Could you explain why you find his replace-out townie, cur?
If he was scum he'd be doing a good job because he inspired a 7 page festival of nonsense, you are not likely to rep out if you are doing a good job
I would have to agree with this.
UNVOTE:
Yep
I was thinking as scum you don’t get that passionate about some of those points was my reason for TR’ing him but that is quite concise and unrefutable so if we can all agree wimpy town that would help
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 10:06 am
by Montosh
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 10:33 am
by Saladman27
Ok, so I might have been inconsistent, but I still TR Vork.
Inconsistency Part II: UNVOTE:
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 10:35 am
by Saladman27
Actually,
Intent to L-1 Wake
for some reason it’s always the too scum to be scum that flips red.
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 10:59 am
by Saudade
who are your townreads saladman
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 11:01 am
by Saladman27
Vork, Wimp/Elbirn, You, Ali, Elements and Zote.
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 11:11 am
by Zote the Mighty
Salad, that is a nice weapon you have in your profile picture. Not quite up to the standard of my weapon though, which I have very fittingly dubbed 'Life Ender.' You could do well to learn from one of Zote's 57 precepts. I'll get you started with one of my favorites.
Precept Twenty-Three: Identify the Foes Weak Point. Every foe you encounter has a weak point, such as a crack in their shell or being asleep. You must constantly be alert and scrutinising your enemy to detect their weakness!
Who are you scumreading?
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 11:53 am
by Saladman27
Wake, initially a TR because he was too obvious but it’s always the obvscum that flips red
Plank-ish, I don’t really get why he’s voting Vork despite most of the votes are on either wake or saudade.
In post 286, Zote the Mighty wrote:Right now I think Saudade is town. I don't much care for his minimalistic posting style, but he seems to want to progress the game along and get us away from the pointless discussion that has clogged the past few pages.
I don't see this. Can you point me to a post where he was progressing the game as opposed to spamming the thread? I'm trying to determine whether my distrust of him is based on alignment or personality.
In post 229, Saudade wrote:Okay, you guys stop it now and move on.
The last 10 pages of content are literally useless (well almost, its only use is for townreading wimpy but thats very narrow)
WHERE ARE THE OTHER PEOPLE
In post 242, Saudade wrote:Also you are spending so much energy arguing with wimpy but it doesnt bring us an inch closer to our goal, so, again, vorkuta!!! Focus child
In post 243, Saudade wrote:Its not about who is right in this argument its about making sure we lynch scum d1 and then do it again tomorrow
Whether or not he's successful in progressing the game along remains to be seen, but the point is that there an attempt/desire to move the game past the shenanigans of the previous pages. I don't think these wretched scum would make these posts.
I reluctantly concede. UNVOTE:
I just really wanted him to be scum so that we could lynch him and cut the page count moving forward in half. I'm sorry for my selfishness.
In post 331, Zote the Mighty wrote:Precept Twenty-Three: Identify the Foes Weak Point. Every foe you encounter has a weak point, such as a crack in their shell
or being asleep
. You must constantly be alert and scrutinising your enemy to detect their weakness!
This made me smile and laugh out loud.
I haven't read Wake yet, but I will. I do remember enough to understand the irony of this situation, though.
In post 286, Zote the Mighty wrote:Right now I think Saudade is town. I don't much care for his minimalistic posting style, but he seems to want to progress the game along and get us away from the pointless discussion that has clogged the past few pages.
I don't see this. Can you point me to a post where he was progressing the game as opposed to spamming the thread? I'm trying to determine whether my distrust of him is based on alignment or personality.
In post 229, Saudade wrote:Okay, you guys stop it now and move on.
The last 10 pages of content are literally useless (well almost, its only use is for townreading wimpy but thats very narrow)
WHERE ARE THE OTHER PEOPLE
In post 242, Saudade wrote:Also you are spending so much energy arguing with wimpy but it doesnt bring us an inch closer to our goal, so, again, vorkuta!!! Focus child
In post 243, Saudade wrote:Its not about who is right in this argument its about making sure we lynch scum d1 and then do it again tomorrow
Whether or not he's successful in progressing the game along remains to be seen, but the point is that there an attempt/desire to move the game past the shenanigans of the previous pages. I don't think these wretched scum would make these posts.
I reluctantly concede. UNVOTE:
I just really wanted him to be scum so that we could lynch him and cut the page count moving forward in half. I'm sorry for my selfishness.
In post 331, Zote the Mighty wrote:Precept Twenty-Three: Identify the Foes Weak Point. Every foe you encounter has a weak point, such as a crack in their shell
or being asleep
. You must constantly be alert and scrutinising your enemy to detect their weakness!
This made me smile and laugh out loud.
I haven't read Wake yet, but I will. I do remember enough to understand the irony of this situation, though.
This post... Rubs me the wrong way.. in multiple places at once..
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 12:59 pm
by Saudade
We should probably stop the quote quoting
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 2:22 pm
by UltimatePlank
VOTE: Salad
So I started reading the game and someone who talks in the 3rd person decided to call me a cur.
Since I'm positive that Wimpy was town, I'm voting wherever his replacement votes.
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 2:23 pm
by UltimatePlank
It'd also be nice if people stopped call others dogs as well.
So I started reading the game and someone who talks in the 3rd person decided to call me a cur.
Since I'm positive that Wimpy was town, I'm voting wherever his replacement votes.
That's a scummy reason for voting me, you could've at least regurgitated Elbirn's reasonable reasoning. You still haven't answered my question, why did you vote Cork?
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 2:43 pm
by Wake1
In short, I can't stand Day 1. Least favorite part of the game. We have literally nothing to work with.
I don't mind hammering at L-1, but I will relax on it being a quickhammer, because we'd need a claim.
If something interesting happens during Day 1 then I'll pick at it, but I'm not interested in being paranoid-psycho on everything Day 1 like others can and do. It's a waste of my time. As bodies hit the floor I can actually start parsing out who is who.
In post 302, alimdia wrote:
Sadalaman: I'm not happy with his contributions so far.
Down to wagon on: Looker, Sadalaman, profii depending on his answers.
Join me fren
Ye sure thing mason buddy, your post 308 makes sense
VOTE: Sadalaman
In post 324, profii wrote:
I have definitely seen someone make a similar statement and caught them as scum day 1
I have also been made aware that apparently I have seen people make similar statements and then they flipped town (what wimpy said)
I’ve also mentioned that it was like a page 1/2 scum read and I’ve hypothesised that there are scenarios where I’m wrong
As it happens, I agree with the point that wake hasn’t really got started in this game - it could be scum believing they are under major scrutiny so not sure how to enter the game but it’s just a thought rather than me saying “we must lynch right now”
I think I’ve got too swept up in this whole thing and I’m probably missing out paying attention to half the player list tbh
At this point we all agree that his first post is null.
The only reason to lynch him is because he is not contributing. But there are also plenty of other slots that are not contributing.
Profii is off the hook, I still have my eye on Looker though.
In post 311, Elbirn wrote:people doing bad things because they always do bad things
just sayin
this describes salad quite well.
You're free to push him- I won't get in your way, but that was just a heads up and a subtle way of letting you know that I prolly won't support your wagon.
yes I also hate it when someone does something scummy and then some random (from my POV) just say 'oh he just does that every game'
like can we have some examples? thats just bad gameplay. What if you're their partner and just say that shit out of nowhere?
In post 314, Saudade wrote:You guys arent going to believe who my mason partner is
It's me obviously
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 3:46 pm
by alimdia
Unofficial vote count:
Wake88 (5): Saudade, profii, Vorkuta, Zote the Mighty Saladman27(L-1)
Elbirn (1): Elements
Saladman27 (3): Elbirn UltimatePlank alimdia
Not voting (2): Wake88 Looker
Posted: Sat Nov 09, 2019 4:41 pm
by Saladman27
In post 345, alimdia wrote:
yes I also hate it when someone does something scummy and then some random (from my POV) just say 'oh he just does that every game'
like can we have some examples? thats just bad gameplay. What if you're their partner and just say that shit out of nowhere?