Mafiascum.net

I dont think jv's comment is as bad as its being made out to be

In post 322, skitter30 wrote:

In post 276, Uncrowned wrote:If we're comparing Skitter to Peta (who you're voting) in terms of non-setup related discussion, they're pretty similar, no?

In what way?

In terms of activity, availability of reads, and just general game content, although I think Peta has been a bit more aggressive.

I wanted to know if JV's vote on Peta was based solely on how Peta had changed his vote, or if it was based on his previous posting.

It's not a 1:1 comparison but more of a "I saw you both as slightly townie" at the time and wanted to know JV's thought process.

In post 325, skitter30 wrote:I dont think jv's comment is as bad as its being made out to be

Neither do I necessarily but I can see it being picked out as weaker posting in a game that imo has had a lot of people posting quite well.

Do you dislike any slots on the JV wagon atm?

Lilith, dave's vote was meh too
Hoopla's i'm also a bit iffy on but i think i need some more there before fully making an opinion

In post 92, Infinity 324 wrote:I'm with skitter on this, I think multitasking is pretty much optimal no matter what.

PEdit: hi!

Disagree I think they one they chose is better

In post 310, davesaz wrote:Yeah that looks weird enough to vote and see what happens.
VOTE: JacksonVirgo

Yeah... no, I think JacksonVirgo is just being a derp

Also voting out Lilith who is top of the draft is not a good move, why are people starting there?

VOTE: skitter30

Because I don't like her vote and she can play like this as scum

Tbf i forgot she was at the top of the draft
Doesnt mean i cant wagon her tho

In post 329, Dunnstral wrote:Yeah... no, I think JacksonVirgo is just being a derp

Yeah I think that's just me at this point lmfaoo

In post 331, skitter30 wrote:Tbf i forgot she was at the top of the draft
Doesnt mean i cant wagon her tho

Literally the wagon started BECAUSE she was the top of the draft.

What did you think execute from the top down meant?

In post 334, Dunnstral wrote:What did you think execute from the top down meant?

I assume this was aimed at skitter?

Yes

In post 325, skitter30 wrote:I dont think jv's comment is as bad as its being made out to be

what bothered me is the emphasis of form over content

In post 330, Dunnstral wrote:Also voting out Lilith who is top of the draft is not a good move, why are people starting there?

VOTE: skitter30

Because I don't like her vote and she can play like this as scum

why her, out of all the lilith voters?

In post 333, JacksonVirgo wrote:

In post 331, skitter30 wrote:Tbf i forgot she was at the top of the draft
Doesnt mean i cant wagon her tho

Literally the wagon started BECAUSE she was the top of the draft.

I'm wagoning her for doing a lack of townie things
Tbf she hasnt been in the thread, but i imagine she would be if town

If it helps, she's the person i can read most accurately in this pl, and her reactions to being wagoned upon actually showing up will be quite insightful. (She herself has acknowledged on more than one occasion that i'm quite good at reading her, i can pull quotes if necessary)

The fact that she's the top of the draft is sort of annoying but not like gonna prevent me from trying to sort her.

In post 338, skitter30 wrote:her reactions to being wagoned upon actually showing up will be quite insightful. (She herself has acknowledged on more than one occasion that i'm quite good at reading her, i can pull quotes if necessary)

do you expect it to work if you say it tho

I mean i wasnt until people called me out on it ...
Either way I'm pretty sure scum!her knows that i'd prioritize sorting her, and the mere fact that i'm voting her should have alerted her to the fact if she didnt

is defending yourself against dunnstral so important that you need to blow up your attempt to test lilith before she responds

I dont think that i particularly need to go out of my way to keep what i'm doing secret - like i said, scum!lilith would have been tipped off already by virtue of the fact that i'm voting her

In post 328, skitter30 wrote:Lilith, dave's vote was meh too
Hoopla's i'm also a bit iffy on but i think i need some more there before fully making an opinion

Hoopla went from the Lilith wagon to the JV wagon pretty quick, which was kinda concerning but at the same time kind of bold for a scum player to do? Makes it difficult for me to judge.

In post 341, petapan wrote:is defending yourself against dunnstral so important that you need to blow up your attempt to test lilith before she responds

That my friend is nai

In post 341, petapan wrote:is defending yourself against dunnstral so important that you need to blow up your attempt to test lilith before she responds

I haven't played too many games outside of newbie queue, but do you think most experienced players getting early wagoned don't already know it's kind of a reaction test?

In post 345, Uncrowned wrote:

In post 341, petapan wrote:is defending yourself against dunnstral so important that you need to blow up your attempt to test lilith before she responds

I haven't played too many games outside of newbie queue, but do you think most experienced players getting early wagoned don't already know it's kind of a reaction test?

i question the value in publicly announcing you expect someone's reaction to being voted to be insightful before that person actually reacts

JV/Skitter haven't interacted a whole lot directly, but have lightly defended each other here and there.

Skitter does this as town I'm pretty sure (idk about JV) but in the event one of them flips red there's some equity there imo

The one newbie I played with Skit she also did this so it's definitely not outside her scumrange from my knowledge

Which game was that, remind me?

In post 340, skitter30 wrote:I mean i wasnt until people called me out on it ...
Either way I'm pretty sure scum!her knows that i'd prioritize sorting her, and the mere fact that i'm voting her should have alerted her to the fact if she didnt

So then you don't think it will work, or you don't think it matters?