Mafiascum.net

Certainly leave TPG out.

It's TGP + {Buj, Pine}
discuss

In post 351, the worst wrote:It's TGP + {Buj, Pine}
discuss

I think it’s TGP and BuJ. Period.

Okay. I think we put all our eggs in one basket.

I’m ready to bet the game on Brie and TW being Town.

I volunteer to be left behind for this mission.

The question is Iconeum.

If Ico is scum I'll be pretty sad.

If Buj is scum, as you say, then Icon has to be town.

But just thinking, scum!tpg obviously choose his team for a reason. Was it to attempt to clear one of Buj or Icon?
O was he just going with Pine's suggestion because it was easy?

Well, scum!TGP chose the team as he did because there was a threat of veto if he did anything else. Plus he had scum on the team, so why object?

In post 356, Pine wrote:Well, scum!TGP chose the team as he did because there was a threat of veto if he did anything else. Plus he had scum on the team, so why object?

The odd thing was that TW agreed to it despite not previously wanting anything to do with TPG.

Not thatI'm trying to shade TW or anything. I'm just saying there was quite a reasonable chance of it not passing.

Information-hunting is like that. It's why I took BuJ with me N1.

Mmm. Anyway, we're now in a tight spot. Iconeum had better show up and add his thoughts to the discussion.

Info hunting doesn't ignore the first mission pass.


There are three options the least likely of which is pine picking his own buddy and then not failing the mission because he sacrifices a point and wastes an opportunity to get his buddy towncred. Town would be inclined to believe 1 scum among us.

So the likely options are 2 towns or 1T 1 S.
You repeat both or one of us because you want to which it is. You can methodically repeat 1 or 2 players from each mission to test out different theories.

Ie if pine/me/x went on misdion 2 and it passed there is a very big chance all 3 are town.

If you take pine/x/y and leave me out and the mission fails you can then do x/y/me. If it fails the most likely scenario is that x/y contains scum.

Now you can do pine/me/x or pine/me/y to find out which of them it was.

Yes there is always a margin of error but that's where the votes would guide you. A townie that isn't chosen in mission 2 has no reason to approve it. So if the mission fails it softly indicates all 3 chosen were town. Likewise if someone on a later mission approves a mission that doesn't include him it could indicate their partner is in it. Another clue is if a person chosen for a mission doesn't vote for it. Because scum in most cases would only vote no for a mission they are chosen for if their partner is in it. So it makes it either a town claim or 2 spies are in the proposed team.

In post 351, the worst wrote:It's TGP + {Buj, Pine}
discuss

My quick thoughts here:

I'm MOST LIKELY going with myself/brie/bujaber here. If Buj is scum, then gg wp.

The last mission will include the worst.

Yes/no?

Both scum in the worst/Pine/TGP.

With 100% 1 in TGP/the worst.

Feeling either TGP/the worst as a team, OR TGP/Pine.

This is solved by choosing my team of Buj, Ico, Brie now (and Pine will accept this I think), and we can add the worst/MAAAYYYBE Pine in last mission.

If we get there

I'm good with this

betting the game on Buj being scum over Pine?

Buj being town over Pine rather

Jfc I'm transparent

See TW this is why I keep having second thoughts about you .. how am I not obviously town relative to pine?

that was a question for tehbrie and ico

Hmm, it seems to me that there's quite a reasonable chance of scum not sabotaging the first mission. At least if there's only one on the mission. Because if the first mission fails, we get fairly specific information.

Mission two a townie might vote if they felt confident about who was on it, but that probably won't happen?

Bu, that's all about how we should have played and not information especially relevant to the current game, right?

(later, after doing important other stuff)

Which question is for me?

I know I'm town
You.know I'm town
I know that you know I'm town
But THEY don't know that I know you know I'm town y'know?

Tier reads for me Brie?

I'm more inclined to believe Buj is town that Pine. So yes. We have to bet something. I'd actually be willing to take you, but it's not my desicion, and I can push that next round. (Do I pick next?)

Tier:
Brie
Iconeum,
Bujuber, TW
Pine
Scummiest scum
TGP

the worst wrote:I know I'm town
You.know I'm town
I know that you know I'm town
But THEY don't know that I know you know I'm town y'know?

Are you trying to confuse me?
I haven't figured out exactly who THEY are and I've thought about it for half a minute now.

ya we got an OK info round out of the scum mission so now we wind things up with the towniest 2 players as leaders

it's buj next then you
we do what we must