Mafiascum.net

elvis_knits wrote:Silavor, please respond to this:

elvis_knits wrote:

JUST BECAUSE SOMEONE NAMES 5 SUSPECTS DOESN'T MEAN THEY HAVE SLIPPED AND SAID THERE IS A 5-MAN SCUM TEAM.

Please tell me why you would see pere name 5 suspects and be like: "OMG A SLIP THAT HE KNOWS THERE IS A 5-MAN SCUM TEAM!!!!"

Stop misrepping, I never said it was a slip.

So what are you saying it was?

...Exactly what I said it was at the time, obviously. I was genuinely wondering if he was suggesting we've got a five-man scum team.

elvis wrote:I don't think PL's are inherently scummy. I don't really agree on PL's, since I'd rather keep and work with a dumb townie than waste the lynch, but I know people who agree with you and I understand. I do think it can be exploited by scum, but it's not inherently scummy. Early game I saw more talk of PL's than scum hunting, which is what worried me.

I was dipping my feet in the pool and checking the temperature before I dived in.

That, and I'm lazy, and discussing PLs always generates some sort of discussion. Plus I don't mind looking 'scummy' early. I find I read the game better when people are attacking me.

re: Daykill- So far in my experience, fake daykills are preceded by "I'm gonna vig you". Real daykills are followed by everyone else saying "Why did you kill ________, he was town!?"

@Amrun- Was responding to

Flavor wrote:

@Peregrine:

Who are your scum picks? Thoughts on Fate and ZeL1nk? They are two of the most active players so far so there is plenty of information from them.

Atilysan and pappums Rat and Lowell each had one post, which was less than me (I had 2). Atilysan and Lowell have since posted, and Pappums is replacing out.

@Silavor- I think the mafia team is 6-8 players. It could be one or two teams. It could include a SK or two, or other self-aligned.

@Earworm- Yes, there were 5 players in the post, but see my response to Silavor above.

@Flavor (re post 310)- Maybe, but I'm not going to make shit up about every single players post in order to make up a case on them. I'll read, post, and contribute, and I'm sure they will too, so, no, I don't think it's hypocritical.

@Pappums- Sorry for your loss.

I think I've hit all the questions, and am caught up.

silavor wrote:...Exactly what I said it was at the time, obviously. I was genuinely wondering if he was suggesting we've got a five-man scum team.

But were you trying to call him scummy for it or not?

Like what was your judgement of that?

Peregrine: So is not posting much a scumtell?

ZeL1nK wrote:Neither Fate nor earworm asked any questions. I was pointing out why I thought they were both incorrect on things they'd said, not answering questions for FA...

How is that any different to what other people have done anyway? And why is it a bad thing to do?

................................................................................you're playing on words

Seriously, when you make a case on someone, you expect THIS PERSON to respond to it. A case for me is the same thing as a question, sorry if it doesn't end with an interrogation mark...
And why is it a bad thing to do? Because if you respond for another person, it's harder to form a read on that other person.

Silavor... explaining more what I mean...

If you thought someone was saying there was exactly 5 scum, and not "maybe" five scum or some other number -- why wouldn't you think that is a slip?

I mean, why comment on it at all if you're not laying blame somewhere? In what way was it important to you otherwise?

I definitely thought you were trying to say the 5-scum thing was a slip. If you're not saying it was a slip... what was your point?

Amrun wrote:Peregrine: So is not posting much a scumtell?

It depends. Last game I was in with Lowell, yes it was. With PRat, obviously not.

Snarky wrote:Seriously, when you make a case on someone, you expect THIS PERSON to respond to it.

No, actually, when I make a case on someone, it's open for discussion, and in fact, I encourage people to discuss any case I make. Pick it apart, tell me what you do or don't agree with, it'll help me get a better read on you.

On the other hand, there are times when I'll ask someone a question and want only a response from them, not speculation from other players. But I didn't answer any questions on FA's behalf, so this isn't the case.

PeregrineV wrote:

Amrun wrote:Peregrine: So is not posting much a scumtell?

It depends. Last game I was in with Lowell, yes it was. With PRat, obviously not.

Do you think that is something he does in any alignment?

(Hint: it is.)

Why would you base calling someone scum in this game based off of 1-game meta in another game (Cold War)? Do you think that is a sufficient reason to suspect someone?

My point was to get him to talk, to find out if he really was trying to say there was only five scum or not. It was too vague for me to make up my mind on whether there was anything scummy about it or not.

So you thought it MIGHT be a slip?

mmm silavor that seems like a just made up excuse made by scum. Like really? To get him to talk? It's not a question that generates a lot of discussion IMO

@ZeL1nK: Ok, then I believe it's more a playstyle issue we're having here

vezokpiraka wrote:AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH


DK makes my mind hurt.

unvote
vote snarky

@DK: I really don't believe you're a townie. I just want you dead.

But I am, I am the Bodyguard.

I have never lied a claim in any games, I've claimed scum before, any role, you name it.

WHY THE HELL WOULD YOU CLAIM RIGHT NOW

DeityKabuto wrote:

vezokpiraka wrote:AHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH


DK makes my mind hurt.

unvote
vote snarky

@DK: I really don't believe you're a townie. I just want you dead.

But I am, I am the Bodyguard.

I have never lied a claim in any games, I've claimed scum before, any role, you name it.

START GETTING YOUR GAMES STRAIGHT. THIS WAS MEANT FOR RETURN TO GAMBITS.

Amrun wrote:WHY THE HELL WOULD YOU CLAIM RIGHT NOW

BECAUSE THEY DONT BELIEVE ME.

Oh, DK.

I can't take it. I can't.

VOTE: DeityKabuto

That was actually a claim in a different game, though. He's already claimed VT twice this game.

ZeL1nK wrote:That was actually a claim in a different game, though. He's already claimed VT twice this game.

Oh, thanks, got confused. Yeah, I'm VT.

Amrun wrote:I can't take it. I can't.

VOTE: DeityKabuto

Stop being lazy, and making me an excuse and actually do something.

I've done more in this game than you, DK. Far more.

I've had it with you and you make every game you're in horrible and not fun and I really want to enjoy the games I'm playing.