Because townblocs don't form D1 out of tonereading.
And we still have time so I don't have to settle for less yet.
And nightless games are exactly why townblocs are even stronger for scum, once scum is in there is no paranoia of why haven't one of us been killed yet questions arising that is common in others.
Probably last post for today.
Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 5:37 pm
by Shoshin
Who said anything about tonereading?
Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 6:46 pm
by northsidegal
Gamma Emerald replaces theslimer3.
The Day 1 deadline is in (expired on 2019-01-13 20:47:59).
Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 7:02 pm
by Maestro
Hooooo boi the replacements are wagoning me
Hi Slaxx - I’ve at least seen you around.
I see Cheeky basically flailed himself into replacing and lost me my only
contemporary
asset when it came to reading somebody this game. How lovely. I’ve already addressed your concern about “fomenting paranoia” which is a stupid thing to call “healthy skepticism”. I don’t do Townreads. So me seeing a whole thread going around going “herpderp town”? I’m gonna call that shit out. A certain amount of paranoia is good in a mafia game, and anybody who thinks otherwise is a bit ROSEY about the game where we pretend to lynch each otherwith democracy.
Did you have any other concerns other than “Maestro plays differently than others in the thread and can’t read Oka”? Of the 3 things I said to Oka in whatever’s post you quoted, I’m not sure which looks like distancing to you but if I wanted to say some of the shit I’ve said to Oka... and we were Scum together... why would I not just say it in Daychat?
I meant what I said about Cheeky’s lynch in that last post somebody said “could never be made by Town” btw and I would say that as either alignment...?
I see Cheeky basically flailed himself into replacing and lost me my only
contemporary
asset when it came to reading somebody this game. How lovely. I’ve already addressed your concern about “fomenting paranoia” which is a stupid thing to call “healthy skepticism”.
I don’t do Townreads.
So me seeing a whole thread going around going “herpderp town”? I’m gonna call that shit out. A certain amount of paranoia is good in a mafia game, and anybody who thinks otherwise is a bit ROSEY about the game where we pretend to lynch each otherwith democracy.
Did you have any other concerns other than “Maestro plays differently than others in the thread and can’t read Oka”? Of the 3 things I said to Oka in whatever’s post you quoted, I’m not sure which looks like distancing to you but if I wanted to say some of the shit I’ve said to Oka... and we were Scum together... why would I not just say it in Daychat?
I meant what I said about Cheeky’s lynch in that last post somebody said “could never be made by Town” btw and I would say that as either alignment...?
sfter this? I'm honestly still trying to process and I've got a post on the back burner but was worried about hitting my limit - idk why I just figured if I got sucked back in after dinner I may notve remember to keep the posts light within the next 18 hours or whatever.
I'm mainly freaking out a lil' biut that I'm townreading basically nobody here
, maybe it's cuz some of you are new, maybe it's becaus I've only ever seen brassherald play before, but y'all are fucking insane by my standards. And it's a geriatric ao I don't mean posting-freqency-wise (because I've played with and modded the worst shitposters on the site), I just mean it's like. trying to read the rosetta stone for some of you, especially hte newbiwes, seriously
That was fun, we can lynch him now.
Next?
Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 7:10 pm
by u r a person 2
VOTE: maestro
Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 7:22 pm
by Shoshin
VOTE: Maestro
Posted: Wed Jan 09, 2019 7:30 pm
by Gamma Emerald
Whoa hold the fuck up, you gonna lynch before I get the chance to say anything? Pretty awful play if you ask me. Congrats URperson2 and Shoshin: you start with a deficit of towniness!
Now onto actual reading plans. This is my second time replacing into a game with posting restrictions of this kind so I’m gonna attempt to use the same method or a similar one I did last time (for reference, the previous time was Mini 1934).
i don't agree with your reasoning on slimer. He's still null
BH's entrance pinged me in that I-should-have-known-just-from-RVS sort of way. It's supes awkward.
It also jokingly endorses the whole idea that town should be wary of wasting posts, which encourages lurking discourages discussion. I know that this rule set nominally encourages that behavior which makes BH's comments a little less scum-indicative, but honestly the post restrictions are not that oppressive.
VOTE: brassherald
I agree with this assessment of brass.
Also feel like Cheeky is town on Page 1.
In post 27, OkaPoka wrote:This might be the perfect playerlist to do this. Y'all wanna do some RAoPS? (Random Asking of Philosophy Stage) where we hit each other up with some philsophical questions about how we view the game should be played? Yes? Please? Yes?
10 posts every 24 hours is a lot lmao I don't think I really need to hardcore restrict myself.
First question should be, do you believe in lynching lylo liabilties (aka policy lynching people who are troll-y)?
Now that I’m not scum I want to really engage this. If I had two equally strong scumreads and one was a lylo liability I’d probably opt to vote them. But if I had a stronger scumread I’d go for that.
In post 99, CheekyTeeky wrote: If NL has been paying enough attention to notice Brass' slip then surely she would have noticed other things that she could comment on if she were actually scumhunting.
I assume you think NL hasn’t posted many other thoughts, which I think isn’t true?
Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 8:45 am
by Shoshin
In post 340, Gamma Emerald wrote:This related to the recent Jester Nightless? If not what does it mean?
Yes, lol.
Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 10:21 am
by no lunch
I have read that Jester Nightless. Still actually not entirely sure what to glean about Slimer's alignment from it.
URAP2 I am very sad you were the first to unvote Maestro.
Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 11:32 am
by u r a person 2
lol don't read too much into it.
new player in a slot wants to say something pre flip, that's cool. you can count on me to revote tonight
Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 12:25 pm
by OkaPoka
The only way in which you give out townreads that early is tonereading shoshin.
Also gamma town
Posted: Thu Jan 10, 2019 1:11 pm
by Shoshin
In post 344, OkaPoka wrote:The only way in which you give out townreads that early is tonereading shoshin.
None of my reads have anything to do with "tone." You need to break out that box you're in, stretch your mind a bit. My reads are based on predictions about what players would do as either alignment when confronted with this environment.
As an example, I townread Brass/NL in part because both would have been doing a lot more work as scum to pocket me (an action, not a "tone"). Why are you saying my reads are based on "tone" when they'er obviously based on predictions about likely behaviors?
I don't like this at all from you. It feels like you're trying to shake confidence in my reads without actually addressing their substantive content.