Mafiascum.net

In post 3248, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Btw i hope this isn't an dupe. I played a game with basically caught scum talking for ages about how they were going to do a wall but they never did anything. In the end we just lynched them and they flipped scum.

In post 2999, NorwegianboyEE wrote:

In post 2874, Battle Mage wrote:Noraa, I don't even need you to believe I'm town, so it doesn't matter if I can convince you or not. I simply want you to look at who else we can elim today.

This is pretty damning imo.
VOTE: Noraa

In post 3066, UNOwen wrote:

In post 2290, UNOwen wrote:

In post 2248, Mundivore wrote:Okay, I missed the claiming action that was going on. That's sort of weird. I could go for PLUS, I could also quite happily go for Norwee here. If this is TvT, then it's really tragic, but it really heavily reads as TvS to me.

Why TvS?

In post 2333, UNOwen wrote:

In post 2318, duppin wrote:the TvS read is so weird to me on day 1. what makes you believe that discussion is more likely to be TvS? you said the same about me and tayl0rs discussion. Like I understand having an independent scumread on someone, but I am not sure I really follow the logic that any of these day 1 discussions are more likely to be town vs scum

I agree with this. Shelly comes across as the type of player who is willing to make these sorts of guesses based on intuition though.

This is me growing suspicious of Mundivore at days end. He never returned to the thread, so I never got to develop this suspicion.

In post 3137, duppin wrote:if noora is scum i can definitely see mundivore being scum with her, but i am not really sold on the UNOwen case

In post 3192, PlusJOYED wrote:so yeah only 2 possibilities remain really
1. we have sk, and they killed bm to frame noraa. unlikely
2. we have an absentminded vig who shot bm and they haven't woken up or won't claim (unlikely)

In post 3254, Mundivore wrote:If there is a vig, do you think their claim is worth it?

In post 2867, UNOwen wrote: Dave who do you think is scum?

In post 3255, NorwegianboyEE wrote:

In post 3254, Mundivore wrote:If there is a vig, do you think their claim is worth it?

If the vig is so bad that they target one of BM/Taylor who both said they could confirm their role. I'd rather they just claim and die tbh.

In post 3256, UNOwen wrote:

In post 2867, UNOwen wrote: Dave who do you think is scum?

In post 107, JacksonVirgo wrote:Noraa is generally more stiff as scum because she's new, she's more loose here and she's probably Town.

In post 696, shellyc wrote:

REVEAL AS INNOCENT CHILD

we were townVtown-ing all along.

In post 3251, Noraa wrote:I will do a wall dont you worry. I will also hard claim in that wall and include my explanation of why I did a few things.

In post 3252, bugspray wrote:can you give a preview

Spoiler:

op wrote: 4. PlusJOYED replaces JacksonVirgo
6. davesaz replaces MiniMegabyte

In post 3136, duppin wrote:another possibility could be a busdriver or something similar.

In post 3174, PlusJOYED wrote:but for that you need to claim right now

In post 3192, PlusJOYED wrote:so yeah only 2 possibilities remain really
1. we have sk, and they killed bm to frame noraa. unlikely
2. we have an absentminded vig who shot bm and they haven't woken up or won't claim (unlikely)

In post 3210, Hectic wrote:I was ralph %_%

I only read around 5% of the game until the final 2 day phases, where I tried to claw it back, but alas.

In post 3232, Noraa wrote:I will be evaluating ~mostly~ based off of yesterday cuz today was just town hard tunneling me and I'm not too interested in repeating what I already said or attack people forming reads on me bc it is the logical thing to do - SR me after BM dies.

Norwee is town but overconfident. He lead the Taylor wagon which ultimately got one of our strongest prs killed night 1. Norwee also outed pr which im inclined to believe however if Norwee survives til limlo, he's 99% guaranteed scum cuz scum would know the setup of the mafia team. He could be lying about mafia doc in that case or it could be his buddy. Who knows.

Shelly has been all over the place this game with sheeping, sussing, tunneling, SRing, and TRing. She's been a huge mess this round and I mean this in the least offensive way possible. Whether or not she's scum, I cant be sure but if she survives til like limlo, she's 99% guaranteed scum.

Hectic isn't tunneling me which is really really strange considering rn if I was in any other position, I would be sussing the fuck out of my slot. I feel that is the normal townie thing to do which is making me reconsider whether Hectic is just trying to look at the big picture or trying to interact with me to set up tomorrows mislim thru me or pocket me in case I dont end up dying. Ur a slight scum lean rn.

Duppin seems very levelheaded this round and I would say he's likely town. He is a rational decision maker and definitely isn't overly confident which is a good thing for town to have. I dont have much there and I understand that he had some ~scummy~ moments but overall I get town vibes there. I can quote some posts but really just the majority of his posts are very naturally towny and im definitely trusting my gut on this one.

Bugs is still scummy as fuck. The first post that didnt seem that scummy was literally sheeping everyone else's SR on me. I'm sorry but I hate that his best post(imo) is 1)130 pages into the game and 2)100% sheeping all the posts before it. Hectic says he's town but im having a hard time seeing town!bugs. If bugs flips red anytime during this game, look into Hectic. Hectic will be very very likely scum in that case.

Plus is just sheeping everyone just like bugs but I've played with plus before and that is normal plusiness. He is easy to pocket and sway which is why even if he makes it to limlo, I would argue he's likely town unless town has a ton of evidence to prove otherwise.

Uno has good reads overall. I think this slot's town. Not much of an explanation here cuz he's not a frequent poster.

and Dave I have no idea on. They've been pretty quiet but the aggression shown when sussing me seems town to me. idk not much here. just like uno, they dont post much so idk its difficult to read.

In post 3192, PlusJOYED wrote:so yeah only 2 possibilities remain really
1. we have sk, and they killed bm to frame noraa. unlikely
2. we have an absentminded vig who shot bm and they haven't woken up or won't claim (unlikely)

In post 3210, Hectic wrote:I was ralph %_%

I only read around 5% of the game until the final 2 day phases, where I tried to claw it back, but alas.

In post 3232, Noraa wrote:I will be evaluating ~mostly~ based off of yesterday cuz today was just town hard tunneling me and I'm not too interested in repeating what I already said or attack people forming reads on me bc it is the logical thing to do - SR me after BM dies.

Norwee is town but overconfident. He lead the Taylor wagon which ultimately got one of our strongest prs killed night 1. Norwee also outed pr which im inclined to believe however if Norwee survives til limlo, he's 99% guaranteed scum cuz scum would know the setup of the mafia team. He could be lying about mafia doc in that case or it could be his buddy. Who knows.

Shelly has been all over the place this game with sheeping, sussing, tunneling, SRing, and TRing. She's been a huge mess this round and I mean this in the least offensive way possible. Whether or not she's scum, I cant be sure but if she survives til like limlo, she's 99% guaranteed scum.

Hectic isn't tunneling me which is really really strange considering rn if I was in any other position, I would be sussing the fuck out of my slot. I feel that is the normal townie thing to do which is making me reconsider whether Hectic is just trying to look at the big picture or trying to interact with me to set up tomorrows mislim thru me or pocket me in case I dont end up dying. Ur a slight scum lean rn.

Duppin seems very levelheaded this round and I would say he's likely town. He is a rational decision maker and definitely isn't overly confident which is a good thing for town to have. I dont have much there and I understand that he had some ~scummy~ moments but overall I get town vibes there. I can quote some posts but really just the majority of his posts are very naturally towny and im definitely trusting my gut on this one.

Bugs is still scummy as fuck. The first post that didnt seem that scummy was literally sheeping everyone else's SR on me. I'm sorry but I hate that his best post(imo) is 1)130 pages into the game and 2)100% sheeping all the posts before it. Hectic says he's town but im having a hard time seeing town!bugs. If bugs flips red anytime during this game, look into Hectic. Hectic will be very very likely scum in that case.

Plus is just sheeping everyone just like bugs but I've played with plus before and that is normal plusiness. He is easy to pocket and sway which is why even if he makes it to limlo, I would argue he's likely town unless town has a ton of evidence to prove otherwise.

Uno has good reads overall. I think this slot's town. Not much of an explanation here cuz he's not a frequent poster.

and Dave I have no idea on. They've been pretty quiet but the aggression shown when sussing me seems town to me. idk not much here. just like uno, they dont post much so idk its difficult to read.

In post 3259, Hectic wrote:I'm rereading Jacko with the knowledge his scumgame is insane and I'm a lot less sure about that townread now.

In post 107, JacksonVirgo wrote:Noraa is generally more stiff as scum because she's new, she's more loose here and she's probably Town.

This stands out.

I also have some doubts on his reaction to shelly supposedly revealing as IC way back then.

In post 696, shellyc wrote:

REVEAL AS INNOCENT CHILD

we were townVtown-ing all along.

This post really looks like a joke to me. Especially with the orange part.

Looking through Noraa's ISO, interestingly enough, she never gives a read there all the way up till his replaceout. She's plenty vocal on shelly but never weighs in on Jack or his side of the conflict, which is partner-indicative.

Oh, and then 981 comes out where she admits she doesn't have a read on Jack but is putting him in the townbook because she likes his personality. Yeah, that's not a good sign.

Once Dave replaces that slot, she doesn't ever state any kind of opinion on read on him, up and until 3232, which is just no comment, but that's a readlist that came after she should know she's going down, so whatever.

In post 3261, davesaz wrote:Hectic, I'm slightly confused by the last part of 3259.

op wrote: 4. PlusJOYED replaces JacksonVirgo
6. davesaz replaces MiniMegabyte

In post 3265, shellyc wrote:

In post 3210, Hectic wrote:I was ralph %_%

I only read around 5% of the game until the final 2 day phases, where I tried to claw it back, but alas.

what the fuck?

that was terrible spelling from you. btw thanks for calling scum!me obvtown

In post 3269, Hectic wrote:Ja, was a gimmick account.