In post 208, Binary Star wrote:You've certainly got into your groove now. I'm wary about town reading you, since you have a good scum game and your slow-roll start was out of kilter with what I expect from town you. I know that if your scum, that's probably the only chance you'll give me to catch you.
-B
If he's scum, at least he's scum that's trying to move the game forward. Let's go after scum that's done nothing.
VOTE: Chickadee
-Y
Why this slot in particular
There are several do-nothing slots
Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 12:40 pm
by Binary Star
I don't see the case for Chick as scum and I'm not happy with how the wagon's developed/sat while Chickadee hasn't really done anything under the pressure as far as I can tell.
Like I appreciate the initiative, but the result seems more to have shown the willingness of others to latch on rather than getting a reaction from the original suspect.
Anyway, Dannflor, what are you doing to figure out and solve the game?
In post 208, Binary Star wrote:You've certainly got into your groove now. I'm wary about town reading you, since you have a good scum game and your slow-roll start was out of kilter with what I expect from town you. I know that if your scum, that's probably the only chance you'll give me to catch you.
-B
If he's scum, at least he's scum that's trying to move the game forward. Let's go after scum that's done nothing.
In post 208, Binary Star wrote:You've certainly got into your groove now. I'm wary about town reading you, since you have a good scum game and your slow-roll start was out of kilter with what I expect from town you. I know that if your scum, that's probably the only chance you'll give me to catch you.
-B
If he's scum, at least he's scum that's trying to move the game forward. Let's go after scum that's done nothing.
In post 247, Chickadee wrote:If I die today, pay attention to all the flimsy jumps on this wagon.
And... What?
You've got a wagon on you and you've noticed some "flimsy jumps" but you're absolutely refusing to study those slots a little closer and even try to scumhunt.
Why would we be fools for lynching you, a slot that's done little to scumhunt? Who *should* we lynch, and why?
And I'm trying to understand what it says about your alignment that my fakehammer was pretty blatant and like, 5 posts away from the VC, but you responded like it was legit.
-The Joker
AA comes off as town here. Chickadee's response to this isn't great but I think scum gives slightly more of a fuck here
I think AA is the less town of the two big hydras - with FL throwing out the idea that one of the hydras is scum and with the two accounts taking up most of the game real estate I feel like people are gravitating towards scum reading AA without too much good reason
imo both hydras can just be town
Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 12:50 pm
by Dannflor
VOTE: ZZZX
@zzzx, what exactly is confusing to you about this about this game?
Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 12:53 pm
by Dannflor
In post 353, Binary Star wrote:I don't see the case for Chick as scum and I'm not happy with how the wagon's developed/sat while Chickadee hasn't really done anything under the pressure as far as I can tell.
Like I appreciate the initiative, but the result seems more to have shown the willingness of others to latch on rather than getting a reaction from the original suspect.
Anyway, Dannflor, what are you doing to figure out and solve the game?
-White
I think I agree on Chickadee
re: the bolded
I would appreciate if you voted or or more directly pushed me instead of passive aggressively questioning me in a way that I don't think helps you sort me
In post 1, Jingle wrote:2. Living players must post in this thread at least once every 48 hours during the day phase.
3. Dead players must communicate with me or post in the Dead thread (their choice) once every 72 hours.
In post 79, Dr Easy Bake wrote:For all the people that don’t know me, let me get this out of the way.
When in regards to my posts, the norm would be described as:
Spoiler:
slightly don't like the % of your iso that has become you defending yourself fluffposting
In post 333, Arkham Asylum wrote:Egix96
Binary Star
Chemist1422
CheekyTeeky
Chickadee
NerfedBuJ
mastina
Flavor Leaf
Pine
ZZZX
Dannflor
Dr Easy Bake
VOTE: Dr Easy Bake
~ Poison Ivy
cheeky too high, chika too high, buj maybe goes up a touch, mastina goes lower, boon up a lot, think scumreading deb for having an iso of pure fluff is risky, ivy
Maybe it wasn't as strong as here but I remember not really getting the scumreads on you in Overkill 2 and then you just sorta flipped scum and I was like "oh okay then"
The part I don't like about him was the way he interacted with Chemist1422 at the beginning of the game and the way he hopped onto the Chickadee wagon. Incidentally, those are the only two points that he has actual non-fluff content, which is really quite interesting when you think about it.
~ Poison Ivy
I was spamming Sanic memes, and I voted for Chickadee because they were a cannibal in their avatar. How were these not fluff? I’m never not fluffing.
The timing of the pop ins themselves just feel weird instead of like, actually hopping on the wagon
It just feels like a way to blend into the rapid wagon building without actually contributing or doing anything
Except not only did I not join the wagon, I later did a gut check on her and declared a TR on her. It helps to consider the whole context before making broad and flexible statements like "this is weird."
I tend to coast D1 if nothing catches my eye. Nothing really has yet. I tend to play the midgame.
Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 3:58 pm
by Dr Easy Bake
That big ass Arkham post is way too long, scummy vibes from long posts for sure.
Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 4:00 pm
by Pine
In post 370, Dr Easy Bake wrote:That big ass Arkham post is way too long, scummy vibes from long posts for sure.
Yeah, this post pings me. That long post was one of the only things I've liked out of AA, and your objection is "too much content?"
In post 370, Dr Easy Bake wrote:That big ass Arkham post is way too long, scummy vibes from long posts for sure.
Yeah, this post pings me. That long post was one of the only things I've liked out of AA, and your objection is "too much content?"
Yes, long posts are an easy way to be like, hey I couldn’t be scum, scum wouldn’t put this much effort into a post like this. I get the desire to add content but that was a damn manuscript.
Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 4:51 pm
by Dannflor
In post 369, Pine wrote:Except not only did I not join the wagon, I later did a gut check on her and declared a TR on her. It helps to consider the whole context before making broad and flexible statements like "this is weird."
I did find your later posts considering the wagon better than I found your earlier posts
That was just my gut reaction to seeing those posts upon catching up
In post 370, Dr Easy Bake wrote:That big ass Arkham post is way too long, scummy vibes from long posts for sure.
Yeah, this post pings me. That long post was one of the only things I've liked out of AA, and your objection is "too much content?"
Yes, long posts are an easy way to be like, hey I couldn’t be scum, scum wouldn’t put this much effort into a post like this. I get the desire to add content but that was a damn manuscript.
maybe read the content and decide whether the actual content is scummy or not in and of itself?
