Mafiascum.net

So either it's TMI or it's hiding a scum buddy in your townreads. I don't think there's any clear tone or post from regrider so far that anyone could read as strongly town.

I think "strong impression" is a misnomer when the bar is "not going to vote". That said, suit yourself.

In post 318, flow trap wrote: Can you name something suspicious about them?

Adding pressure, thats all :)

Actually UNVOTE: CheekyTeeky for now as they are starting to actually show us their suspicion.

In post 244, Prism wrote:Town
=====
DaTacoX
CheekyTeeky
RegRider
flow trap
RH9
MargotRosa/Noksve
camelCasedSnivy
Connordragon07
=====
Scum

3rd place when much less content from reg than others just reads fake tbh.

Sorry Camel I've lost my WIM in mafia and been busy irl but I'm back now.

In post 330, CheekyTeeky wrote:Sorry Camel I've lost my WIM in mafia and been busy irl but I'm back now.

Thats ok, but when you did post, I didnt really get to see how you were viewing the game at all so I needed that.

(if you cannot tell im trying to make good reads as much as possible)

I townread you Camel so we're good

It's a strictly ordered list. I have two townreads and a townlean. The rest are null or scumleans, and as my post on my vote implies, the scumleans aren't strong either. If you put 10 people on a mile long track, they are not guaranteed to be exactly 0.1 miles apart.

I would really encourage you to look at the actual reason I gave for it to be a townlean. I actually gave it once before and just restated it for you.

It's not a tonal read, which I generally don't do or believe in. It's finding a line of questioning plausible and thinking the persistence is likely to come from good faith. I don't think this is clearcut, but I don't think it's a stretch.

You're also making a weird comparison where my townlean of 171-175 is invalid because Reg has given less content than others. His lack of content is a valid criticism, but my read is a direct reaction to the content he did give in 171-175. Finding one section more likely town than not is enough.

By contrast, I have seen plenty from other players that I actively do not like and have questioned accordingly, and would probably be pushing more strongly were it not 4/5 different players I felt that way about.

Question for y’all out there
When is it appropriate to make a reads list and when is it appropriate to demand a reads list?

I really don't know.

In post 336, DaTacoX wrote:Question for y’all out there
When is it appropriate to make a reads list and when is it appropriate to demand a reads list?

I think Cheeky is getting to that point. Something something nail that sticks up get nailed down. Like Cheek should get us something.

Votecount 1.6

RegRider(2)

~ flow trap(58), DaTacoX(30)

Prism(2)

~ MargotRosa(5), CheekyTeeky(38)

Connordragon07(1)

~ Prism(37)


Not Voting (4): Connordragon07(15), RegRider(16), RH9(43), camelCasedSnivy(84)

With 9 alive it takes 5 to eliminate.

Day 1 deadline is in (expired on 2021-09-27 18:24:47)

FLAVOR

In post 336, DaTacoX wrote:Question for y’all out there
When is it appropriate to make a reads list and when is it appropriate to demand a reads list?

Whenever and I'd say when everyone has made around at least 20 posts

Here's a list I put together just now.
There is no specific order to the people within the same category.
Anyone in neutral has either done things that go both ways or hasn't provided enough info.

Town == camelCasedSnivy
Town Lean == CheekyTeeky, RH9
Neutral == Prism, MargotRosa, flow trap
Scum Lean == Connordragon07
Scum == RegRider

I'll take questions on any of my choices. A few of them were stretched a bit to fill out each list category.

Mine would be:
Town {DTX, Margot}
Town lean {flow, RH9, camel}
Scum lean {Regrider, Connor, Prism}

The way you have engaged with my read of RegRider, asking for a reason only to completely dismiss it as impossible because of your own completely separate criticism of him, is deeply frustrating.

I've read your explanation, not completely dismissing it but not quite satisfied that I'm wrong yet. Please don't be frustrated, I'm not tunneled on you so I'm sure I'll be able to see if I'm wrong as you interact with others.

That acknowledgement was what I wanted. Thank you.

I kind of agree with DaTacoX's townread, but I'm not sure about Prism and RegRider. They both seem helpful and have somewhat good defences as to why they're not anti-Town.

In post 299, Prism wrote:At the risk of being OMGUSy, I'm wondering why you found it persuasive to begin with. Rosa only read the first 5 pages, and probably didn't know how to update it when I pushed Camel. You saw my turn towards being more proactive, which persisted in other dimensions after the Camel vote.

I think you missed that this is asking for further elaboration on why you found Rosa's case persuasive.

I will not wind up having the time to go over the game again today, but I should have virtually unlimited time this weekend to read and talk as people desire.

In post 342, CheekyTeeky wrote:Mine would be:
Town {DTX, Margot}
Town lean {flow, RH9, camel}
Scum lean {Regrider, Connor, Prism}

Margot only made 5 posts, why do you Town read them?

Why is everyone against RegRider and Prism?