Ya one part of my role is worded in a way that implies it only matters if I am dead night three and beyond......but then after that it makes a blanket statement that I cannot recruit if I am dead.
I need Dan Brown to write a book about my role PM.
That's the guy who wrote da Vinci code, right?
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 6:46 am
by PMysterious
In post 325, Doctor Drew wrote:Ya one part of my role is worded in a way that implies it only matters if I am dead night three and beyond......but then after that it makes a blanket statement that I cannot recruit if I am dead.
I need Dan Brown to write a book about my role PM.
That's the guy who wrote da Vinci code, right?
Try separating it sentence by sentence, and take each sentence individually. Then see what sentences contradict each other.
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 7:02 am
by Doctor Drew
It's not that I don't understand it, it is just that I am trying to find any reason I shouldn't be lynched.
I want to live and play the game, but I also don't want to hurt town.
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 7:09 am
by gameplay506
Just ask the mod
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 7:29 am
by Vorkuta
@Drew
Can you full-claim your role and all (or as many as you are willing/able to share) your modifiers so we won't have to play this game of chinese whispers?
inb4 modkill!gated
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 7:42 am
by Doctor Drew
Town Unconvertible Strongwilled Compulsive Secretly Selective Cultifier
Andd....breathe.
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 7:43 am
by Doctor Drew
Honestly I think I should be lynched.
I really don't think I will just be killed and then game over, I bet I still will have influence over the game.
But that is just me guessing.
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 9:35 am
by PMysterious
In post 330, Doctor Drew wrote:Town Unconvertible Strongwilled Compulsive Secretly Selective Cultifier
Andd....breathe.
That sure is a lot of modifiers. I got Unconvertable, Strongwilled, Compulsive, and Cultifier, but Secretly and Selective I did not get.
It's a shame you want to die. You sure have a lot more going on in your Role PM than I do.
In post 237, gameplay506 wrote:Thing is how does RCE not accounting for Drew being a jester make RCE scum? From all I know if Drew gets lynched he wins solo so its not really scumindicative rathet than dumbindicative what RCE is doing
I don't actually have a problem if drew is jester. It's still non town and not the worst lynch.
A mislynch is a mislynch.
In drew's case, not really
In post 291, cyrus62 wrote:now that i have cught up i will state why i unvoted nom pointed ouit my fear but i will go deeper. what if doctor is jester and lying and we kill him and the recult dose get another cult meber
this would make 3 cults then unless we find the person making cults is killed then we will always be out number. we are taking chance voting doctor.
now here is the wired part doctor and i go back to my 1st game and his i honestly think the way hes playing is good for town but what if hes just cult trying to deflect from the guy making more cult.
i only said kill me to make sure some other random town doesn't die due to me not know who is who i rather me a non power role die then a town pr.
i want to know whats with ?? voting game play and us being told its town voting game play any one want to know why ?? is voting game play besides me
Tldr: Don't rope Drew because reasons, I am cult
Isn't it like obvious atp lol?
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 10:59 am
by gameplay506
Honestly Drew is the only logical and mechanically right lynch today.
I was worried that he might be jester and thus was going to propose a cyrus lynch just to prove that a cult exists since he is giving some strong cult vibes
But Drew's recent posting just seems as genuinely coming from town
Coupled with the fact it said that not everyone can be recruited, I took it even though I won't know who is recruited it isn't completely random.
Like there is an actual reasoning to who is recruited.
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 11:11 am
by gameplay506
And @nonmon even if drew is town his "mislynch" equals to 2 or 3 scum lynches since we are essentially stopping him from recruiting town to cult
There is just one thing bothering me: What is the purpose of this role? Like if Drew is town and he really is this role, the correct play would be to claim D1 and get lynched. So either the mod has to hope that to role lands on someone who feels like creating chaos ( like PM) or he has just knowingly distributed a role that basically restricts the player to playing only on D1.
Both scenarios are pretty meh tbh
Coupled with the fact it said that not everyone can be recruited, I took it even though I won't know who is recruited it isn't completely random.
Like there is an actual reasoning to who is recruited.
Ok just some questions
You are sure the recruit turns the recruitee to a third party cult?
You are sure you won't know who gets recruited?
If not just ask mod
I mean
It could be because of what I said previous post that this role makes little sense
But again this is extremely bastard so it could be exactly what he is claiming and the mod just betting on town being paranoid to leave the slot
Idk
The question is is it worth keeping Drew around under the presumption that he has a fake role while potentially getting townies converted every night?
To this I think the answer is no.
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 11:20 am
by Doctor Drew
I mean, korina was killed before the game started and the running theory is that he isn't gone from the game.
I am hoping for a similar outcome.
Pre Edit: I will convert people into the cult.
Doesn't say I won't know who it is, just that I don't have a choice on who is converted.
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 11:23 am
by Doctor Drew
Not sure if they will tell me, but I just asked the mod if I know who is converted.
In post 306, Chickadee wrote:If you have any questions about your role, you should ask the mod. He will either answer them, or tell you that he can't (for mechanic reasons). It's way better than us discussing possibilities for several pages.
I thunk though that your role saying it's not good for town, means literally that....being recruited is bad for town. As is such with cults.
This is a bastard game.
For obvious reasons I can't just copy and paste the role PM here. There is alot of room for interpretation though. I understand the core mechanics, there is some vagueness though that I feel is intentional.
So talking it out helps with solving the game.
Is there something about my role that worries you? We can talk about it.
I don't have any concerns that talking about would help. I actually do think your town. I'm just saying if YOU have any questions about your role, ask the mod. For instance, ask the mod if your role will still enable recruiting if you're dead.
I just think it's your time to go, because of the negative town utility.
I think it doesn't matter if I am alive or dead the first two nights, I still will recruit. And then I will recruit after that every night only if I am alive.
Sorry, I have been trying to decipher my role PM like it is a riddle and I pick something new up Everytime.
In post 330, Doctor Drew wrote:Town Unconvertible Strongwilled Compulsive Secretly Selective Cultifier
Andd....breathe.
That sure is a lot of modifiers. I got Unconvertable, Strongwilled, Compulsive, and Cultifier, but Secretly and Selective I did not get.
It's a shame you want to die. You sure have a lot more going on in your Role PM than I do.
UM
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 12:17 pm
by Not Known 15
The vote named ??, marked with a green color, comes from someone aligned with the town.
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 1:02 pm
by Doctor Drew
No clarification from mod about if I know about recruitment.
Also, trying not to get mod smacked here so I can't really say much more specifically...but I think i should be kept alive.....at least until tomorrow.
JUST FUCKING TRUST ME OK
Posted: Tue Oct 08, 2019 1:07 pm
by Chickadee
Can you make a compelling argument why town should allow a cult to grow when we have the chance to just not?
Mechanically I really do think you are today's lynch, and it has nothing to do with your play, or what you've said. You're pretty town sounding here. But...you enable a cult to start growing.