Mafiascum.net

yeet

Andante [1]:

Umlaut

Umlaut [1]:

Andante

not voting [1]:

Stephen A Smith

mod notes

~ this is a mod note.

flavour

In post 3245, Umlaut wrote:Working on a post highlighting Andante'a behavior toward the wagons on known scum but it might not be done til tonight because I have to actually do my job at work today

uh yeah, when I started doing this I remembered how many pages and pages and pages of wallposts and crap there were go through in the early game and never really got far with it

but ask me any questions you have, Stephen. Looks like you don't really want to read a big case anyway and I really don't have one aside from what I and others have already said about Andante, but maybe I can at least make a case that I'm town.

hmmm my bad. Umlaut is still maf, tbh can I see your self town case please umlaut?

so are we doing anything or just staring at each other for 4 days?

you can give me your #1 reason why your opponent is guilty or you are innocent

i am rereading and thinking deeply about my choice.

yeah, no thanks. I think I'm pretty clearly town, and the fact I would've gotten Umlaut before eye's stunt... is just annoying to me, and Stephen, I really doubt you're sitting there "reading" for a week... Umlaut has had a post count LOWER THAN DATISI the entire game. I knew that looked odd considering next lowest was well above, and clearly we see why now. all umlaut has done all game has been push me back after I started pushing them, yet for those mis lims we had, umlaut was perfectly fine not limmiing me, like sure I didn't care that eyes ended up being town, conceeding as maf... as town? whatever... I genuinely thought hockey was maf, I was then prepared to have to really read in you two, thus even though I was 90% sure on umlaut, I waited to vote, cause yes, the worst had me genuinely believing you were maf Stephen, and I'm honestly still not convinced you're not slowrolling maf, but Umlaut here is not too convincing he's town, literally just copied me going "if you have any questions ask" like what? he said he could town case himself or whatever, and THAT is something I really want to see, cause nothing about Umlaut this game screams town. I'm just annoyed I have to show up every 36 hours here (just like you are) to prod dodge. like, can we just end the game? why is this a hard thing to do?

oh neat, it's a wall of text. next time I have to show up, I'm making a bigger wall

lol these posts are funny to me, nero was maf, this comes from make knowing their partner is town, so me, a town with a wrong read, can easily get pushed for it! the same thing as when a town SRs another town, and maf can step in like "I'm not so sure about that" that's the same vibe I get with this

In post 788, Umlaut wrote:Haven't done more catchup and probably won't have time to do more today since I'm at work (and then doing Valentine's Day stuff) but I like that both Fire and Frozen seem to have actually made the effort to read what I've written so far. And I also like that Frozen is arguing points with me even though I called her town.

In post 694, Nero Cain wrote:scum are far more likely to claim a PR to get out of an elimination than town unless said town is a pr. Not impossible that we did hit a town pr and I guess the correct play might be to give him a day or 2

Agree with others this is ugly, that first sentence compresses to "town who isn't a PR is unlikely to say they are" which is not exactly a revelation.

In post 791, Umlaut wrote:

In post 745, Andante wrote:I'm pretty sure Nero is town here

Why?

Umlaunt is "catching up" but knows the consensus is "NERO MAF!!" so Umlaunt is like "yeah nero is looking bad" sees me, then is like "why would you possibly tr nero here?" when like, I'm pretty sure I said why, it was more of like a vibes read, felt like nero was town there, until the claim then I got sold on nero maf, and I'll go look it up, but I'm pretty sure Umlaunt was one of the ones going at me for "voting a pr claim" when like, even night gs, when we have a backup, makes 0 sense...

In post 2439, Nero Cain wrote:I'm an even night gunsmith so lets not vote town and TW instead.

In post 2440, Andante wrote:lol yeah no I'm leaving my vote

In post 2442, Andante wrote:also I don't buy you're a town pr... you were on e-1 before,had like no reaction to it

In post 2446, Umlaut wrote:

In post 2439, Nero Cain wrote:I'm an even night gunsmith so lets not vote town and TW instead.

UNVOTE: Nero

Provisionally accepting this claim, may revisit later depending on what happens. Nero would be a good investigation target if someone has an investigation that distinguishes Town Gunsmith from Mafia [Whatever].

Hockey, can you say whether you are a backup gunsmith specifically, or a backup of something else? (No need to say what else if not gunsmith)

In post 2442, Andante wrote:also I don't buy you're a town pr... you were on e-1 before,had like no reaction to it

Why is this bad? If I'm a PR I don't claim until I absolutely have to.

In post 2447, Umlaut wrote:

In post 2444, Dwlee99 wrote:I felt like Nero was obviously a PR even D1 sad

Did you hint at this anywhere?

In post 2448, Umlaut wrote:Nero, tell me why TW.

That's the claim, and then reactions to the claim. earlier, umlaunt was saying "nero didn't look good" or whatever (I quoted it, but it was throwing shade on nero) I know it's like 2000 posts later, but, the INSTANCT REACTION to nero's claim is like "must unvote! why is it bad nero never claimed before?" then like, jumping to nero's defense... there's no way I see town being like that in that situation. Instead you fished for more info on hockey's role specifically, like, WHO CARES WHAT HOCKEY'S CLAIM IS THERE??? nero was top fos, just claimed...

In post 2451, Umlaut wrote:Actually no

VOTE: Andante

Instantly disbelieving a PR claim usually comes from scum imo

In post 2450, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 2447, Umlaut wrote:

In post 2444, Dwlee99 wrote:I felt like Nero was obviously a PR even D1 sad

Did you hint at this anywhere?

By not voting the Nero wagon?

That means you thought he was obviously town, not obviously a PR. I'm not saying you

should

have hinted at this just asking if you

did

.

if it comes from scum, and you've been "convinced" I'm scum, why have you like not pushed me AT ALL when we had 2 MLs... instead, you feel like Nero's push on me will gain traction, so then you go for me in that moment?

In post 2455, Andante wrote:lol it's umlaut and nero!!! that's funny

lol

In post 2454, Nero Cain wrote:

In post 2448, Umlaut wrote:Nero, tell me why TW.

My scum vibes are tingling. I have a headache and I'm busy later today so I'll go into more detail later but basically I feel like he's just been floating around for most of the game and d1 he went from scum reading Greeting to hopping off Greeting for ???? reason.

based on how Nero interacted all game, there's no way this isn't S/S interaction... call it an "attempt to distance" or whatever you'd like, but, Nero and umlaunt are maf

In post 2457, Scorpious wrote:

In post 2449, Nero Cain wrote:VOTE: Andante

do you guys really think AD is town?

no,she is your buddy. and when you flip red,she's next

cause I'm not sure in what world (we know this is 2 maf talking to each other) the maf team is gonna push like this, but then, if I was there and aware that was going to happen, I'd just bus them harder? like, I literally unvote nero... what reason would I have to unvote, instead of continuing to tunnel Nero's bad claim, KNOWING both my partners were like "lol get andante" just doesn't make sense to me. Just like that night kill makes 0 sense. I HAVE SO MANY INTERACTIONS WITH SCORP AND NERO.... Umlaunt, you thought you could survive a 1v1 with me? bring it, I would LOVE TO SEE why I'm maf. cause apparently you're convinced I'm maf, thus you had zero issue voting me, but I haven't even seen a legit reason from you for why I'm maf all game

@Stephen, if you want to look at that page 98, 99 stuff with the claim, I think that's honestly really good evidence for why I can't be maf here

In post 2460, wavemode wrote:

In post 2451, Umlaut wrote:Instantly disbelieving a PR claim usually comes from scum imo

I find the opposite is true... scum suffer from TMI, thus they often feel like they *have* to believe claims or else they will look bad once it turns out they are wrong

the only times I've seen someone instantly disbelieve a pre-lylo claim (except a guilty on themself, of course), they've been town

in fact just yesterday fire did not believe hockey's claim. how was that different?

Agree with wave here like, me INSTANTLY disbelieving the claim, how the heck would I be maf there? ok I guess this is gonna be "partners, and thus you're bussing.. ok right, I'll find the next posts which are definitely a bus!!

In post 2481, Andante wrote:

In post 2478, wavemode wrote:can the people who do not believe nero's claim please take a stance on hockeyfan. are they scum fakeclaiming GS and backup GS together? and why do you believe so

"I'm an even night role, and tonight is an even night. let me live 1 more night!" that just screams JOAT/strongarm

Ah yes, bussing my partner and calling him a JOAT, when he definitely wasn't...

In post 2548, Andante wrote:VOTE: eyes
if we can't yeet a pr, I'm down to yeet the one who voluntarily claimed VT d1

Like, if I'm bussing nero... I say this? no. if I'm bussing, I think I'd commit to a bus, full send. no brakes

In post 2462, Umlaut wrote:in general I've found Andante's play all over the place and still think her saying that she would/wouldn't/would vote Nero depending on whether that's where the town is going at that moment to be awful, particularly on the condition Nero is town.

You think me being all over the place is bad? it's called a natural progression of reads, one which you never stopped to ask me "Hey andante, what made you flip from this read to that read?" no, it's cause you're maf and you don't actually care why I flipped, my flip from tr to sr only became bad because it was your partner, and you're trying to use that as fuel so partner doesn't die

In post 2463, Umlaut wrote:

In post 2459, Scorpious wrote:is Nero's role mechanically possible? I need the big brains for this one.

How would it not be possible? Even-Night Gunsmith is a normal role, that's all that's required.

Instantly jumping to defend nero, but this time interaction with your partner "for distance"

In post 2464, Umlaut wrote:

In post 2456, Dwlee99 wrote:I swear we are never going to kill eyes lol

If there is a vigilante please for the love of god shoot eyes tyvm

Do you really believe scum doubles down on a VT claim when told someone has a mech guilty on them?

stems from having TMI, you know eyes town, know town has a wrong read... so you feel "by correcting" that read, town points.... right

In post 2466, fireisredsir wrote:imo the only question is if it makes sense for the setup to have an even-night gunsmith and then a backup gunsmith (which is apparently not even-night). and to that i really have no idea

this was my exact thought process with the claim, like, if backup is "more powerful" makes NO SENSE... yet Umlaut jumped straight to defending the claim, no questions about it

In post 2480, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 2479, Umlaut wrote:

In post 2473, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 2464, Umlaut wrote:

In post 2456, Dwlee99 wrote:I swear we are never going to kill eyes lol

If there is a vigilante please for the love of god shoot eyes tyvm

Do you really believe scum doubles down on a VT claim when told someone has a mech guilty on them?

Yes what is the other option

Claim like Ascetic Visitor or some other low- to negative-utility role, and say you were happy to eat a launch because you were probably worse than a VT anyway.

That's a scum claim. If you didn't claim ascetic in first post...

Went silent after this post, Dwlee going "well that'd be claiming scum" and Umlaut probably was like "oh no! panic! I'm towny no more?? I'll just dissapear, since I've been TRed thus far for doing nothing"

Like, I honestly think the most compelling evidence here is just, Umlaut dissapeard every time something significant happened, and when he was therre it was just something with "distancing" with partners, or just a dash of TMI, like, I don't believe Umlaut read much of the game. cause the progression of umlaut, doesn't exactly follow what's happening in the game, it's close, but it's not reactions I see coming from town.

I think I'll just leave it at that, stop "spamming" I probably could go on, but hey, now I feel a bit better in the event Stephen does want to hammer me here, at least I've put forth some effort, I mean if I keep going, we could have datisi post more VCs and then end the game with a higher post cunt than umlaut... but, I think I've said enough, I'm really not sure how I could be viewed as town, so like, I really want to know the angle umlaut was going for here choosing to take me to final 3 over dwlee, like umlaut, give me something lol, why are you town? why am I maf? I WANT SOMETHING PLEASE!!!

next post can have the top of the page