Mafiascum.net

In post 3324, The Goat wrote:

In post 3323, DrippingGoofball wrote:

In post 3321, The Goat wrote:I'm conditioned to playing in games where protects are shown in write ups.

I've never seen that. Can you point to an example?

Current game at :sj:. Read the morning writeup.

http://www.packmentality.net/forum/inde ... 4.msg0#new

"Only registered members are allowed to access this section."

In post 3295, Messiah wrote:Who do you want to lynch, then, Guille?

I'm think about that.

Personally, I got a bad feeling about DGB. Before UN was banned, he was all DGB is scum, I just feel it, in our QT. And I was against that idea. Today's reaction and Obsession to my PC made it seem like he was role fishing, like I said it seemed like he wanted to figure out how my power worked. I'm going to have to ISO her and Cryo.

. How do you view DGB and Why?

Ms Marangal has been under the radar most of the game. She has posted a lot, like she normally does, but I feel that she has been rather tame. Not quite like I normally see her play. However, she was the driving force behind Qwint's wagon. Although I want to go check and see how that wagon appeared. It is unlikely that she bussed him like that, unless she miscalculated and didn't think that the wagon will actually result in a lynch. Not willing to lynch her, unless Rubi/Goat flips orange.

Viomi, has been utterly useless. But he.... She... has is like this on pretty much every game I've played with him, when she is town. I don't recognize her scum play thought.

AN. Well, UN gave Nero a lot of praise, and thought that Nero can't be town or he would have played better. I thought the opposite. I think Nero keeps tunneling the wrong people. Last time I played with him he got lynched and left no contribution. He's been utterly wrong the entire game and I don't think he is write about Mac and MS. By VCA alone, he should get lynched. This one is an acceptable lynch for me today, but I don't think this is his scum play.

Mac. looking at #2089, I find that mac cannot be Orange. This is a very strong intent to lynch PC. If he were orange, he suspect know that Slaandar was not busing PC and there for that PC was town. This post is a genuine (wrong) suspicion of scummy play by PC.

Acceptable lynches for today are AN and DGB.

In post 3326, guille2015 wrote:Acceptable lynches for today are AN and DGB.

You're at least 50% wrong. You think I bus'ed qwints? KOC?

I think we should lynch either Rubicon or Goat. One of them is a mafia doctor and is lying about targeting Messiah.

Scratch that, Rubicon probably has a 1-shot BP.

Night 5 ended in NO DEATH. We should have had two - PLUS Guille's Rubicon bomb. So three deaths were somehow averted last night.

It's not impossible that a kill was not sent by one or more of the scum groups.

Something doesn't sit right with Rubicon surviving the bomb.

And something doesn't sit right with Goat not having been targeted for a NK.

VOTE: Rubicon

In post 3304, The Goat wrote:Is it reasonable to think that if there is an un-NKillable town PR that there would be an equivalent role for each scum team?

Not a BP doctor, no.

In post 3327, DrippingGoofball wrote:

In post 3326, guille2015 wrote:Acceptable lynches for today are AN and DGB.

You're at least 50% wrong. You think I bus'ed qwints? KOC?

That's the only reason I am not outright voting for you.

I'll post more this afternoon, I know there are some questions that I was asked, but for now: I don't really buy DGB as scum.


DGB, we don't know that there are still two scum teams. If Goat is a mafia doc or had some other way of blocking the vig kill, he probably couldn't do that and submit a night kill the same night.

MMMMMMMMM

I change my mind. I think Rubicon will flip scum.

In post 3333, Rubicon wrote:DGB, we don't know that there are still two scum teams. If Goat is a mafia doc or had some other way of blocking the vig kill, he probably couldn't do that and submit a night kill the same night.

I would wager two scum teams remaining, one member each. Oftentimes the last scum can use their power and the NK.

Allllright but I want goat dead two

VOTE: Rubicon

In post 3337, Viomi wrote:Allllright but I want goat dead two

VOTE: Rubicon

So, let me get this straight. your saying that you want goat dead regardless of Rubicon's Flip?

Any last words Rubicon?

In post 3339, guille2015 wrote:

In post 3337, Viomi wrote:Allllright but I want goat dead two

VOTE: Rubicon

So, let me get this straight. your saying that you want goat dead regardless of Rubicon's Flip?

yep pretty much

Unless he's a doctor

Then idfk
ehh

In post 3333, Rubicon wrote:I'll post more this afternoon

In post 3296, Messiah wrote:

In post 3287, Rubicon wrote:

In post 3276, DrippingGoofball wrote:

In post 3269, guille2015 wrote:I don't know how Rubi survived. But I find it unlikely that there was a roleblocker.

one-shot BP?

Actually, just proving I have a targetable ability of any kind would disprove this.

.. why?

Well, scratch that if you think there's a 1-shot bulletproof scum with a targetable power that doesn't kill and isn't roleblocker.

In post 3297, Viomi wrote:

In post 3229, Rubicon wrote:Also, I was thinking about something. Is there any way for a doc, vig and watcher to mutally townfirm each other? Like, if a kill fails and the only two people visiting the target were me & Guille.

So
This actually makes sense
And would definitely make you doctor

Except the problem is scum might take this opportunity to kill you, and because you were dead you couldn't protect the target and guile would accidentally kill them.

Which is why I disagree with this.

I'm reasonably sure the protect would still go through, but anyway, the bigger problem with the plan is that DGB thinks there could be a scum doctor.

In post 3306, The Goat wrote:

In post 3228, Rubicon wrote:(1) the Goat (who would have been lynched immediately today if I died) used some kind of protection / redirection / etc. to make people wonder about both me (and to some extent you) for why I didn't die.

Rubicon...

...let me ask you something...

...if I "used some sort of protection or redirection on you"...why isn't Messiah dead?

Because I protected Messiah. I think I'm missing your point, though, since your phrasing suggests you think this question is significant.

In post 3340, guille2015 wrote:Any last words Rubicon?

I'd prefer not to be lynched, mostly because Messiah will die right after, but... You can probably still win this either way. Lynch Goat after me. If there's another scum left, it's probably Nero. If not, it's probably MS.

VOTE: The Goat
just in case anyone would rather to jump straight to the point.

hey! why are we lynching Rubi if guille's got a bomb on him?

I don't think Guille does?
Unless he was blocked from detonating and it's still there, or something.

What's your position on the whole is-Goat-lying issue, Mac? Are you with me or are you wrong?