Mafiascum.net

In post 323, fua wrote:Mafia is Scorp/Butter/Dwlee. If Owl is lying we just lim him tomorrow. Town should realize a 1 for 1 trade is a good thing, especially if it’s a VT.

What? This is not a 1 for 1 situation, and both can easily be telling the truth here. Town should realize that most likely scenario here is that dwlee and Owl are both town. Be logical. I think Owl was overzealous in their attempt at a gambit, and that combined with my prior suspicion means I'm not going to rule out the possibility of them being scum (because I find it hard to see the town thought process there, despite the evidence), but I think the way this all went down means most likely both are town. I think if dwlee was mafia doctor here they wouldn't have been insistent on claiming VT, because Owl clearly had some information. The only way dwlee's response here makes sense to me is if they are telling the truth. Everything fits the narrative of them both being town alongside a mod error. I don't think it's confirmed, but it does seem to be most likely. I think it would be a strange play for Owl to go for as town, but it's just as strange of one if they were scum.

And if they are both town, scum would probably try to get a free miselim out of the confusion here. In fact, it looks like you're trying to get two. Are you just missing or ignoring the indications that there was clearly a mistake in either Owl's role or result, and they were therefore working based on incorrect assumptions?

In post 323, fua wrote:

In post 321, Dwlee99 wrote:On reread: I think I missed that the idea was to spring a trap and see if I'd claim VT? But also why gamble when >90% of scenarios a no gun result is just town?

I mean you’re still claiming VT so it doesn’t matter how we got here.

Mafia is Scorp/Butter/Dwlee. If Owl is lying we just lim him tomorrow. Town should realize a 1 for 1 trade is a good thing, especially if it’s a VT.

]Vote]Fua[/vote]
Me and Scorpius in a solve is lacking paying attention to the game and this entire post is just ridiculous

VOTE: Fua
Heck

I also am not claiming VT at this time, and I'm not claiming anything

UNVOTE:

Turns out I don't have a complex modifier and without that the theory has no basis. Without a contradictory role claim, Dwlee gets a townread for their response.

In post 326, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 323, fua wrote:

In post 321, Dwlee99 wrote:On reread: I think I missed that the idea was to spring a trap and see if I'd claim VT? But also why gamble when >90% of scenarios a no gun result is just town?

I mean you’re still claiming VT so it doesn’t matter how we got here.

Mafia is Scorp/Butter/Dwlee. If Owl is lying we just lim him tomorrow. Town should realize a 1 for 1 trade is a good thing, especially if it’s a VT.

]Vote]Fua[/vote]
Me and Scorpius in a solve is lacking paying attention to the game and this entire post is just ridiculous

Two people claimed investigative results. Also what even is there to pay attention to?

VOTE: Scorpious

In post 330, fua wrote:

In post 326, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 323, fua wrote:

In post 321, Dwlee99 wrote:On reread: I think I missed that the idea was to spring a trap and see if I'd claim VT? But also why gamble when >90% of scenarios a no gun result is just town?

I mean you’re still claiming VT so it doesn’t matter how we got here.

Mafia is Scorp/Butter/Dwlee. If Owl is lying we just lim him tomorrow. Town should realize a 1 for 1 trade is a good thing, especially if it’s a VT.

]Vote]Fua[/vote]
Me and Scorpius in a solve is lacking paying attention to the game and this entire post is just ridiculous

Two people claimed investigative results. Also what even is there to pay attention to?

VOTE: Scorpious

I’m hoping you aren’t taking Ahri seriously. If you are. You’re probably scum.

In post 324, Scorpious wrote:Quiet Owl,

What is your mafia experience?

Couple words is fine, have you played many games?

Not counting a marathon game, this is my third. Uncertain how this is relevant.

In post 323, fua wrote:

In post 321, Dwlee99 wrote:On reread: I think I missed that the idea was to spring a trap and see if I'd claim VT? But also why gamble when >90% of scenarios a no gun result is just town?

I mean you’re still claiming VT so it doesn’t matter how we got here.

Mafia is Scorp/Butter/Dwlee. If Owl is lying we just lim him tomorrow. Town should realize a 1 for 1 trade is a good thing, especially if it’s a VT.

Why are you scumreading butterchurn?

In post 333, Quiet Owl wrote:

In post 323, fua wrote:

In post 321, Dwlee99 wrote:On reread: I think I missed that the idea was to spring a trap and see if I'd claim VT? But also why gamble when >90% of scenarios a no gun result is just town?

I mean you’re still claiming VT so it doesn’t matter how we got here.

Mafia is Scorp/Butter/Dwlee. If Owl is lying we just lim him tomorrow. Town should realize a 1 for 1 trade is a good thing, especially if it’s a VT.

Why are you scumreading butterchurn?

TMI.

Actually quite blatant TMI now that I think about it.

I know that most of the playerlist is treating this like it's chat mafia, but that doesn't mean the few people actually trying to play the game are scum.

VOTE: Fua

VOTE: Butterchurn

Let's see how long it takes for me to be limmed next. (Although I shouldn't complain since I contributed to the Greeting wagon anyway.)

TMI for realizing that the mod saying there was a role pm error meant owl and I's 1v1 didn't have to have scum? Isn't that just you not paying attention/reading?

If you lack the basic logic and reasoning skills necessary to come to the same conclusions, don't blame me. What I said should be immediately obvious to anyone that is paying attention. I wasn't even the first to say it, see 307 and 311. The fact that you don't seem to recognize that means that you are either not thinking critically about the situation (even after having it explained), or you misjudged what information was available to town, because you are scum and are not working with the same information as the rest of us. And you're probably frustrated that your attempt to take advantage of the current state of affairs failed.

Jesus

Going to vote Fua after Ahri gets back. Don't want to risk Fua being flash wagoned and then Ahri dying in the night before we get to hear what she has to say.

I lack the investment in this game to properly fight these accusations beyond the statement 'I am town'.

In post 341, Quiet Owl wrote:Going to vote Fua after Ahri gets back. Don't want to risk Fua being flash wagoned and then Ahri dying in the night before we get to hear what she has to say.

Ahri is scum, there is no reason a town would float the idea of claiming an investigative role and stating a scummy result on me..

this game already gives me a headache so far (at post 120)
anyways butterchurn seems towny, geraintm seems depressed (aka towny), looking or whatever their username seems scummy because of how defensive they were, gonna state my opinions on the game so far after i read more

gerain is starting to look less towny and more like a null because while what everyone is saying makes sense, i don't believe it automatically warrants the assumption that gerain's scum