Broken quote tags suck, but whatever
Part One: Mae is relaxed in the early game
That is not alignment indicative. Many players as scum are extremely relaxed in the early game especially since they can write off anything they do as not being serious/being RVS/not mattering. Conversely many townies come in very strong and are super obsessive, focused, and wound up, perhaps wanting to exit RVS quickly or just feeling eager. This is null.
Part Two: Mae questions Mhork
This isn't anything. Town Mae has just as much reasoning as scum Mae to find an early game target. Town Mae to start the scumhunting search and scum Mae to search for potential mislynches. You can note that her questions are more of a probing nature testing the water rather than making accusations. While I suppose there's a chance that she is sincerely super calm about everything without a care in the world, it's so much more likely that she's looking for someone to see her minor questions, grab on, and let her ride their cases they build against me. That's a simple, relatively effective scum tactic. She paints a target and someone else goes after it, absolving her of guilt but achieving the mislynch.
And again, you're assuming you're playing with your clone/twin/doppelganger/whatever. You might act this way as town, but other people act this way as scum. What you would do in this situation is irrelevant. And scum Mae wouldn't necessarily push harder. Pushing means attention and until she's sure she has plenty of people agreeing that I look bad, what is there to gain by attention?
Part Three: But she isn't confident guize!!!
Your quote doesn't show her piecing anything together. All she's doing is noting a vote and calling it sheeping. That's just her trying to see if people are agreeing with her about me looking bad. And if scum are too confident, they could just as easily get called out because they already know who is town and who is scum. It's just as common a scum tactic to play like a total idiot, mislynch bait and hope someone like you comes along to white knight them to the end game. It's a matter of tactics. Everyone has different ones.
Part Four: Not making others do work
First of all quote is one of Mae's
Lies
, but that's for another time. Point is she isn't making other people do work for her, but she also isn't doing anything either. I've already pointed out that she was laying a foundation for someone to grab hold of. Why wouldn't she do it? Why was she waiting, lazily probing and testing the waters?
Part Five: The secondary lynch candidate
I would absolutely expect a scum player to point out that a bunch of people are holding her as a secondary lynch candidate. What does she have to lose. Not only does she throw suspicion on all those people away from her, but it also taps into a bit of AtE to get people on her side.
And how in the hell can you read that she's ok with that? Where in there does she say she's ok being a compromise lynch? You're reading into it substance that isn't even there. He tone is accusatory. She points out that she's a back up lynch amongst people and fingers them. She points out all the people who are voicing suspicion without voting her. Where are you getting this idea that she's fine being a compromise?
And that last line is absolute bullshit. She's not trying to figure anything out. She's throwing some slight slander at me. If she has read a single one of my posts, she'd have the answer. She wasn't reading though. She wasn't trying to understand. She was just trying to make people think I was scummy without actually doing or committing to anything.
Part Six: mastin takes the bait hook, line, and sinker
Yeah you're a sucker for buddying. You know why her thoughts seem largely along yours?
It's 'cause they are
. You were defending her and finally accepting the little foundation she was setting against me. Of course she is going to support you and say that I'm ignoring what you're saying and blah de blah blah. And as for the generic platitude that is 'people only do that when they have nothing to say'... please. Anyone can spew that trash. She didn't actually say anything new in that post. She just decided to buddy the shit out of you.
You're being hypocritical. Also you're still making up stuff and reading things that don't exist in the post. She does not--I repeat
she does not
--point out that she's doing the same thing. Instead she ignores that fact that I've been looking at other players, including (very obviously) shos whose wagon I had JUST gotten off of, and makes me look like a some heartless, scummy asshole cruelly trying to force a lurker lynch against poor little her. Nevermind the fact that she never even gave a reason as to why she was lurking so bad, nor would I really expect her to, just look at how much of that is made up or a misrepresentation of the facts. You're reading town motivation and town thought processes that again aren't there and are just reading that how you would expect it to be written if you were town in her position. Once more for good measure
she does not acknowledge that she is doing the same
.
I had given reads on other players long before this point, but whatever. Those aren't reads on GG or elle. That's literally just her giving an explanation as to why she's bitching me out instead of them. This could of course come from scum, especially scum that doesn't want to fight a multifront battle.
I can't believe you're falling for this. She's buddying you because you're the only player standing up for her. Of course that statement resonates with you: it's what anyone would think if they were getting buddied as hard as she was buddying you. Buddying is not a town tell. Not even buddying you. I see scum posting this. Definitely. In fact I would only expect town to post this once in a blue moon. She's not contributing to scum hunting; she's just giving you good feels towards her. Also you have no way of knowing that's legitimate paranoia. You're again making that up.
Part Seven: Tiredness a town tell?
I'm just gonna say you're wrong. That was applied as an AtE. So yeah. You're again reading things that aren't there.
tl;dr: Mae crumbed that she was scum back in 23
Just read the wall. It's that hard
mastin's town case for Mae boils down to her buddying him and him reading his own perspective in her posts and projecting what he would do as town in her actions. There isn't a shred of actual evidence in there, in fact most 'evidence' is false, made up, or just plain wrong.
There's still nothing to really indicate Mae town, so I'm still totally down with lynching Ghostlin.
