Mafiascum.net

In post 336, Aubrey wrote:

In post 329, oddmusic wrote:
Transcend is probably town folks. Annoying town, but still town. And there might even be a method to his madness.

Sell me on this. Cause just looking at this sentence makes me think your town reading him just cause he is active.

Transcend has been very transparent with his thought process in a way that feels very town to me right now. I think Transcend has been overstating his cases to put pressure on people. He did this with SAJ, MDS and sad. The thing is, he backed off of all of those guys once they responded to pressure in a way he saw as towny…at least that's my take on what he's been doing. That strikes me as something town would do, whereas scum would probably have stuck his vote on SAJ or sad and not been flexible.

Look, I don't actually have any 100% reads town or scum. So I could be wrong. And I really don't get his case you you. But Transcend looks town to me right now.

I don't like tojam pushing the Transcend wagon right now. Maybe it's just because I'm townreading Transcend right now, but he feels like exactly the kind of player that scum would push for a mislynch.

In fact, VOTE: tojam

Ari's on V/LA so my vote's basically doing nothing stuck on him.

In post 345, tojam2 wrote: Aubrey I can't say I remember many of your posts.

...Then maybe you should read my ISO?

In post 349, doomfeathers wrote:

In post 348, tojam2 wrote:@doom, we have 3 scum to find, I never claimed to be remotely good at mafia so if you think my content is useless then you can ask Io to replace me.

Actually, that's just what you're doing. You're voting Transcend because of playstyle, not scumminess. By your logic, why not ask to have him replaced instead of voting him?

FOS tojam2

^

In post 341, Aubrey wrote:

In post 338, sad1492 wrote:Burger isn't even putting effort into his/her posts.
Also the more I reread the more I realize MariaR is more likely scum protecting townie. Creature says that Transcend is good as scum. Assume that is correct, then MariaR should know that as well, and it is unlikely she'll protect him.

Seems like you and burger hold similar ideas though, so shouldn't that be a plus in your eyes since the both of you scumread Maria?

In post 342, sad1492 wrote:nah. In fact as scum wouldn't it be likely for people to cling onto existing suspects?

I'm confused by this. Are you saying Burger is clinging onto an existing suspect while you are doing the exact same thing here?

Alright, i am convinced that i read Transcend wrong, i am removing my vote from him. UNVOTE:

If i look at my new perspective on Transcend as town then that makes Maria look very town to me and makee tojam look like a scum.

VOTE: tojam

In post 338, sad1492 wrote:Burger isn't even putting effort into his/her posts.
Also the more I reread the more I realize MariaR is more likely scum protecting townie. Creature says that Transcend is good as scum. Assume that is correct, then MariaR should know that as well, and it is unlikely she'll protect him.

yeah im busy, hoping to put more effort into the game by next week.
at least i gave a few reads/thoughts

In post 346, doomfeathers wrote:

In post 344, tojam2 wrote:VOTE: Transcend
I can't put up with another 3 months worth of s***posting, I thought I'd seen the end of it but NO, Transcend comes back to haunt me AGAIN.

I'm not sure whether tojam is scum, but he's not playing very well toward the town win condition.

i think hes town.
i can see the way hes thinking bc transcend is a great lynch in terms of a liability lynch as he posts a lot of useless filler
but i am of the idea that lynching scum is better than lynching a liability.

In post 350, oddmusic wrote:

In post 336, Aubrey wrote:

In post 329, oddmusic wrote:
Transcend is probably town folks. Annoying town, but still town. And there might even be a method to his madness.

Sell me on this. Cause just looking at this sentence makes me think your town reading him just cause he is active.

Transcend has been very transparent with his thought process in a way that feels very town to me right now. I think Transcend has been overstating his cases to put pressure on people. He did this with SAJ, MDS and sad. The thing is, he backed off of all of those guys once they responded to pressure in a way he saw as towny…at least that's my take on what he's been doing. That strikes me as something town would do, whereas scum would probably have stuck his vote on SAJ or sad and not been flexible.

Look, I don't actually have any 100% reads town or scum. So I could be wrong. And I really don't get his case you you. But Transcend looks town to me right now.

really bad read and i disagree with everything u said. everything u said he did, could have been done by scum easily without effort.

but that being said, i think the way u were thinking about his thought process is pretty towny

town: creature, tojam2, oddmusic
scum: mariaR

In post 359, Burgerking wrote:town: creature, tojam2, oddmusic
scum: mariaR

Sell me on Mariar scum and Tojam town.

Not so confident on town!tojam2 as my other reads, but I feel better about him than people like Burgerking, Transcend, MariaR, Aubrey and Aristophanes.

Hi again. <3 Missed me?

What's with the townreads on Burgerking and tojam2? Literally haven't seen anything from them so far that stands out as town. Also why is MariaR scum?


Is your sucpicion on Creature just because of the 'fake meta', or is it more than that? What about Ari and Aubrey?


I think I agree with pretty much all of your reads, except the mason part. I didn't find it all that scummy to be totally honest.

In case you're still wondering about my hammer statement that made you nervous, I was hypothetically given the choice to hammer one of 3 people, all of whom I had null reads on. I just picked the one whose flip I felt would give town the most information. I don't usually do "information lynches" like that unless I'm all out of options. Feel free to review my other game where I died as town and you'll see I said pretty much the same thing there (except about a vig shot).


Agree about Burger, but why did you just question Transcend's read on MariaR, then proceeded to produce the exact same read literally in your next post? I don't get why she's "scum protecting a townie". She was just derailing a misguided wagon on her friend. You're overanalysing it and I don't like that.


I completely echo your sentiment about Transcend's uhh "shitposting" but I don't really think he's scum. At least I think his reactions are genuine. I just don't think he's making the game any easier for the village.

Why would we ask for you to be replaced just because you're "bad at mafia"? I don't think replacement works that way. Besides I don't think any of us are super mega brilliant at mafia. We're just here to have fun and do our best. (Speaking of which, why didn't you follow that logic and ask to replace Transcend? I would do that in a heartbeat if I thought I could.)

Omg, just saw doom asked you literally the same question. Great minds, etc. etc.

Tojam, please let us know when you're fully caught up.



Oh so we're voting tojam now? Interesting. Can't say I super disagree, but that wagon caught on quick. Speedy wagons always make me uneasy. Call it motion sickness.

At the moment I'm slightly suspecting that sad1492 and MariaR could be scum distancing from each other. Mostly intutition, but I don't like that sad's last page and I don't like that MariaR hasn't really engaged with the game other than to argue with others about herself. I'll wait to see how that develops.

Could you please link Transcend's scum game you were meta'ing him with? I'd like to look into it, too.

Um, , I think you owe us a little explanation on those reads. Especially the tojam2 town read.

Burger is correct

Tojam is town

Why is tojam town? Why didn't either of you say anything to the people voting tojam right now?

None of my 3 fos's are getting lynched?
Off to lurking I go.

Because he has a green pm

You know what, I'm not even going to bother with you anymore.

Ite

Burger is also town

I'll be V/LA until Monday. Thank you.

Actually, I am having a feeling that some of my townreads are actually NAI.

Odd bk burger creature tojam sad lock town

Mini prob town

Aris I'm feeling gut town

Saj prob town

Aubrey scum

MariaR scum

Third guess for scum is doomfeathers but irdk.