Mafiascum.net

Something_Smart, you are correct that answering a question not directed at yourself is not scummy on it's own. but when there is a question that is very clearly directed at one specific person, it is already unlikely that you'll reply. and if you do reply, it is highly likely because of previous negative interaction with said person (you want to say what they'd say and say why it's wrong before they can get to it). andante has not interacted with april in the slightest here so answering this question does not make sense.

In post 108, Andante wrote:

In post 106, April Ludgate wrote:Andante
Holiday

Right with Holiday you say? This game is like a fun holiday for me!! Only, there's some bad fish here trying to ruin it, we kick them out, then we party!!

ok i was incorrect since there was an interaction. but i dont really count this either way.

aside from that, andante's posts jump from defensive and shady to bright and happy every couple posts. i would say that's a pretty good indicator of scum struggling to keep their towny facade up

As of right now i'm TL-ing: Azaariah, Geraintm, Gamma, Jeff, Osuka.

In post 116, Andante wrote:

In post 114, T3 wrote:what is andante doing

playing the game. what do you what from me?

In post 117, Andante wrote:I KNOW yall missed me when the game started but have no fear!!! doggo is here!!!

their iso is pretty long but im not going to dig through this all. posts like these two come right after each other.

andante hasn't actually done anything this game besides shade and pocket players. it may be that their personality is bright and cheery but people like that tend to be a little more trusting or extremely paranoid depending on which side they lean towards. this is highly likely to just be scum play.

i've posted a forth of andante's post count yet i can say with certainty that i've said more on the game than andante has.

In post 328, NorwegianboyEE wrote:As of right now i'm TL-ing: Azaariah, Geraintm, Gamma, Jeff, Osuka.

vote andante. lets see some pressure

In post 330, Azaariah wrote:

In post 328, NorwegianboyEE wrote:As of right now i'm TL-ing: Azaariah, Geraintm, Gamma, Jeff, Osuka.

vote andante. lets see some pressure

Agreed.
VOTE: Andante

In post 324, Azaariah wrote:i've thought about this for a pretty long amount of time and it still strikes me as extremely strange. the reason im not clear on the motivation is because it could be purely to shade or it could be tmi. either way i think the Andante is still scum.

In post 329, Azaariah wrote:

In post 116, Andante wrote:

In post 114, T3 wrote:what is andante doing

playing the game. what do you what from me?

In post 117, Andante wrote:I KNOW yall missed me when the game started but have no fear!!! doggo is here!!!

their iso is pretty long but im not going to dig through this all. posts like these two come right after each other.

andante hasn't actually done anything this game besides shade and pocket players. it may be that their personality is bright and cheery but people like that tend to be a little more trusting or extremely paranoid depending on which side they lean towards. this is highly likely to just be scum play.

i've posted a forth of andante's post count yet i can say with certainty that i've said more on the game than andante has.

AGREED.
VOTE: andante

T3 who do you townread.

you
azar
idk who else ngl

One positive thing about this pressuring point is that if Andante indeed is scum then T3's ISO evolves him into a pretty strong townlean.

ohhhh i also townread a50
i forgot-

I feel like you always townread me.
In like every single game, no matter if you're scum or town.

it's the anime pfp

I get bored of having the same one. Think i'll stick with this one for a bit.

i should change my pfp

In post 324, Azaariah wrote:i've thought about this for a pretty long amount of time and it still strikes me as extremely strange. the reason im not clear on the motivation is because it could be purely to shade or it could be tmi. either way i think the Andante is still scum.

i dont think that was a scumpost, it's just andante andanteposting because posting that sort of shit is just what andante does from what i can tell

In post 327, Azaariah wrote:aside from that, andante's posts jump from defensive and shady to bright and happy every couple posts. i would say that's a pretty good indicator of scum struggling to keep their towny facade up

i also think this is just andante being andante. imagine a kid that already can't sit still in class. now, imagine that kid that can't sit still in class, but is hopped up on like three red bulls and a big starbucks coffee with all the sugar you can get in it

yeah but does she change emotions that fast?

In post 343, T3 wrote:yeah but does she change emotions that fast?

yeah if memory serves, yeah she does

ninjad
dunno
i'll meta her and see ig

i think that my problem with the andante situation in particular is that i dont think that slot's alignment is as clear cut as some people are trying to make it sound like it is. there's probably scum motivation ~somewhere~ in here and i cant quite tell where from or in what way, but something feels off just enough that i feel like i have to point that out

like the whole thing just fucking smells. in fairness, i do agree that andante went off the rails way too quickly even for andante, but that's probably close enough to what i've seen that i can imagine this being scum or town andante just having a stroke a little bit too early

In post 323, Azaariah wrote:so you think that if i posted a reads list and someone asked me a specific question about it, some newly replaced in person saying "it'd be really scummy if Azaariah replies [this]" isn't strange?

Well, it would be strange, but not for that reason. It wouldn't be any less strange if someone who'd already interacted with you a bunch said it.

im not going to go read andante's past games to see if any of this is true but what i know is that i think this behavior comes from scum and it is likely to flip scum. if you want to do my homework that im not doing and quote some things over, that would be fine and i will read it.

Something_Smart, answering makes sense in a couple scenarios. picture this.

person 1: readslist
person 2: how confident are you in the read on person 3?
person 3: of course person 1 is going to say they hard scum read me. they've been tunneling me since day 1, we need to find our last vote elsewhere.

but i do understand what you mean since it doesn't make too much sense to answer that way as either alignment. in situations like this, it is just an opinion of which is more likely and i would say it is more likely to come from scum.