Mini 1624: Joss Whedon Mafia: The Musical (Game Over)

[ArcAngel9]

the point was..He didn't ask either. How did he justify that i was picking on lurkers. He should rather ask me first...
I said in my post that there is someone i need to push and I said "Enough lurkiing. come out rat". So how it looks i intentionally choosing a lurker to vote when i clearly stated my intention behind it. ?

[ArcAngel9]

And please ISO serra, Would you be the IC of this game and play like this. Ask yourself and AP too.

[Murder of Crows]

And please ISO serra, Would you be the IC of this game and play like this. Ask yourself and AP too.

He's doing a metric fuckton better than the last gamestart IC I played with.

Which doesn't surprise me.

If you're town, then you need to find a way to work with him.

[Murder of Crows]

Ffery, you get town feels from AA9? I actually thought her going after serra was unlikely to come from scum but I started scum reading her latest posts a little.

[Murder of Crows]

Yes I am. We need a qt or a skype convo. en-hydra discussions in the game thread will make greyice's head explode.

[Riddleton]

will make greyice's head explode.

Sounds like a plan. I'm excited to be part of it, let's go!

[istott]

After reading the last few pages, Ive noticed there is a huge amount of insults being thrown around. People insulting other people, not their play styles.
Also, I somewhat agree with the core message of GreyICE when he says that some people are posting too much. Im finding it hard to pick out important parts because of all of the off-topic discussion and the arguments. I haven't been posting as much as I'd like to (in my other newbie game, were about 10 days in, and Im second highest in activity [that game only has 360 posts in 5x as much time]) because:
A: I don't like being insulted, and I'm slightly feeling that if I put my views forward, people will insult me.
B: I don't want to clutter up the game even more.
I have also decided to only speak in flavour until further notice. I'll still post meaningful stuff, but for Joss Whedon Mafia, I'm gonna be in character.

[HypotheticalBassists]

@AA9

: Doesn't matter if serra's vote was a ragevote, since you're currently the one raging. Please don't. Other than the lurker, what are your current reads on the people who've actually posted? Thoughts on Anatole?

@istott

: While I appreciate you not wanting to clutter the thread, your last post was meaningless and all your posts have been about you. So yeah. Doesn't really do much.

@serra

: Not getting the AA9 votes, she reads town to me. Care to explain a bit more?

For those asking what the deal with

LMP's

'meter' is, it's the fact that he has 5 scum suspects and 2 non-IC townreads, which is extremely disproportional to the setup.
I want to see him talk about his reads on Antihero, Boon, and istott.

[HypotheticalBassists]

...How did this thread manage to double in size since this morning?

Anyway, I'd like to say that, yes, I am pretty sitfencey (serrapaladin, wha--- what's that supposed to mean?), I guess. I also want to say that with the whole RVS thing, I was not the one who unvoted Boon. I wasn't consulted on that. Nor was I consulted on the GreyICE vote until after the fact (which I'm okay with).

I'm still looking for the LMP read from Riddleton and the Egg read from Grey, but it seems like they've both fallen off the face of this game until tomorrow, so I guess it'll have to wait.

GreyICE <--> Hypo interactions on page 6 are giving me all sorts of red flags. I could see distancing buddies in here.

I'd say that I'd love to hear your thoughts on Riddleton vs. GreyICE on pages 10-12, but I'm not entirely sure what you're referring to with 'red flags' there. Care to explain? Actually, we can discuss Riddleton vs. GreyICE, too. From what I've seen with Grey, he's a pretty passionate (coughabusivecough) player, so I'm hesitant to call anything off of those arguments. Seemed pretty intense, like Istott said. Plus I doubt Riddleton (or anyone) would call for a replacement if he was acting, so in my mind, that whole episode probably doesn't indicate an association there. (Drama... You seem to have jinxed it, Medea.)

[Bulbazak]

Vote Count

Medea the Alien (0):
LynchMePls (2): Antihero, Boonskiies
Antihero (0):
Anatole Kuragin (0):
GreyICE (1): HypotheticalBassists
Egg (1): GreyICE
Serrapaladin (0):
HypotheticalBassists (4): Medea the Alien, Egg, LynchMePls, Riddleton
Boonskiies (1): ArcAngel9
Istott (0):
Murder of Crows (1): Anatole Kuragin
ArcAngel9 (1): Serrapaladin
Riddleton (0):

Not Voting (2): Istott, Murder of Crows

It is day 1. With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day ends on Tuesday, November 25 at 1:15pm EST. Countdown: (expired on 2014-11-25 13:15:00).

GreyICE is V/LA until Friday, November 14.

[Medea the Alien]

UNVOTE:

Lots of new pages and that recent VC is ick from what I remember from my new wagon mates?

[Murder of Crows]

riddleton is probably town.

[Medea the Alien]

You picked a very stale game to reference speaking of arms racing.

If you want a rock solid town read, then earn it.

post 166 is ick, namely the vote reasons ort of parrots-ish what i was saying without actually parroting it



reads list is weird and really shouldnt have us that high of null nearing town without some sort of explaination because we've been a non presense. Hell, Penguin's yet to post. Drawing a conclusion of potential distancing is super weird given grey's in the very least scummyness category of scumreads. (ffery a list that is in order, such an alien concept to us)

Like antihero's points in 167/168, would probably sheep

@riddleton re: 197, why did you say "i suspect too many people" without actually saying... you know... who you suspect and why?

Re crows 199, fucking lol at the continued joke of orc not ebing in the game?

Riddleton as of post 210, what changed from post 197? Like, you went from "omg i think a ton of people are scum" to "i have exactly 3 scumreads i a 3 scum game, one null read, and a fuckton of town reads" HOW?!? I didn't even fucking post in between these posts. Neither did a bunch of other players?!?

Yes antihero, I'm on the LSD train with you apparently.

~skips a bunch of pissing contests ~

@greyice when you get back, although you'll likely tldr this post i'll quote it when you do, what exactly about my 4 posts screamed town?


~more skipping of pissing contests~

p-edit:
fferypidgeon why is riddleton town because before I read you and AP expressing a townread here I was about to ask you to vote with me there.

[Medea the Alien]

(also 149 is quoted for my amusement)

[Medea the Alien]

The lack of instant or near-instant response worries me here given who you two are :~(

[Murder of Crows]

hush you. orci is here in spirit and he's probscum.

regarding riddleton, he's reminding me a little of some open game morph replaced into a while back.

p-edit I was on the phone.

[Medea the Alien]

If I squint I can see a few similarities (but just as many discrepancies) but I'm asking you what in

this game

is making you town read him.

(please contain your rampant gasping that I just asked you to reject meta in favor of an in-thread only read basis)

[Murder of Crows]

I'll post after I leave my dad's. little too crazy to concentrate atm.

[Medea the Alien]

Actually if you don't mind I'm kind of more interested in the pidgeon's opinion, yours can wait until your mom stops doing the things that give you said headache.

[Murder of Crows]

I don't actually think he looks like he did in that open game. Not to say that makes him scum, cause I don't think he is, but yeh.

Honestly, I don't know if I can explain it other than how his posts come across.

oh

See, posts like this and "Why?" make me pretty much certain it's faked.

This just sounds like the kind of assumption a townie would jump to.

On the flip side, I dont see scum likely being bold enough to push something they know is false.

[GreyICE]

@greyice when you get back, although you'll likely tldr this post i'll quote it when you do, what exactly about my 4 posts screamed town?

I don't TLDR posts. For pete's sake, one of my favorite players was MoI, and he used to post walls. I like well-formatted, well thought out posts.

What I hate are posts where there's a huge block of text, followed by "I was thinking the same thing" or "why was that?" or some inane comment, followed by more inane commentary. While I don't want to insult anyone, post #79 is what I would call a classic example of a post that is custom designed to be totally unreadable and irritate anyone who even tries.

For the record, I really liked this post and this post, in terms of them both having content and seeming townie. As I recall, you (or at least the Cabd head) is not typically stoked about being scum, and that seemed genuine enthusiasm. So it more seemed a case of someone who just hadn't logged on in a whole 24 hours (which is apparently 200+ posts) than someone like, well, I give to you this ISO, in all of its glory.

[Medea the Alien]

As I recall, you (or at least the Cabd head) is not typically stoked about being scum, and that seemed genuine enthusiasm.

For the record this is the 100% legit complete opposite of my usual mood, I love grabbing scum. Penguin's the one who dislikes it.

[GreyICE]

Oh. Well... crap. Was it Camn who hated it?

Whatever, my point about your 4 post ISO actually having things in it as opposed to what I linked stands.

[Boonskiies]

Damn. I'll catch up later, babes.

[Bulbazak]

Bump.