Mafiascum.net

In post 323, Doc Holliday wrote:'Too dumb to be scum' is a legit strategy. Props, TIP.

Angel, every one of my criticisms stands in full force post-reveal. I may have been flat-out wrong about TIP, leading to my initial suspicion of you, but you did absolutely, positively squat that was pro-Town. You lurked, you OMGUSed, you pointed fingers without reason or coherent case, and all of that caused the seed of suspicion to explode into full certainty. I bear some responsibility for leading the charge against you, but your belligerence and refusal to be productive sealed the deal. Please act more calmly and rationally next time we're Town together.

In post 44, Candillan wrote:It's almost as if you're claiming Cult Leader.

Also, if we mislynch, that's pretty much an instant win for the Cult.
Also, I haven't seen much of a "meh" attitude with Who in this game so far. What are you talking about?
What are your reads on the other three of us?

In post 48, Candillan wrote:I already stated my reads.

Here:

In post 35, Candillan wrote:My gut says that TheIrishPope shouldn't be governor. a.k.a. I think you're scummy.
Who I'm less so worried about. a.k.a. Null, but I still feel something odd from that slot.
Holliday I'm feeling good about. a.k.a. He's townie.
ArcAngel I dunno. a.k.a. She's null.

In post 52, Candillan wrote:Okay so reasons why you're scummy.
1. You instantly recommended me to be the Governor, even though I hadn't posted anything. That seems like you're trying to get on my good side somewhat by pseudo-buddying me. That is scummy.
2. You elected yourself for Governor, but you put me as another potential candidate in order to make yourself seem okay with not getting the power. It honestly seems as if you're wholly interested in grabbing the power yourself, which is why you instantly voted yourself right afterward.
3. Your reads seem as if you don't want to tread on any toes. I don't personally count your reads as reads per se, because all it is is you calling all of us null, then voting the 'lurker'. ArcAngel hasn't necessarily been lurking. This game's been open for two days, and she confirmed yesterday. I wouldn't call that lurking.
4. In post #43, all you did was say that Who is null, say you should be Governor (but not //why// you should be Gov), then defend the idea of the Cult Leader getting Gov. Why would you say that if you were town? You don't want to give the Cult Leader the advantage in any way, shape, or form. In that respect, I feel as if you're trying to have us warm up to the idea of the CL getting the Gov. That I interpret as you saying "I'm Cult Leader and I want the power. It's not like it's gonna do much harm!"

Who I'm somewhat worrisome of for the same reason as #4. The conversation around post 31 gave me bad feelings, but he was saying it in more of an objective fashion than you. He also makes me feel ehh about him because he, too, seemed relatively eager for the power.

Doc reads town for me because instead of saying that he should be Gov, he started talking about who //shouldn't// be Gov. That gave me great vibes, and he's been calling people out on being scummy.

ArcAngel has had one post. Therefore, null.

Pedit:
Yeah, I'm pretty confident in Doc being town.

In post 63, Candillan wrote:@Doc, I agree that who has been slipping under the radar, but I feel as if we should give Arc the benefit of the doubt. I'm also not confident in your townread on Pope. Rolefishing is aghterrible, and his motivations don't seem town to me.

@Pope,

1. Fair enough.
2. I see the scum motivation behind it. It mostly lies in the words 'must' and 'necessary'. I don't see it as necessary; I see it as scummy.
3. Yes, it is beneficial to the town. If I didn't know what it does, I wouldn't have started campaigning for it. I would have at least looked it up.

I see more defense than scumhunting, though to be fair, the only posts I've seen have been focused on you.
Rolefishing is still terrible.

You said that his deferring of the power is him trying to keep the heat off him, but then you admit that he did attack you, which is inherently not keeping the heat off him?
Also, I agreed with his points. It wasn't out of the blue, he was calling you out on what was wrong with your post.
I'm not joking about anything I post. What about them makes it look like I'm joking?

So you have a nullread on Doc and a townread on me. Didn't you just say that you had no reads? What makes you suddenly read town on me? Weren't you just calling some of my actions scummy?

Fair enough on the last bit, but your eagerness is still troubling.



Is everyone okay with me being the Governor? If so, we can move into night zero. I personally want to wait until ArcAngel posts her thoughts before we do so.

In post 340, Doc Holliday wrote:Angel, your refusal to do anything productive made you the only choice.

I'm willing to accept responsibility for my part in the loss, but you didn't make any effort. You were wrong, offensive, and unproductive. I was just wrong.

Candillan, don't give me that crap. You thought I was wrong, but made practically no attempt to push any agenda of your own.