Mafiascum.net

In post 317, Andante wrote:

In post 314, Stephen A Smith wrote:Andy this is an opinion talk show

We can make shit up if we don't know

ok sorry!! distracted!!

My reads are like this:

Stephen
Fire
Eyes
Dwlee
Greeting
Frozen
Nero
Wave
Hockey
Scorp

ok,how about this one?

How is eyes at 3? because of their 3 posts?

How do they move above Dw who you were siding with in the post i just quoted.

In post 324, fireisredsir wrote:

In post 321, Andante wrote:uhhhh person I'm voting for?? UNVOTE:
surye just hasn't posted... I'm not SRing someone cause of not posting over 300 osts

you were voting overkill

This,^^^^

they arent even on your list and you said the ones you omitted you had nothing on..

I'm officially calling this list BS

uhhh again, there's not much from overkill right now, wave's vote makes me suspicious to call that slot maf, need more

In post 284, Andante wrote:wavemode feels off to me... like, I had vote overkill, then this.. like "here's some reads, I'll vote here, and say nothing" why? "ehhh just gut"
doesn't feel towny to me

In post 163, fireisredsir wrote:

In post 158, wavemode wrote:okay

fire and stephen are probably town here

greeting and dwlee are slightly town pinging me

VOTE: 0verki11

why the vote

In post 164, wavemode wrote:ah, no real reason tbh. gut?

In post 320, Scorpious wrote:

In post 162, Andante wrote:

In post 160, fireisredsir wrote:stephen looks a lot worse off that than dwlee does to me. pushing a pointless point and acting like you caught someone in something? hmm. i can see a certain type of scum player doing that, whether because he really thinks he has a point (he doesn't, dwlee is right here) or because he knows that dumb extended fights like that a lot of times will make others skim and assume both are town

for sure, stephen was like actually trying to spam the thread, which is definitely more likely to come from maf

Like, I was definitely on team Dwlee there, like, if you're giving a list of "top 5 scum" there should be some sort of reasoning with it. like, Surye was on the list, when he only had 1 post... his rvs vote... Yeah I was calling surye out as maf, but I'm pretty certain the average person doesn't declare a SR when someone literally only has a vote for "content"

In post 288, Andante wrote:Page 8 - I TR Stephen over hockey, call me crazy but I think stephen might be town

Can you explain this progression please?

umm,have I not been forthcoming enough with you to not get the same respect?

Why won't you?

ABWOP

In post 322, Andante wrote:

In post 320, Scorpious wrote:

In post 162, Andante wrote:

In post 160, fireisredsir wrote:stephen looks a lot worse off that than dwlee does to me. pushing a pointless point and acting like you caught someone in something? hmm. i can see a certain type of scum player doing that, whether because he really thinks he has a point (he doesn't, dwlee is right here) or because he knows that dumb extended fights like that a lot of times will make others skim and assume both are town

for sure, stephen was like actually trying to spam the thread, which is definitely more likely to come from maf

Like, I was definitely on team Dwlee there, like, if you're giving a list of "top 5 scum" there should be some sort of reasoning with it. like, Surye was on the list, when he only had 1 post... his rvs vote... Yeah I was calling surye out as maf, but I'm pretty certain the average person doesn't declare a SR when someone literally only has a vote for "content"

In post 288, Andante wrote:Page 8 - I TR Stephen over hockey, call me crazy but I think stephen might be town

Can you explain this progression please?

nahh I'm good

Stephen had good posts between 162 and page 8? like, not saying town has to be mega towny all the time, town just had to be towny part of the time, to be found

what is the problem? it's not even like I'm voting anyone right now, just giving thoughts

In post 331, Andante wrote:what is the problem? it's not even like I'm voting anyone right now, just giving thoughts

I asked a question, you didn't answer. in fact you specifically said you wouldn't. It wasn't even a hard question. you voting anyone has noting to do with you refusing to answer questions.

That doesn't scream town motivation.

It just doesn't all add up, the list, the refusal to answer seemingly benign questions.

I'm not feeling comfortable with any of it.

In post 332, Scorpious wrote:That doesn't scream town motivation.

ah yes.. my bad for playing catchup on 300 posts and skimming to get here

In post 334, Andante wrote:

In post 332, Scorpious wrote:That doesn't scream town motivation.

ah yes.. my bad for playing catchup on 300 posts and skimming to get here

then say that,and not nonsense.. you saying this 10 posts ago would have meant so much more.

it's not important to tell yall I skimmed, caught up? I gave my thoughts from that. that list? genuinely where my reads are at

In post 336, Andante wrote:it's not important to tell yall I skimmed, caught up? I gave my thoughts from that. that list? genuinely where my reads are at

Thats total garbage. I want to know who is reading critically and who isn't thats important.

Because you saying you are skimming as making that BS list you posted more and more illegitamte.

You said I was scum based on knowing nothing about what I was saying,and I took the time to explain it to you. Now that you aren't skimming and actually engaging in real time, do you still feel that way?

In post 284, Andante wrote:wavemode feels off to me... like, I had vote overkill, then this.. like "here's some reads, I'll vote here, and say nothing" why? "ehhh just gut"
doesn't feel towny to me

sound familiar?

Can you explain why eyes are so high in your list

In post 339, Frozen Angel wrote:Can you explain why eyes are so high in your list

You go into my early town pile.

We aren't 100% but very much thinking along the same lines.

I look good in a suit

imo full lists like that are easy to tear apart, at this stage of the game i don't think anyone would really be able to sort things that precisely, prob just general groupings. putting everyone ordered without any tiers is just asking to get overanalyzed. since he's at the bottom, i can see why scorpious would want to poke at it, and i don't think it's bad to do so (cause he thinks its a bad list if he's town, or cause it's something easy to pick at if he's maf). not sure which one this looks more like though, ill think on that

and fwiw i don't think it's a very good list either but i don't really think that makes it more likely to come from maf. maf could either just give the top 5 townreads as requested, or put some more work in to make the list look a little more convincing. i don't see much scum motivation to do a kinda sloppy partway finished list that doesn't have much to support it and won't hold up strong if anyone looks closely at it. i do see how some of those could just be gut calls and honest reads from town, and the important/stronger ones have mostly been justified already

umm I can explain my list a little better later for people interested, but I also don't wanna feel forcer to live by those reads so mehhh like a few of the higher up reads are contingent upon having towny content later, got the placing cause of stuff I liked/their interactions with each other

In post 342, fireisredsir wrote:imo full lists like that are easy to tear apart, at this stage of the game i don't think anyone would really be able to sort things that precisely, prob just general groupings. putting everyone ordered without any tiers is just asking to get overanalyzed. since he's at the bottom, i can see why scorpious would want to poke at it, and i don't think it's bad to do so (cause he thinks its a bad list if he's town, or cause it's something easy to pick at if he's maf). not sure which one this looks more like though, ill think on that

and fwiw i don't think it's a very good list either but i don't really think that makes it more likely to come from maf. maf could either just give the top 5 townreads as requested, or put some more work in to make the list look a little more convincing. i don't see much scum motivation to do a kinda sloppy partway finished list that doesn't have much to support it and won't hold up strong if anyone looks closely at it. i do see how some of those could just be gut calls and honest reads from town, and the important/stronger ones have mostly been justified already

yeah definitely. any early reads in this stage of game can be torn apart and lists like that don't say much on their own.

The reason I questioned why eye is so high in their list is,

In post 307, Andante wrote:

In post 217, Eyes without a face wrote:Early townreads on both Andante and Dwlee for seemingly being the driving forces of the game getting out of RVS so quickly.

heck yeah!! giving me credit for getting out of RVS? I'll take it!! lol I genuinely hate RVS, glad we got out of it so fast!!

that's the only interaction made by Andante about eye and eye has really close to nothing posted in game to be that high in any list

So it just felt really out of place

In post 343, Andante wrote:umm I can explain my list a little better later for people interested, but I also don't wanna feel forcer to live by those reads so mehhh like a few of the higher up reads are contingent upon having towny content later, got the placing cause of stuff I liked/their interactions with each other

If you’re communicating a list these are details that should be included.

At this point with all of your explanations about it, it’s almost moot.

And why would you put people higher on a list that are “contingent” on town content? That doesn’t make a lot of sense.

And fwiw, I’d pick this list apart regardless of my station. It’s just a horrible post.

Adante goes into early scum pile for me. Too much explanation needed for a list that is horrible to begin with.

TFW you tell the new intern she can just "make it up" and suddenly people are giving her shit on twitter about her top five list being terrible

One last thing about “the list”

I was told why I was scum read. Based on me trying to re direct posting. Fair.

Then I ask if they knew who SAS really was and they said no.

I feel I was very helpful in explaining how my scum read comment wasn’t that at all, and was STILL on the bottom of the list. Surely I’d move up a notch or two based on that.

Strongest and really only sr at the moment and I gotta clear this joke vote. So.


VOTE: Andante

In post 225, Greeting wrote:

There, happy?

1 sec lemme go print and frame this

so far I believe stephen, dwlee and fire are town

I *want* to believe greeting and hockeyfan are town

nulls are andante, overkill, surye, frozen angel

nero cain, scorpious, eyes without a face are giving me scum vibes

VOTE: Eyes without a face