Posted: Mon Feb 10, 2020 5:04 pm
Your reading of the Ame situation seems to reflect my own.
https://forum.mafiascum-staging.net/
In post 67, Luca Blight wrote:Welcome dsjstr, but damn I’m disappointed creative left. Was looking forward to playing with them.
How were my RQS answers?In post 346, Ame wrote:Are y'all just like coldhearted mafia consumers? To me, mafia is a social game, and I enjoy making friends in the process.
Because once you make him aware it might be a townslip, it would obviously influence his answer (especially if he is scum).In post 356, Hectic wrote:Why does it lose meaning? I asking the question because I think it has potential to be a townslip, but I wanna check.
It seems that you misinterpreted my read's intention. Common sense, in this context, are suggestively basic attitudes or actions, with simple reasoning based on evidence or a series of information that, when linked, form a certain conclusion that is beyond the reach of possible scums, being more easily performed by towns, precisely for the intuitive behavioral authenticity, which I used to subjectively evaluate the set of posts I quoted about you. Evidently, when a fragment is separated from them, it is not possible, however, to understand the general meaning, therefore, isolating post 67 the way it was done in this post is something that significantly distances it from the proper interpretation and, consequently, contributed to the structuring of a line of thought that fits me, obviously, as extreme scum from your point of view. Possibly the two games we played in, had a greater impact on your decision making about my possible alignment placement here, if we do not consider my distance from the beginning of the game. This is problematic, considering that you are locktown to me, even though you are mistaken in most of your considerations. I believe that an approach to this, imagining myself in your place, will not be effective in changing your opinion, so I will probably be ignoring you in this game.In post 352, Luca Blight wrote:250 - I don't really get why Clidd has me as lock town for the posts he linked. Why would you TR someone for common sense?
And how is the post below common sense or even town-indicative?
In post 67, Luca Blight wrote:Welcome dsjstr, but damn I’m disappointed creative left. Was looking forward to playing with them.
I already touched on this but this is most likely a town post because scum wouldn't even care to assume such a stance. They are much more likely to base cases on inconsistency due to the nature of the game, a town is much more likely to get pissed at this push from someone else onto them as it can feel opportunistic. I don't think Wimpy fakes this as scum.In post 300, Wimpy wrote:Cause she used my v/la as a reason to vote. Every time somebody does that I will death tunnel their ass.In post 294, Hectic wrote:Ame's Flippo read on page 5 was a good catch. Not liking Wimpo's vote there. You voting here there because you think she's scum, or because you think she's lying about realising you were V/LA? Stupid thing to lie about.
Why would she push a V/LA slot as scum if she knows she's not gaining anything from it? It's like talking to a brick wall and it's essentially wasting your time, all the while not achieving anything. I just don't see an agenda behind her push on you. Might be biased because I read her slot town but please reconsider and don't make this an unnecessary thunderdome, nobody wants to sit through this negative energy day one, it's snowballing scum to an easy team due to the apathy that's being created.In post 301, Wimpy wrote:So to better answer your question. No I don’t think she lied. I think she actually thought that was an acceptable strategy and it’s not.
I don’t care if she didn’t realize it was Sunday. Even if it had been Monday, that’s when I would have just been getting back.
It’s a low life despicable reason to vote for somebody and to me that means she’s scum or a low life despicable player who thinks that it’s ok to vote somebody who’s v/la.
Either way. I don’t give a damn. I am unable to look past it. I definitely will never be able to town read this slot so the best thing to do is to get rid of her. She’s shown poor judgement and is incapable of helping town win.
Not really liking this post, mainly because what possibly could've been conveyed in the thread that gives off the feeling of 3 scum? It feels more like an attempt at fake-derping rather than actual derping. Clidd, how'd you come to that conclusion? Do you have a lot of scum leans or?In post 308, clidd wrote:I'm considering the scenario where there are 3 scums, because of what I've read so far.
I like this post, not sure this PoV comes from mafia either. Feeling as though scum would just deliberately choose to push someone for their in-game content rather than just choose to compare them to another player's style, I have yet to see wolves take this approach, surprisingly. it's like trying to justify a gut feeling, all the while not being able to properly put the finger on the "why", so they choose to do it by comparing it to another player, whereas scum wouldn't even bother to make such points, hope that makes some sense.In post 316, clidd wrote:Do you know the player TSE ? (TrueSoulEnergy) I am feeling something similar with your playstyle (scum indicative).In post 313, Wimpy wrote:Best way to play as scum is to play how you would as townIn post 312, clidd wrote:Because he wouldn't say this as scum. We played a game together, and he's acting the same way (he was town that game).
Don't really like this post, I don't think it accomplishes anything and is just trying to paint Ame scummy. After I sifted through this post, i think the mentality behind it is luca "scum reading" ame and trying to paint her scummy, rather than trying to deduce her alignment here, with that leading question. What is ame even supposed to answer to that?In post 337, Luca Blight wrote:Just catching up now...
Why did you wait for Insomnia to get on-board with your Flippy SR before voting yourself?In post 190, Ame wrote:Yes!
Vote: flippy
Also thank you for the quotes. I had actually completely missed that you had already started to consider town Aaron before you logged off.
Nope. Unfortunately I’m town but thanks for playingIn post 362, clidd wrote:Plus: Wimpy is probably scum.
Unfortunately this isn’t accurate. Regardless of alignment when people cross the line, I care and will make sure they get punished one way or another. The site mods don’t enforce rules unfortunately so I have to just make sure they die.In post 364, insomnia wrote:I already touched on this but this is most likely a town post because scum wouldn't even care to assume such a stance
We'll see.In post 367, Wimpy wrote:Nope. Unfortunately I’m town but thanks for playingIn post 362, clidd wrote:Plus: Wimpy is probably scum.
Why would she as town?In post 364, insomnia wrote:Why would she push a V/LA slot as scum
Why is it a violation ? everyone has the right to play.In post 371, Wimpy wrote:Why would she as town?In post 364, insomnia wrote:Why would she push a V/LA slot as scum
How about I just see the act as disgusting and technically a violation of site rules and because of that she doesn’t deserve to play. I personally scum read the act. If nobody else does that’s fine.