Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:51 pm
whyu
Page 15 of 130
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:51 pm
this is not a reason btwIn post 303, DrDolittle wrote:Ok so I'm pretty sure A50 is town. You don't pull blatantly crappy reads like this from scumIn post 297, Almost50 wrote:Seph is a strong TR because he is actually providing some content and even a full read list already. I wanted to poke him in the nose for the messed up vote, but then felt other players won't understand and might think it a distraction, so I held myself back.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:52 pm
gamma's not reading tonight and its a cause for concern
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:52 pm
no, just thought it was a funny criticism considering the level of certainty a lot of regulars on this site exude when it comes to early game reads
when I have a strong early game read they tend to be right. When I become confident on a read, I tend to remain confident on that read, unless I have a good reason to re-evaluate. So far I have not had one
when I have a strong early game read they tend to be right. When I become confident on a read, I tend to remain confident on that read, unless I have a good reason to re-evaluate. So far I have not had one
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:54 pm
I trust you won't take offense if I call you crown prince Akeem Joffer, will you?In post 337, DrDolittle wrote:PS its not the bear avi - I'm the dude and the bear is supporting cast, if that's unclear. but i don't mind if you continue bearavi-ing.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:54 pm
Not reading whatIn post 352, DrDolittle wrote:gamma's not reading tonight and its a cause for concern
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:54 pm
are your strong early game read typically town readsIn post 353, DVa wrote:when I have a strong early game read they tend to be right
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:55 pm
no you're just giving me more eddie murphy movies to watch and its amazingIn post 354, Almost50 wrote:I trust you won't take offense if I call you crown prince Akeem Joffer, will you?In post 337, DrDolittle wrote:PS its not the bear avi - I'm the dude and the bear is supporting cast, if that's unclear. but i don't mind if you continue bearavi-ing.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:55 pm
yeah, this guy is going to be annoyingIn post 349, OkaPoka wrote:very presumptuous
my read is "very presumptuous"
like you're not making me want to engage you even though you're still probably town
I liked someone enough to sheep their vote to generate pressure and help get the game going -- that's not presumptuous, it's called playing the game bro
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:56 pm
Dva can you elaborate about puffyfish imploding when pressurized
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:56 pm
So, what do you suggest? Leave him alone? I'm open to other options if they are going to lead to something productive.In post 344, DVa wrote:A50, I mean the thing is I don't disagree
I guess now I'm less certain a pressure wagon on that particular player will lead to 'good' results for the town
cause he seems to implode as either alignment under pressure
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:57 pm
the thread.In post 355, Gamma Emerald wrote:Not reading whatIn post 352, DrDolittle wrote:gamma's not reading tonight and its a cause for concern
two examples:
first: you had no idea what Dva was talking about in her job hunt 30 pages cut 6
second: you quoted my two FakeGod examples even after I said it was a joke.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:57 pm
Have I not provided reasoning? You even commented on it.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:58 pm
In post 351, DrDolittle wrote:this is not a reason btwIn post 303, DrDolittle wrote:Ok so I'm pretty sure A50 is town. You don't pull blatantly crappy reads like this from scumIn post 297, Almost50 wrote:Seph is a strong TR because he is actually providing some content and even a full read list already. I wanted to poke him in the nose for the messed up vote, but then felt other players won't understand and might think it a distraction, so I held myself back.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:59 pm
First: that was completely off topic so it was odd?
Second: I read the thread linearly most of the time. As such I didn’t see it was a joke when I posted that. And I took the time to click the links, so your shade is undermined.
Second: I read the thread linearly most of the time. As such I didn’t see it was a joke when I posted that. And I took the time to click the links, so your shade is undermined.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 5:59 pm
I say I strong TR him for this and you tell me it's not a reason? I've just finished playing a game with the dude. I mean, he himself admits to being good at scum, but I have seen nothing to make me feel he's being deceptive at any rate so far in here.In post 351, DrDolittle wrote:this is not a reason btwIn post 303, DrDolittle wrote:Ok so I'm pretty sure A50 is town. You don't pull blatantly crappy reads like this from scumIn post 297, Almost50 wrote:Seph is a strong TR because he is actually providing some content and even a full read list already. I wanted to poke him in the nose for the messed up vote, but then felt other players won't understand and might think it a distraction, so I held myself back.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 6:00 pm
Would recommend a kokichi vote to all undecided people, just check his iso to see if he has any desire to find scum.
Why is this scum behavior?
Because as town we really have two options to play, create information or analyze the information given to us. After all, we have no information to work with so we have to make use with what we have got. There is no sense of desire in kokichi's post to actually play the game in finding mafia, nor is there any activity indicating that he wants to create a healthier environment with more info for everyone else to work with. Leading me to the conclusion that he is my definition of a liability, he does not share the motivations all townies share, rather he is just making pointless conversation and probably hoping that his small talk can carry him a certain distance. Wouldn't be surprised if he hopped onto a wagon soon however, he needs to eventually give the appearance of him playing the game.
@Dva, locking in townreads day 1 for weakass reasons is how you lose games. People like to say they reevaluate all the time, but usually that doesn't happen until lylo. Until I can see evidence of you constantly reevaluating, I have no reason to trust that you will reread in an unbiased manner. Your either damaging town with your cocky attitude or your just buddying in so you can lock yourself into a very simple position to play as scum so you can fend off pressure easily. You can remove my suspicion if you give more solid reasons as to why Nako is doing things that scum is incapable of, but so far all your reasoning can be easily done as scum, its nothing out of the ordinary.
Why is this scum behavior?
Because as town we really have two options to play, create information or analyze the information given to us. After all, we have no information to work with so we have to make use with what we have got. There is no sense of desire in kokichi's post to actually play the game in finding mafia, nor is there any activity indicating that he wants to create a healthier environment with more info for everyone else to work with. Leading me to the conclusion that he is my definition of a liability, he does not share the motivations all townies share, rather he is just making pointless conversation and probably hoping that his small talk can carry him a certain distance. Wouldn't be surprised if he hopped onto a wagon soon however, he needs to eventually give the appearance of him playing the game.
@Dva, locking in townreads day 1 for weakass reasons is how you lose games. People like to say they reevaluate all the time, but usually that doesn't happen until lylo. Until I can see evidence of you constantly reevaluating, I have no reason to trust that you will reread in an unbiased manner. Your either damaging town with your cocky attitude or your just buddying in so you can lock yourself into a very simple position to play as scum so you can fend off pressure easily. You can remove my suspicion if you give more solid reasons as to why Nako is doing things that scum is incapable of, but so far all your reasoning can be easily done as scum, its nothing out of the ordinary.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 6:01 pm
unfortunately I can't without breaking the spirit of site rules. I can just say, as a general statement, that you can investigate on your own if you desire, that he tends to implode under pressureIn post 359, Joey_ wrote:Dva can you elaborate about puffyfish imploding when pressurized
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 6:02 pm
I can relate. Often enough though they replace out and the new comer manages to sway my opinion and I end up feeling like I should be included in Dumb and Dumber IV as a guest star postgame.In post 353, DVa wrote:when I have a strong early game read they tend to be right.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 6:04 pm
answer this question please, am interested in how you playIn post 356, DrDolittle wrote:are your strong early game read typically town readsIn post 353, DVa wrote:when I have a strong early game read they tend to be right
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 6:04 pm
1 - if its odd, you can quote many of the posts where dva and joey were banteringIn post 364, Gamma Emerald wrote:First: that was completely off topic so it was odd?
Second: I read the thread linearly most of the time. As such I didn’t see it was a joke when I posted that. And I took the time to click the links, so your shade is undermined.
2 - im wrong on that front and it does seem like a linear reading starting from 284
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 6:06 pm
1 not doing anything deceptive != your strongest town read.In post 365, Almost50 wrote:I say I strong TR him for this and you tell me it's not a reason? I've just finished playing a game with the dude. I mean, he himself admits to being good at scum, but I have seen nothing to make me feel he's being deceptive at any rate so far in here.In post 351, DrDolittle wrote:this is not a reason btwIn post 303, DrDolittle wrote:Ok so I'm pretty sure A50 is town. You don't pull blatantly crappy reads like this from scumIn post 297, Almost50 wrote:Seph is a strong TR because he is actually providing some content and even a full read list already. I wanted to poke him in the nose for the messed up vote, but then felt other players won't understand and might think it a distraction, so I held myself back.
2 unless you think seph-scum is blatant on not providing content early game, your strongest town read is also unjustified. + that would make him a shitty scum player.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 6:07 pm
whoo any hour+ hanging out with my mafia friends. its been fun but I gotta sleep.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 6:07 pm
Koki hasn't exactly posted since the RVS phase ended btw. Also hes a much better player than you give him credit for, there's a reason why A50 and myself aren't outing reads on the guy as of yet, because he gets much easier to read the more you give him time. His alignment will be pretty transparent when town will need to vote correctlyIn post 366, OkaPoka wrote:Would recommend a kokichi vote to all undecided people, just check his iso to see if he has any desire to find scum.
Why is this scum behavior?
Because as town we really have two options to play, create information or analyze the information given to us. After all, we have no information to work with so we have to make use with what we have got. There is no sense of desire in kokichi's post to actually play the game in finding mafia, nor is there any activity indicating that he wants to create a healthier environment with more info for everyone else to work with. Leading me to the conclusion that he is my definition of a liability, he does not share the motivations all townies share, rather he is just making pointless conversation and probably hoping that his small talk can carry him a certain distance. Wouldn't be surprised if he hopped onto a wagon soon however, he needs to eventually give the appearance of him playing the game.
@Dva, locking in townreads day 1 for weakass reasons is how you lose games. People like to say they reevaluate all the time, but usually that doesn't happen until lylo. Until I can see evidence of you constantly reevaluating, I have no reason to trust that you will reread in an unbiased manner. Your either damaging town with your cocky attitude or your just buddying in so you can lock yourself into a very simple position to play as scum so you can fend off pressure easily. You can remove my suspicion if you give more solid reasons as to why Nako is doing things that scum is incapable of, but so far all your reasoning can be easily done as scum, its nothing out of the ordinary.
Posted: Wed Oct 31, 2018 6:07 pm
Gamma has made 41 posts and none of them seem to be of substantial value or content. He's engaging in a lot of pointless conversation that don't lead anywhere, but he's obviously reading the thread as he is responding to questions directed at him. His lack of actually doing something of importance makes me think active lurking? What's your gameplan gamma.