Animal Rescue: petsPick (Game Over!)

[Quilford]

Eh, mafia alignment actually makes more sense than SK.
A hard to use vig-power gives scum something to strategize on together and a vehicle for massclaim punishment.
Just like Baby Spice in Zor's Strategy Mafia game.
His described role doesn't sound like a legitimate serial killing role because of the 'you die if you shoot the wrong thing' aspect and the reduced target pool.
The way he claimed, rolling it out in two phases and mentioning Mao was killed by a dog, sounded like he has the role he has claimed even if he's scum.

Also scum totally gave town useful strategy advice (scum had ways of killing through doors) in Strategy Mafia.
Telling people not to massclaim is like the easiest thing to say town sounding things about ever.

Amrun? This sounds pretty damning.

[Llamarble]

He could also be town. I just don't really think he's an SK.

[Quilford]

...

[Amrun]

Eh, mafia alignment actually makes more sense than SK.
A hard to use vig-power gives scum something to strategize on together and a vehicle for massclaim punishment.
Just like Baby Spice in Zor's Strategy Mafia game.
His described role doesn't sound like a legitimate serial killing role because of the 'you die if you shoot the wrong thing' aspect and the reduced target pool.
The way he claimed, rolling it out in two phases and mentioning Mao was killed by a dog, sounded like he has the role he has claimed even if he's scum.

Also scum totally gave town useful strategy advice (scum had ways of killing through doors) in Strategy Mafia.
Telling people not to massclaim is like the easiest thing to say town sounding things about ever.

Amrun? This sounds pretty damning.

HOW does that sound pretty damning? It doesn't at all. He's saying the exact thing I'm saying: lew's probably not an SK because of the dying thing.

Why are you looking to me, anyway?

Make your own mind up. You're starting to really rub me the wrong way. You're absolutely looking for ANY REASON to lynch lewarcher, sensical or not, instead of actually trying to figure out his alignment.

[Untrod Tripod]

right, so uh

why again aren't we lynching lew when we know that his roleclaim is bullshit?

oh right. because CES fucked that up. let's all point and laugh at CES.

[Amrun]

We don't know that, though?

[Untrod Tripod]

We don't know that, though?

Human owners are killed, not their pets

I am Mao-Tse-Tung, and I am a town assassin cat. Each night I can decide to visit a player. If that player has a cat, I will kill him. If that player has a dog, I will die. The flavour is connected with the real biography of my former cat Mao, who was killed by a dog.

But

why does he kill other cats

? What's the flavor reasoning for that?

NINJA'D. Mao was an extremely aggressive cat. No other cat in the neighborhood as long as he was alive.

so yeah. we do know that.

[Amrun]

I read the original claim post as killing the owner...

I would like lew to clear it up, though.

[Untrod Tripod]

yes, because rather than reading the words that he wrote before we questioned it, we should give him the latitude to say "lololol of course I meant the owners!". That is a very extremely smart plan.

[Quilford]

Eh, mafia alignment actually makes more sense than SK.
A hard to use vig-power gives scum something to strategize on together and a vehicle for massclaim punishment.
Just like Baby Spice in Zor's Strategy Mafia game.
His described role doesn't sound like a legitimate serial killing role because of the 'you die if you shoot the wrong thing' aspect and the reduced target pool.
The way he claimed, rolling it out in two phases and mentioning Mao was killed by a dog, sounded like he has the role he has claimed even if he's scum.

Also scum totally gave town useful strategy advice (scum had ways of killing through doors) in Strategy Mafia.
Telling people not to massclaim is like the easiest thing to say town sounding things about ever.

Amrun? This sounds pretty damning.

HOW does that sound pretty damning? It doesn't at all. He's saying the exact thing I'm saying: lew's probably not an SK because of the dying thing.

He's also saying he's probably mafia... or at least, he did.

Why are you looking to me, anyway?

Because you're defending lewarcher most vigorously, and because I'm finding it hard to 'make my own mind up'.

You're absolutely looking for ANY REASON to lynch lewarcher, sensical or not, instead of actually trying to figure out his alignment.

This is so much bullshit I'm going to stop here and calm myself with visions of you being lynched.

[Llamarble]

VOTE: Quilford

[Amrun]

yes, because rather than reading the words that he wrote before we questioned it, we should give him the latitude to say "lololol of course I meant the owners!". That is a very extremely smart plan.

Okay I made a post on this and apparently lost it.

I read the post originally as meaning owners; the first time I considered otherwise was when he was asked "why do you kill cats." I can see him not making that distinction in his mind and just relating back to what his actual cat did.

More importantly, zoraster said that in his first post and though scum COULD have forgotten, if lewarcher was scum (or sk), he would already have a description of killing owners to reference and probably would have been a lot more careful in his wording of a fakeclaim.

So it shakes out to null in my eyes.


Quilford, you are being really dense right now. Even though LLamarble was expressing a general scumread on lewarcher, that is his opinion and in no way "damning."

aw crap I'm losing my scumvibes for llamarble

SOTTY HELP

[Ghostlin]

Llam, you do realize that Lew's alignment isn't a question with one answer, right? I say this because your last two posts go 'oh, he could be scum.' 'Oh, he could be town.' We know what he could be, choose one.

Also, your case on Quilford?

[Quilford]

Quilford, you are being really dense right now. Even though LLamarble was expressing a general scumread on lewarcher, that is his opinion and in no way "damning."

Okay, my folly was not selectively quoting.

What do you think of the mod-meta Llamarble posts about?

[Quilford]

Eh, mafia alignment actually makes more sense than SK.
A hard to use vig-power gives scum something to strategize on together and a vehicle for massclaim punishment.
Just like Baby Spice in Zor's Strategy Mafia game.
His described role doesn't sound like a legitimate serial killing role because of the 'you die if you shoot the wrong thing' aspect and the reduced target pool.
The way he claimed, rolling it out in two phases and mentioning Mao was killed by a dog, sounded like he has the role he has claimed even if he's scum.

Also scum totally gave town useful strategy advice (scum had ways of killing through doors) in Strategy Mafia.
Telling people not to massclaim is like the easiest thing to say town sounding things about ever.

Eh, mafia alignment actually makes more sense than SK.
A hard to use vig-power gives scum something to strategize on together and a vehicle for massclaim punishment.
Just like Baby Spice in Zor's Strategy Mafia game.
His described role doesn't sound like a legitimate serial killing role because of the 'you die if you shoot the wrong thing' aspect and the reduced target pool.
The way he claimed, rolling it out in two phases and mentioning Mao was killed by a dog, sounded like he has the role he has claimed even if he's scum.

Also scum totally gave town useful strategy advice (scum had ways of killing through doors) in Strategy Mafia.
Telling people not to massclaim is like the easiest thing to say town sounding things about ever.

Amrun? This sounds pretty damning.

He could also be town. I just don't really think he's an SK.

That last quote is so lol.

[Ghostlin]

Llam, you do realize that Lew's alignment isn't a question with one answer, right? I say this because your last two posts go 'oh, he could be scum.' 'Oh, he could be town.' We know what he could be, choose one.

Also, your case on Quilford?

Should read 'you do realize Lew's alignment isn't a question with more than one answer'.

[Amrun]

What, Baby Spice's role in Strategy Mafia?

That proves nothing except that Lewarcher could be scum. HEY GUESS WHAT OF COURSE HE COULD BE SCUM... I never said any differently, and you are failing very hard at reading comprehension so far in this game.

But now that I think about it, zoraster is unlikely to put another role like that in two games back to back as the same alignment.

I don't see the merit in speculating about mod meta in this instance; I speculated about it because you asked, but I think it's fairly irrelevant.

[Quilford]

Okay. Thanks.

[Ghostlin]

What, Baby Spice's role in Strategy Mafia?

That proves nothing except that Lewarcher could be scum. HEY GUESS WHAT OF COURSE HE COULD BE SCUM... I never said any differently, and you are failing very hard at reading comprehension so far in this game.

But now that I think about it, zoraster is unlikely to put another role like that in two games back to back as the same alignment.

I don't see the merit in speculating about mod meta in this instance; I speculated about it because you asked, but I think it's fairly irrelevant.

What do you think he is, Amrun?

Also, the line about zo unlikely putting another role like that in two games back to back is WIFOM. And slightly outguessing the mod.

[zoraster]

Spoiler: Sausage!

[
No game purpose. Just a photo of Apollo. He wants sausage.

Day 1

Amrun ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 9 )

Cogito Ergo Sum ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 9 )

Debonair Danny DiPietro ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 9 )

Ghostlin ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 9 )

glowball ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 9 )

JasonT1981 ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 9 )

Kublai Khan ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 9 )

lewarcher82 ( 7 )

XReckonerX,

Untrod Tripod,

Ghostlin,

Debonair Danny DiPietro,

Kublai Khan,

VP Baltar,

glowball,

[/color]

(L - 2 )

Llamarble ( 3 )

Sotty7,

Cogito Ergo Sum,

Amrun,

[/color]

(L - 6 )

Quilford ( 2 )

xvart,

Llamarble,

[/color]

(L - 7 )

Sotty7 ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 9 )

Untrod Tripod ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 9 )

Vi ( 1 )

lewarcher82,

[/color]

(L - 8 )

VP Baltar ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 9 )

XReckonerX ( 0 )

[/color]

(L - 9 )

xvart ( 1 )

JasonT1981,

[/color]

(L - 8 )

No Lynch ( 0 )

Not Voting ( 3 )

Roxi, Vi, Quilford,

Total Votes ( 17 )

Needed to Lynch [ 9 ]

Deadline: Nov. 18th at 20:00 EST

[Amrun]

What do you think he is, Amrun?Also, the line about zo unlikely putting another role like that in two games back to back is WIFOM. And slightly outguessing the mod.

Learn to read and/or shut up. Of course it's wifom and outguessing the mod. I stated as much RIGHT AFTER and only said it in the first place because I was asked to.

AND AS STATED MANY PAGES AGO, I am leaning scum on lewarcher, but it's retarded to lynch him today.

[Untrod Tripod]

...you don't want to lynch your scum reads?

[Amrun]

Not in this case, nope.

[xRECKONERx]

Not in this case, nope.

Okay Amrun is town but we should ignore her anyway

[Amrun]

You're the one pushing for an sk lynch without even any flips. We should ignore YOU.