actually hunting. Is there any specific posts that make you uneasy about that slot?
I dont like #150. It's a HUGE overreaction to what I originally said and that kind of set off my radar
My read on AA was essentially a meta read, I was observing her playstyle in past games and going off on my read on her based on that. So I'd LIKE to think I know what the fuck I'm talking about when I say that stuff. I dont like the fact that he seemed to imply it didn't matter when it was something as simple as a metaread
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 11:47 am
by RATEDR
In post 289, RATEDR wrote:Also, ancient posts, but I gotta quote them. From my own partner:
In post 142, RATEDR wrote:Arc is town since she's not playing akwardly
I don't know, even before I read these posts, my first thought of Arc's posts, especially his big stand-off with Monkey, come across as nothing short of "awkward". Is he really that much more awkward as scum?
In post 339, Nero Cain wrote:I kinda like Des. Not only does he have a town read on me but he looks like he's actually hunting. Is there any specific posts that make you uneasy about that slot?
I dont like #150. It's a HUGE overreaction to what I originally said and that kind of set off my radar
Are you referring to #151? #150 is a response to ferret.
Can you explain what specifically felt like a huge reaction? I had already mentioned my dislike for basing an Arc town read on her meta once before and provided an example of her being awkward as town, a direct counterpoint to the notion that not-awkward Arc = town Arc. Your response was to ask if I had seen scum Arc, which was so awkward it made you cringe, as if this somehow supports your argument. I think my followup response was perfectly appropriate.
In post 339, Nero Cain wrote:I kinda like Des. Not only does he have a town read on me but he looks like he's actually hunting. Is there any specific posts that make you uneasy about that slot?
I dont like #150. It's a HUGE overreaction to what I originally said and that kind of set off my radar
My read on AA was essentially a meta read, I was observing her playstyle in past games and going off on my read on her based on that. So I'd LIKE to think I know what the fuck I'm talking about when I say that stuff. I dont like the fact that he seemed to imply it didn't matter when it was something as simple as a metaread
I wasn't implying anything, I was out right stating that your meta read was insufficient. Your read was "I know Arc scum, and it is awkward as fuck. Arc is not playing awkwardly this game, therefore Arc is town." and when I presented evidence of awkward town Arc, you just repeated yourself.
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 12:20 pm
by RATEDR
I dont know what you mean, what I said was Arc is amazingly akward as scum
I dont like that you respond by going "whoa that's insufficient" when I'm obviously playing off from my own experience with her
At that point you cant really be attempting to prove that I'm wrong, you just have to go with it. And if you didn't believe me at that point you could have just asked for evidence, I dont know if you did that but if you did I probably missed it. I just dont see why it couldn't have simply be left at that.
Which is why I was like whatever when you went off
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 12:27 pm
by Nero Cain
If Arc is scum she'll active lurk like crazy. You both need to stop it.
I want comments on ESQ. NOA!!!
Posted: Tue Apr 30, 2013 12:31 pm
by Desperado
In post 347, RATEDR wrote:I dont know what you mean, what I said was Arc is amazingly akward as scum
I dont like that you respond by going "whoa that's insufficient" when I'm obviously playing off from my own experience with her
At that point you cant really be attempting to prove that I'm wrong, you just have to go with it. And if you didn't believe me at that point you could have just asked for evidence, I dont know if you did that but if you did I probably missed it. I just dont see why it couldn't have simply be left at that.
Which is why I was like whatever when you went off
What I mean is I gave you an example of Arc acting awkward as town. Your town read was based on Arcscum being awkward, so if the validity of that meta read is questionable, the read is questionable. When I pointed this out you repeated yourself, like I didn't understand what you meant. And can you quote the post and tell me specifically where I "went off"?