At the time you cast this vote, Honeybee, one of your top suspects had two votes and FT who you said all the votes on him were crap had four votes. If you strongly believed that the FT cases were crap and one of your top suspects had a counterwagon building on them, why not help that counterwagon?
Especially since your OTHER suspects Baboon and Lissa were the ones pushing FT the hardest?
↑Nashville Dreams wrote:God I hate the options here. No one is lynching Csareo. I really think FT is town. So that means I have to move our vote and hope that people scumreading ika and beast will follow.
again butting in: that sounds very sketch can you clairify why they should be? what id they are not?
once fery catches up im l-1ing you
Considering this post and the fact that deadline was looming and FT was the most viable wagon, an FT wagon really should have gone through but for some reason it didn't.
Didn't I just explain why I believe Honeybee is town?
Did you like not read that readslist I just posted.
~M
This doesn't feel like scum-scum interaction btw and is partly the reason I'm comfortable ruling Nashville out as scum (I have plenty other reasons as well, might elaborate for Majiffy if I have time).
The readslist they posted a few posts earlier kinda sucked though. They had Baboon as town and Honeybee as leaning town.
Posted: Sat Oct 18, 2014 2:26 pm
by F-16_Fighting_Falcon
↑Nashville Dreams wrote:Honey Bee: The whole asking me if I played with her before and her reaction after me outting felt genuine. In a way I feel she was trying to genuinely scum hunt me and get some sort of read on the ~mystery~ hydra. More gut than anything, but I like it.
This feels super genuine though and doesn't feel like a fake reason for townreading a buddy at all.
here was my realist from forever ago. Fonz moved down to maybe scum and Ika has moved up to null
I don't really have any conclusions from this.
Perhaps it points against Anatole being scum since Mara was highly townread and could manipulate the lynch away from him if she wanted to. It is nothing conclusive though and I wouldn't rule out her putting it there as a red herring.
can you offer your take on all the Tammy stuff I've talked about? You are in a unique position because you know exactly my mindset in Vesperia since you occupied my slot and I was candid with you on stuff that never made it to the thread. I don't want to have to worry about that read (and I'm not terribly due to how she's interacted with pretty much everyone)
-b
This is one of the many reasons I'm reading Cutty as town. (I did have them as fairly solidly town a couple pages into D1 though which based on my record at reading Bork probably means they are scum... but I don't think so).
this doesn't feel like a town pov. you've done a really cursory vca without taking any notice of the reasons and trajectories, and you've done nothing to refine it.
What makes Nashville scum to your mind? What makes them more likely to be scum than Cutty?
Who makes sense as SK? I don't see how you can even sk hunt at all if you're focusing on vca.
Didn't I answer all of them?
You asked me what the role was and I gave it to you, what else have I missed? (I been kinda skimming because I been busy and I'm trying to get into contact w/ Titus)
↑F-16_Fighting_Falcon wrote:I'm gonna complete my meta dive tomorrow but I'm leaning towards voting Anatole.
I do also. The whole claim does feel odd to me.
Do you think he's partners with Mara/Honey or a Serial Killer?
I'm not really sure.
I think the whole I'm a vig, but can't use makes sense for a SK, but I'm really not sure, but I think that slot is scum regardless.
this doesn't feel like a town pov. you've done a really cursory vca without taking any notice of the reasons and trajectories, and you've done nothing to refine it.
Allow me to make an exaggerated shrug to accurately portray how little I care
↑fferyllt wrote:What makes Nashville scum to your mind? What makes them more likely to be scum than Cutty?
50/50. Anatole and Cutty make the least sense as scum for differing reasons.
↑fferyllt wrote:
Who makes sense as SK? I don't see how you can even sk hunt at all if you're focusing on vca.
Whichever one of Oka/Nash isn't scum.
You're overcomplicating things unnecessarily.
Posted: Sat Oct 18, 2014 3:25 pm
by Nashville Dreams
Jiffy how is that you don't feel bad for doing exactly what you did in Micc's Micro. Like you replace in, decide to not read the game and then tunnel on a player, then tunnel on the same player when you are confirmed town. obv different scenario here, but still.
