Mafiascum.net

And yes I totally avoided Vivax and Andante's ISOs because I do not want to deal with that right now.

In post 320, Enchant wrote:FancyPants* - lurk idk
Vivax - troll town
MalcolmTucker - prob maf
Greeting - idk always failed at reading
Firebringer - hot null would't care to vote
Fredrick A Campbell - can afford to die
Dwlee99* - lurk
Crescent - eh idk
Lowell - prob town
bugspray - always failed at reading
PookyTheMagicalBear - always mafia
geraintm - prob maf
UNOwen - idk i started yawning at this guy, pretend that's there's something funny drawn at next 3 persons and i call it a day, too much effort for me
Prince of Paterson
Andante
MegAzumarill

VOTE: Enchant
When has Enchant ever made a reads list

In post 345, Crescent wrote:Fire's only effective content i

i would argue my vote isn't even content

In post 349, Crescent wrote:but there's absolutely no fire.

im right here

In post 344, FancyPants wrote:

In post 334, MegAzumarill wrote:

In post 330, FancyPants wrote:

In post 329, Firebringer wrote:if i had more to say on crescent i would say it. I just read her posts and was like "this person is someone i should look into later"

Why is azumaril wagon bad

Tonal town read on them.

If the only read you have on someone is tonal why would you think its a bad wagon.

To me this feels like tmi that I'm town.
Also dont like the MT vote.
VOTE: Fancypants

I read plenty of people based on tone alone. I find it a bit strange that you find it scummy, this clearly isn't your first game.

In post 342, Crescent wrote:Oh there were quite literally 0 posts I hadn't read either before or on this page.

..Fancypants next.

Vote on Malcom is for #261 which is.. Not a Malcolm post that scumpinged me. Comes off as arrogant like the rest of that train did, not scummy. Why did this post draw your vote?

Has now called me, Enchant, Meg, and Fred town for... No apparent reason other than "vibes" or "tone" for any of us. Do you have any play-based reasons you can point to? It feels like you're taking a bunch of simple stances without backing any of them up.

Like my tonal read on Andante was null, but I thought the wagon was awful because I thought the reasons for it were awful. What do you think of the actual reasons and votes on Meg?

I do have reasons for all my town reads.
I like Enchant's read list as it's similar to mine, I also like how they didn't even bother to finish the list, feels too IDGAF too be scum'.

Meg started too too whimsical, and I liked a couple of the questions they asked, seemed like a effort to game solve.

I didn't call Fred town, I'm actually not sure of the slot I don't like the wagon for meta reasons I can't talk about because the game is still ongoing.

As for you, I think you're genuinely tying to solve game solve.

Malcome is scum in post 261 because of how non-committal it is, he's voting but leaving himself wiggle room, its also pointless as a pressure vote, if you tell someone you aren't that positive about the vote.
In other words he wants to be on the wagon but he wants to have plausible deniability for being on the wagon.

I'd say I'm more just making clear it's still early game and a lot of players haven't posted a lot yet in the way of content - I personally think you're making too much out of this, would you rather I lied and acted as if my first D1 vote was locked in and wasn't going to change? All early votes are non-committal and subject to change because unless you decide to tunnel someone without legit reason you're going to change your beliefs on who as scum as the game progresses.

My train of thought is pretty consistent - Andante has been attacking other players for a lack of in-game content and for spamming, but in the process ironically had an identical ISO which largely ignored in-game content. I found that hypocritical, potentially scummy, and worthy of a vote. If I think someone else is a better vote - which is perfectly possible - I will move my vote, because it's the first day and some players haven't said much yet.

In post 336, MegAzumarill wrote:too much information

This feels just about the right level of information

In post 336, MegAzumarill wrote:too much information

In post 343, Crescent wrote:Fred's ISO kinda just makes me want to punch him, but that just appears to be his thing. "Neat."

I'd like to hear some reasoning behind why people are townreading Enchant, because I feel like they've gotten a few random casual town reads and this ISO is almost void of actual content.

Malcolm's new stuff is just post #321.. Which just leads me right into Gera's ISO.

I find it confusing that he votes for absolutely no reason, and later calls attention to the fact that he voted for no given reason... Then shades Enchant for doing the same thing with essentially no justification, but remains on Fred anyway for.. No justification. I want him to walk me through his thought process here.

I had a reason

Did a read through. Until now I was on my phone and bluffing, ignore whatever thoughts I had then and take these as real:

4- pooky claims town (I'm buying it, seems like a weird scum move)
20, 21- Meg speculates on roles on and tries to start a battle over nothing (scummy)
30- greeting "jokingly" justifies random vote (scummy)
40, 42- Fred calls vivax town (scummy white-knighting)
46- Fred calls pooky town due to 4 (scummy when he does it)
51, 61, 77- Meg tries to be cute, make friends (scummy)
69- andante rants about nothing (town, doesn't look calculated that's for sure)
72- prince calls enchant town (scum, first post white-knighting?)
88- gerain enters, claims confusion, wishes for speedy death (town, I'm buying)
130- greeting calls all the active players town, two meaningless lurkers scum (scummy low-hanging-fruit chasing)
144- prince votes dwlee (scummy, essentially naked vote on a lurker)
152, 153- prince inserts himself into a fight not about himself, then asks... everyone?... to weigh in on it? (scummy as hell, looking to lead town to nowhere while looking busy)
186- geraintm naked votes leading fred wagon (I like this, fearless)
216- prince joins fred wagon, overexplains (no)
page 11- andante panics (scummy. why?)
339- fred asks me a question from post...169? (nah bruh, why now? and if anything, Fred's meta on me should be that I don't know any of you, so weird question unless one's goal is only to look busy and do nothing)
341-349- crescent spams, has no filter (I like this, not so much as content but as someone who isn't holding back opinions)

Biggest scumread that stands out to me that I didn't notice before is . Not going to derail the perfectly good wagon but if this feckless town chickens out let's do him or next. looks worse than I remember. Some likely towns are: .

In post 356, geraintm wrote:

In post 336, MegAzumarill wrote:too much information

In post 343, Crescent wrote:Fred's ISO kinda just makes me want to punch him, but that just appears to be his thing. "Neat."

I'd like to hear some reasoning behind why people are townreading Enchant, because I feel like they've gotten a few random casual town reads and this ISO is almost void of actual content.

Malcolm's new stuff is just post #321.. Which just leads me right into Gera's ISO.

I find it confusing that he votes for absolutely no reason, and later calls attention to the fact that he voted for no given reason... Then shades Enchant for doing the same thing with essentially no justification, but remains on Fred anyway for.. No justification. I want him to walk me through his thought process here.

I had a reason

...Which was?

In post 351, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 320, Enchant wrote:FancyPants* - lurk idk
Vivax - troll town
MalcolmTucker - prob maf
Greeting - idk always failed at reading
Firebringer - hot null would't care to vote
Fredrick A Campbell - can afford to die
Dwlee99* - lurk
Crescent - eh idk
Lowell - prob town
bugspray - always failed at reading
PookyTheMagicalBear - always mafia
geraintm - prob maf
UNOwen - idk i started yawning at this guy, pretend that's there's something funny drawn at next 3 persons and i call it a day, too much effort for me
Prince of Paterson
Andante
MegAzumarill

VOTE: Enchant
When has Enchant ever made a reads list

Some games are so out of the ordinary that people can do extraordinary things.
I'm telling you in the most amicable way possible that your vote sucks.

In post 360, Vivax wrote:Some games are so out of the ordinary that people can do extraordinary things.
I'm telling you in the most amicable way possible that your vote sucks.

I don't get what would make this extraordinary for enchant

In post 361, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 360, Vivax wrote:Some games are so out of the ordinary that people can do extraordinary things.
I'm telling you in the most amicable way possible that your vote sucks.

I don't get what would make this extraordinary for enchant

Then maybe you should ask them before voting for them. If you want to play mafia that is.

Is this a chainsaw

In post 363, Dwlee99 wrote:Is this a chainsaw

You'd need a read on me to guess that

In post 334, MegAzumarill wrote: If the only read you have on someone is tonal why would you think its a bad wagon.

To me this feels like tmi that I'm town.
Also dont like the MT vote.
VOTE: Fancypants

Why aren't you bothered by the wagon against you?

@Crescent

In post 320, Enchant wrote: Crescent - eh idk
Lowell - prob town

^I think this part of his read list in particular looks genuine, lazy scum would more likely have the reads flipped as easier to justify.

In post 351, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 320, Enchant wrote:FancyPants* - lurk idk
Vivax - troll town
MalcolmTucker - prob maf
Greeting - idk always failed at reading
Firebringer - hot null would't care to vote
Fredrick A Campbell - can afford to die
Dwlee99* - lurk
Crescent - eh idk
Lowell - prob town
bugspray - always failed at reading
PookyTheMagicalBear - always mafia
geraintm - prob maf
UNOwen - idk i started yawning at this guy, pretend that's there's something funny drawn at next 3 persons and i call it a day, too much effort for me
Prince of Paterson
Andante
MegAzumarill

VOTE: Enchant
When has Enchant ever made a reads list

Explain why that makes them more likely to be scum?

In post 367, Prince of Paterson wrote:

In post 351, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 320, Enchant wrote:FancyPants* - lurk idk
Vivax - troll town
MalcolmTucker - prob maf
Greeting - idk always failed at reading
Firebringer - hot null would't care to vote
Fredrick A Campbell - can afford to die
Dwlee99* - lurk
Crescent - eh idk
Lowell - prob town
bugspray - always failed at reading
PookyTheMagicalBear - always mafia
geraintm - prob maf
UNOwen - idk i started yawning at this guy, pretend that's there's something funny drawn at next 3 persons and i call it a day, too much effort for me
Prince of Paterson
Andante
MegAzumarill

VOTE: Enchant
When has Enchant ever made a reads list

Explain why that makes them more likely to be scum?

Enchant tries harder to keep up appearances as scum

Alright, that's reasonable. Do you still think Andante is town, and if so, why?

Yes and cause her tone is the same townie exasperation whatever I've experienced with her in a ton of games

In post 351, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 320, Enchant wrote:FancyPants* - lurk idk
Vivax - troll town
MalcolmTucker - prob maf
Greeting - idk always failed at reading
Firebringer - hot null would't care to vote
Fredrick A Campbell - can afford to die
Dwlee99* - lurk
Crescent - eh idk
Lowell - prob town
bugspray - always failed at reading
PookyTheMagicalBear - always mafia
geraintm - prob maf
UNOwen - idk i started yawning at this guy, pretend that's there's something funny drawn at next 3 persons and i call it a day, too much effort for me
Prince of Paterson
Andante
MegAzumarill

VOTE: Enchant
When has Enchant ever made a reads list

But i made them!

... Well mostly as mafia but whatever

In post 357, Lowell wrote:Did a read

In post 357, Lowell wrote:andante panics

hahahahahahaha

In post 320, Enchant wrote:FancyPants* - lurk idk
Vivax - troll town
MalcolmTucker - prob maf
Greeting - idk always failed at reading
Firebringer - hot null would't care to vote
Fredrick A Campbell - can afford to die
Dwlee99* - lurk
Crescent - eh idk
Lowell - prob town
bugspray - always failed at reading
PookyTheMagicalBear - always mafia
geraintm - prob maf
UNOwen - idk i started yawning at this guy, pretend that's there's something funny drawn at next 3 persons and i call it a day, too much effort for me
Prince of Paterson
Andante
MegAzumarill

what's your read on me?

In post 321, MalcolmTucker wrote:Ger tends not to do much on D1 as a general rule. Vote on Fred could be read as opportunistic and there's not much in their limited ISO so far but it's feasible from town Ger.

this feels like TMI

VOTE: Malcolm

like, ok so what gerain usually doesn't do much? you used too many words to go "gerain probably town" like, you're trying to justify a TR there, but it's actually a really bad take, cause I have a great example of scum!gerain doing nothing day 1. but going "that's feasible from town Ger" like what?? Gerain should be no where near being called town right now. I'm not saying they have to be a SR, but like, there's nothing in this game so far to push gerain into TR territory