Mafiascum.net

He deserves the win... why, exactly?
You've put in a lot of words to say you don't scumread him, but zero explanation about *why*.

Well I guess it's balanced then, because, apparently, I didn't give enough explanation to "why" he was scum in the first place. If I had, he probably would have been dead yesterday. Or the day before that when I was trying to get him killed.

Your reticence is making it harder to form a read on you.

Please outline "why" you believed he was scum yesterday (and the reasons must be pretty convincing if he would have died as a result).
Please also explain "why" you believe he's town now.

UNVOTE: Unvote

Let’s actually take some time this day phase.

I’m cool with that.

I’m going to do some Team Analysis. I haven’t done the famous Boonskiies Crewskiies Analysis in a while.

Boonskiies Crewskiies Analyses, the BCA, better know your abc’s, because a’s been at the forefront of the media for far too long, and the b’s and c’s won’t deal with it no mo!

An extensive partner exclusive analysis that pairs the remaining players in the game up.

Used to be more detailed than my VCA play

I mean, that's assuming there are 2 scum players left. 4 scum in a list of 13 feels like too much.
How is there at least one scum in {Auro, Insomnia}, Flavor?

I’ll explain in the BCA

Titus was a fucking cop

Why are we even discussing the nightkill here and who would make it? Everyone would.

FL’s probably scum but if he is I don’t have the mental energy to go through lynching him so I’d rather towncase everyone else, eat the rope and when he doesn’t die after my lynch in F3 after claiming cop, you flash wagon him.

Auro if we don’t lynch scum this day phase we lose in F3

Hope you know why

She was a rolecop, not really much of a mechanical threat unless there's a traitor?

Not much of a threat? 2 clears is not enough of a threat? A potential red is not a threat? Lmfao

Why is FL scum? I'd need *very* convincing evidence to believe that, because the argument that scum!FL doesn't bus from meta is strong.

Because everyone else is town

In post 3410, insomnia wrote:Not much of a threat? 2 clears is not enough of a threat? A potential red is not a threat? Lmfao

You understand that they're not clear, right? Rex and Looker are just "vanilla". Role != Alignment. They could be goons.

I don’t need a scum case on FL, I need to town case everyone else so he’s the only one left in the PoE.

Then it was someone who doesn’t understand mechanics

Or maybe the only mafia left is a PR

The converse applies too, I'd need superstrong towncases on everyone else before I'd lynch FL.

Even if it's a PR, I can't imagine a role that strongly points to scum and not town - unless they planned some fakeclaim gambit. Titus feels like a sub-optimal kill for anyone who wasn't being hard-pushed by her.

How do I know you’re not scum tho Auro? You’re the odd on left.

I’d need to be sure on you as well, which I’m not.

Honestly? If I was scum with Pine we could've pushed a TFL lynch together and perhaps killed you at night - that seems like a superior strategy for me to take.
Of course, it's not entirely implausible that I'd bus the crap out of Pine and then try to coast off the towncred.
I don't know if I've exhibited any behaviors that exclusively come from town!me.

In post 3419, Auro wrote:that seems like a superior strategy for me to take

Especially given the flips imply more weak investigative roles and I'd be the only one left to perform Night Kills, which means I leave myself open to getting guiltied - thus, bussing is <utility than lynching TFL and bussing the next day instead.

Also, you've been scum alongside me - I shade partners a lot as scum but I prefer to avoid bussing if I can, I think - so there's that.

I’m gonna re-evaluate just to make sure and then the only course of action that makes sense is for me to hold the game hostage by tunneling FL all day so that when I flip town, all you have to analyse is today’s talk and you’d have more incentive to lynch him F3.

I gotta be sure tho.

Oo....I know which one of you guys are scum.

@Auro - can you make me a list of all the roles claimed and actions made?

I’m gonna brain blast this.

Stars just aligned up, I just won the jackpot on a nickel machine.

I need all mech info.

If you got me as scum then you’re wrong