but if you are town you shouldn't be. When we lynched the rest of the kings army and the game is still ongoing then we can talk about lynching between our groups but if a50 is telling the truth then it won't.
but if you are town you shouldn't be. When we lynched the rest of the kings army and the game is still ongoing then we can talk about lynching between our groups but if a50 is telling the truth then it won't.
I like the COMPLETE about face from yesterday
Also L-word reminder
I mean, not really. I'm pretty sure that I made a post yesterday about not eliminating you guys. I realize that you are sore but get over it guy.
Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2020 3:29 pm
by Nero Cain
In post 3203, MathBlade wrote:However 6 masons I just have a hard time seeing approved
there are not 6 masons. There are 2 3p groups that are confirmed to themselves but not each other. In my personal opinion its kinda iffy design to make a 3p that wins exclusively with town is a bit silly but whatever.
I feel like you and april and whomever pushing us has a good chance of being scum b/c hunting 3p is a pro-scum move.
with 23 alive, it takes 12 to Execute someones Ass. day 1 ends october 24th at 13:30 central US time; in (expired on 2020-10-24 13:30:00)
831: i have not provided information about how roles were assigned this game. there have been past games in the series (such as the first one) where mafia were given a role and forced to assign it to a member of the town
[/area]
So let’s start from here with what we know:
Gamma flipped Army. Assuming army scum. That’s the assumption I was working under last night. Combined with the cop Army is probably scum. Without this assumption is VCA useless as we don’t have a useful flip.
For the purposes of this “NT” is anything not town. This also will assume alignment claims other than town are honest.
Almost50 is 3P claim
Ban Hydras was town.
Nero is a 3P claim because Titus says so if I follow
Menalque was town.
Titus is claimed 3P.
Superbowl is claimed 3P
Norwegian is not Army.
This means the only possible army player on that wagon is Pickaxe Pete.
However this does also match the wagonomics I had earlier that NT were likely the main driver. It was just not the same alignment as gamma.
Ban all hydras has at most three people on it. Assume for a moment Army has a minimum of four members. It’s unlikely they all stack on a “counter wagon”. Therefore by necessity scum would be scattered.
Ban hydras dying also doesn’t make sense as a scum kill because this relies on the idea hydras was a counter wagon.
Based on what I have limited read day one Menal makes more sense as a vig shot because they seemed scummy to me. I took a brief look at their iso last night and their confidence of not dying is weird.
When I was reading Ban All Hydras they seemed a lot more a joking account and blending in and didn’t really follow what was going on with their wagon.
The main question is why the 3Ps gathered on Gamma and why Mastina hopped on later and who moved and why.
This was pretty much a done deal by this point from the thread vibe.
Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2020 3:35 pm
by superbowl9
In post 1521, Nero Cain wrote:im counting a50 and SB. Even if they do win with the town I feel like anything that's not TOWN is scum. There are those that say that a 3p that can win with town aren't scum but I don't really buy into that philosophy.
In post 1848, Nero Cain wrote:my thoughts on 3p always being scum despite being able to win with town are consistent throughout my time on site.
This leaves Morning Mage and Pickaxe Pete as only potential army on the wagon.
On the Ban all hydras wagon added Nero Sam and GE
Nero is 3P who floated between the wagons
GE was voting the biggest wagon other than himself.
So we’re left with Plus DS Christopher (who I think is Chemist) and Samantha (scully I think)
Rule of three says there’s likely a scum somewhere in this list.
However again none of these were really pushing the wagons iirc (please correct me if I am wrong)
Based on tone this didn’t seem like a scum driven wagon either.
So this game seems to be driven by NT players.
This jives with my 2-8 out of no where scum bus just it was NT.
Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2020 3:43 pm
by Tayl0r Swift
In post 3494, April Ludgate wrote:Yeah, but you were mocking a mock post, so it just made you come off like you weren’t mocking to them
so youre saying your massclaim suggestion was sarcastic?
In post 3506, MathBlade wrote:The main question is why the 3Ps gathered on Gamma and why Mastina hopped on later and who moved and why.
Why is this even a question?
If I believe both of our groups are against scum. So if we are against them why doesn't it make sense that we'd vote them?
I am saying you’re 3P. I understand the claim. I just am not sure I buy it. If you’re 3P aligned with town building the town should be your goal. I am just really suspicious that a majority of the 3P claims were on the wagon.
but if you are town you shouldn't be. When we lynched the rest of the kings army and the game is still ongoing then we can talk about lynching between our groups but if a50 is telling the truth then it won't.
I disagree, it just let’s you 3 non townies run the game. I’m not high key pushing for your fade or anything, but i do believe you guys should be harnessed.
A50 doesn’t know your alignment, so that doesn’t hold weight.
In post 3496, Almost50 wrote:I have no idea what you're talking about. I said explicitly that for all practical purposes we count as TOWN for the win cons of both Town and Scum.. so assuming you're town and your win con is to eliminate all threats to town my win is your win and vice versa, unless YOUR win con also states there has to be at least one "explicitly town" player alive.
I didn't check the town wincon before posting that because I am a lazy-ass. We are on the same page now.
scumslip VOTE: something_smart y'all
"i didn't check the TOWN wincon" as opposed to "i didn't check MY wincon"
Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2020 3:52 pm
by Tayl0r Swift
if you were scum in multiball with a neighborize ability (but maybe no factional kill), and you found out there was another group the same size as you claiming not to be a part of the town, would you neighborize them to investigate and see if you were both scum?
Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2020 3:53 pm
by MathBlade
In post 3519, Titus wrote:@Mathblade, You're running yourself ragged trying to avoid the conclusion scum were shopping for a counterwagon and failed.
Logically, gamma could not have been a planned bus because only Pickaxe Pete could be early army on the wagon.
If you read my post carefully I agree, planned bus was impossible based on claims. However I don’t see the evidence of a scum aiming for a counter wagon. I looked at the people on the wagon and a majority of the scum would have to be on Ban All Hydras.
I just don’t see that as viable based on my read.
Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2020 3:53 pm
by Titus
UNVOTE: SS
I don't think he's town per se but I don't want him accidentally eliminated before we solve Shelly.
Posted: Tue Oct 20, 2020 3:53 pm
by MathBlade
This reads as scum were inactive /useless at the time of the gamma wagon. Not a counter wagon.
